Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 51 of 54 ยท Projects and Practice

Practice problems with worked answers

Fourteen numerical meteorology problems on pressure, wind, moisture, storms, forecasting and climate, with a method, worked solutions and a code cell that checks every answer.

Reading about meteorology gives you the ideas; solving problems makes them stick. This lesson collects fourteen numerical problems that span the course: pressure and wind, moisture and lapse rates, storms, forecasting and probability, and climate. Each uses a formula you have already met. Try each problem on paper first, with units, before you look at the worked solution. A code cell at the end recomputes every answer so you can check yourself, and a short interactive checker lets you type in answers and see whether they are within tolerance.

Five numbered cards: read, units, formula, compute, check
Caption: A five-step method that works for almost every problem in the course: read, convert units, choose the formula, compute with units attached, and check that the answer has a sensible size.

What you will learn

  • Apply the five-step method to numerical meteorology problems.
  • Recognize which formula each type of problem needs.
  • Check an answer for plausible size and units.
  • Use code to verify hand calculations.

Key terms

SI units are meters, kilograms, seconds and pascals; convert hPa to Pa and km to m before using a formula. Plausibility check is comparing an answer with typical sizes: wind of 5 to 30 m/s, sea-level pressure of 950 to 1050 hPa, rain rates of 1 to 50 mm/h. Order of magnitude is the power of ten of an answer, a quick way to catch slips.

The method

  1. Read. What is asked, and what is given? Underline the numbers and their units.
  2. Units. Convert everything to SI: hPa to Pa (multiply by 100), km to m, hours to seconds.
  3. Formula. Write the formula in symbols before you put in any numbers.
  4. Compute. Substitute, keep the units attached, and round only at the end.
  5. Check. Is the size plausible? Would a forecaster believe it?

Useful constants and relations: ฮฉ = 7.292 ร— 10โปโต rad/s; f = 2 ฮฉ sin ฯ†; standard pressure p(z) = 1013.25 (1 โˆ’ 2.25577 ร— 10โปโต z)^5.25588 hPa with z in meters; dry lapse rate 9.8 K/km; LCL โ‰ˆ 125 (T โˆ’ Td) m; speed of sound about 343 m/s at 20 ยฐC; Z = 200 R^1.6.

The problems

Problem 1 (pressure). Using the standard-atmosphere formula, find the pressure at a mountain pass 3,000 m above sea level.

Problem 2 (pressure gradient force). The pressure falls 3 hPa over 150 km. With an air density of 1.1 kg/mยณ, find the pressure gradient force per unit mass.

Problem 3 (geostrophic wind). Isobars are 4 hPa apart and 200 km apart at 50ยฐ N. With ฯ = 1.2 kg/mยณ, find the geostrophic wind speed.

Problem 4 (Coriolis). Find the Coriolis parameter at 30ยฐ N.

Problem 5 (LCL). Surface temperature 25 ยฐC and dew point 13 ยฐC. Estimate the cloud base height for a parcel lifted from the surface.

Problem 6 (foehn). Air with T = 15 ยฐC and Td = 9 ยฐC crosses a 2,500 m ridge. Use a moist lapse rate of 6 K/km above the LCL and assume all condensed water falls out. Find the temperature at the crest and on the lee side at sea level.

Problem 7 (thunder). You count 12 seconds between a flash and the thunder. How far away is the lightning?

Problem 8 (return period). What is the chance that a 50-year flood occurs at least once in a 25-year period?

Problem 9 (ensemble). 14 of 40 ensemble members forecast more than 5 mm of rain. What probability should the forecast give?

Problem 10 (Brier score). A forecaster says 70 percent for rain. Find the Brier contribution for a day with rain and for a dry day.

Problem 11 (wind chill). Find the wind chill for an air temperature of 10 ยฐF and a wind of 20 mph, in ยฐF and ยฐC.

Problem 12 (bomb cyclone). A low at 50ยฐ N deepens by 24 hPa in 24 hours. What is the threshold at that latitude, and does the storm qualify as a bomb?

Problem 13 (radar). A radar shows a reflectivity of 45 dBZ. Use the Marshallโ€“Palmer relation to estimate the rain rate.

Problem 14 (heat index). Find the heat index for 95 ยฐF with 50 percent relative humidity, using the NWS regression from the floods and heat lesson.

Worked solutions

  1. p = 1013.25 ร— (1 โˆ’ 2.25577 ร— 10โปโต ร— 3000)^5.25588 = 1013.25 ร— 0.93232^5.25588, which is about 701 hPa, close to 70 percent of the sea-level value. Plausible: the pressure falls to 700 hPa near 3 km.
  2. PGF = (1/1.1) ร— 300 Pa / 150,000 m = 0.0018 m/sยฒ. Convert hPa to Pa and km to m first.
  3. f = 2 ร— 7.292e-5 ร— sin 50ยฐ = 1.117e-4 sโปยน. Gradient = 400 Pa / 200,000 m = 0.002 Pa/m. V_g = 0.002 / (1.2 ร— 1.117e-4) = about 14.9 m/s, about 29 knots.
  4. f = 2 ฮฉ sin 30ยฐ = ฮฉ = 7.292 ร— 10โปโต sโปยน, because sin 30ยฐ = 0.5.
  5. LCL โ‰ˆ 125 ร— (25 โˆ’ 13) = 1,500 m.
  6. LCL = 125 ร— 6 = 750 m. Temperature at LCL = 15 โˆ’ 9.8 ร— 0.75 = 7.65 ยฐC. At the crest: 7.65 โˆ’ 6 ร— (2.5 โˆ’ 0.75) = โˆ’2.85 ยฐC. Descend dry: โˆ’2.85 + 9.8 ร— 2.5 = 21.65 ยฐC, which is 6.65 ยฐC warmer than at the start.
  7. Sound travels about 343 m/s, so the distance is 12 ร— 343 = 4,116 m, about 4.1 km. The rule of thumb 12 / 3 = 4 km agrees.
  8. P = 1 โˆ’ (1 โˆ’ 1/50)ยฒโต = 1 โˆ’ 0.98ยฒโต = about 0.397, or 40 percent.
  9. 14 / 40 = 35 percent.
  10. If it rains: (0.7 โˆ’ 1)ยฒ = 0.09. If it stays dry: (0.7 โˆ’ 0)ยฒ = 0.49. Confident forecasts that miss are punished heavily.
  11. WC = 35.74 + 0.6215 T โˆ’ 35.75 V^0.16 + 0.4275 T V^0.16 with V^0.16 = 20^0.16 = 1.615. That gives about โˆ’8.9 ยฐF, which is โˆ’22.7 ยฐC. Check: colder than the 10 ยฐF air, as it should be.
  12. 24 ร— sin 50ยฐ / sin 60ยฐ = 24 ร— 0.766 / 0.866 = about 21.2 hPa. A 24 hPa fall exceeds it, so the storm qualifies as a bomb.
  13. Z = 10^(45/10) = 31,623. R = (31,623 / 200)^(1/1.6) = 158.1^0.625 = about 23.7 mm/h, a heavy rain.
  14. Substituting T = 95 and RH = 50 into the regression gives about 105 ยฐF, or 40.7 ยฐC. It feels about 10 ยฐF hotter than the air temperature.
Python Check all answers with code

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Type your answers and check them

Why problems go wrong

Most errors fall into a short list. Unit slips: using hPa where Pa is needed makes a result 100 times off. Sign slips: a pressure gradient force points toward low pressure. Wrong reference: the LCL formula uses the spread between temperature and dew point, not either one by itself. Rounding early: keep extra digits until the last step, especially for return periods and Brier scores. No sanity check: a wind of 150 m/s from a normal weather map should always prompt a second look.

Common misconceptions

"If the formula is right, the answer is right." Units and arithmetic slips are the commonest source of error; a plausibility check catches them. "Heat index and wind chill apply to any temperature." Each formula is only valid in a limited range. "A bomb cyclone threshold is the same at every latitude." It scales with the sine of latitude.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Before substituting numbers into the geostrophic wind formula you must convert

    The formula assumes SI units, so pressure must be in pascals and distance in meters.
  2. 2. The Coriolis parameter at 30 degrees latitude equals

    Since sin 30 degrees is 0.5, f = 2 Omega x 0.5 = Omega.
  3. 3. A forecaster says 70% and it does not rain. The Brier contribution is

    (0.7 - 0)^2 = 0.49.
  4. 4. Which is a sensible check on a computed sea-level pressure?

    Typical sea-level pressures lie in that range.
  5. 5. A 50-year flood over 25 years has a chance of about

    1 - 0.98^25 is about 0.40.

Summary

  • Use the five-step method: read, units, formula, compute, check.
  • Convert to SI first; keep units through the calculation.
  • Use plausible sizes to catch mistakes.
  • Verify with code when possible; the answer to every problem here is checked above.

Next: Glossary