Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 27 of 49 ยท Baroque to Romanticism

The Dutch Golden Age: art for a merchant republic

How a Protestant merchant republic created a market for portraits, interiors, landscapes and still lifes, with Rembrandt, Vermeer, Hals and Leyster.

In the 1600s a small, wet, newly independent country became one of the richest places in Europe, and its painters invented a new kind of art. They did not paint for popes or kings. They painted for brewers, merchants, magistrates and shopkeepers, who wanted pictures to hang over the fireplace. The result is a century of portraits, quiet household scenes, windswept landscapes and astonishingly detailed still lifes. This lesson explains the conditions that made that art, then looks at its great names and its hidden meanings.

What you will learn

  • Why the Dutch Republic produced a different art from Catholic Rome.
  • How the genres (portrait, genre scene, landscape, still life) fit together and how they were ranked.
  • What makes Rembrandt, Hals, Vermeer and Leyster individual.
  • How to read the symbolism of a vanitas still life.

Key terms

Genre painting: pictures of everyday life, such as a woman pouring milk or peasants drinking in a tavern.

Still life: a picture of arranged objects such as flowers, food, glass and silver.

Vanitas: a still life that reminds the viewer that life is short and worldly goods are fleeting; from the biblical phrase "vanity of vanities".

Tronie: a Dutch term for a head or face study of an interesting character or costume, not a portrait of a specific person.

Guild: an association of craftspeople. Painters in Dutch towns belonged to the Guild of Saint Luke.

A different kind of country

The northern provinces of the Netherlands rebelled against Spanish Habsburg rule from the 1560s and formed the Dutch Republic. Their independence was formally recognized by Spain in 1648, though the republic acted as a free state for decades before that. Amsterdam became a global port, and the Dutch East India Company (the VOC, founded in 1602) shipped spices, textiles and silver across the world. That wealth rested partly on colonial exploitation and the transatlantic slave trade, an uncomfortable fact that modern museums now include in their labels.

The official church was Calvinist. Calvinist services were plain, and altarpieces were not wanted in whitewashed churches. So the great source of work for painters in Catholic countries (the Church) largely disappeared. In its place came thousands of buyers who could afford a modest painting: town councils, militia companies, guilds, and well-off families. Visitors to the republic commented on how many ordinary households owned pictures, though we should be careful with exact numbers.

A pyramid of painting genres from history painting to still life beside a card explaining Dutch buyers' tastes
Caption: Theorists ranked history painting first and still life last, but Dutch buyers bought the lower genres in huge numbers.

The ranking on the left comes from academic theory, which valued subjects that needed learning and imagination. Dutch buyers ignored it. Painters specialized, one in seascapes, another in winter skating scenes, another in flower pieces, and sold on an open market, through dealers, auctions and even lotteries. A specialist could repeat a successful format efficiently.

Portraits: Hals and Rembrandt

Frans Hals (about 1582 to 1666) of Haarlem painted people who seem to be in the middle of a laugh. His brushwork is loose and visible: a few quick strokes of cream and gray make a lace collar. The Laughing Cavalier (1624) is a famous example, though the sitter was neither a cavalier nor, probably, laughing; the nickname is a later invention.

Rembrandt van Rijn (1606 to 1669) learned his trade in Leiden and moved to Amsterdam. His group portrait The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Nicolaes Tulp (1632) shows surgeons peering at a dissected arm, and made him famous in his twenties. His Night Watch (1642), a militia company portrait of Captain Frans Banninck Cocq and his men, turns a line-up into an event: the men are mid-march, with a girl in gold and drum and flag in motion. It is a huge canvas, about 3.6 by 4.4 meters, now in the Rijksmuseum. Despite the old story, there is no evidence that it caused his downfall. His bankruptcy in 1656 came from debts, an expensive house and a changing market.

Rembrandt also painted dozens of self-portraits across his career, so we can watch him age. Look at the way he uses light on the face while the clothing sinks into brown shadow. That borrowing from the Caravaggisti, softened into warm gold, is a kind of lighting you can recognise at once.

Judith Leyster (1609 to 1660) of Haarlem was a successful painter with her own workshop, who painted lively genre scenes and a self-portrait showing her at her easel. After her death she was largely forgotten and some of her works were attributed to Hals. In the 1890s a scholar found her monogram, a star pun on her name, on a painting that had been sold as a Hals, and her reputation was rebuilt.

Vermeer and the quiet room

Johannes Vermeer (1632 to 1675) of Delft produced very few paintings; about three dozen are generally accepted today. He painted women reading, pouring milk, weighing pearls, with light from a window at the left. The Milkmaid (c. 1657 to 1658) is a real person doing work, treated with the dignity of a saint. Girl with a Pearl Earring (c. 1665) is not a portrait of a named sitter but a tronie, a character study.

Vermeer's room paintings teach one of the most useful ideas in this course: how a picture constructs space. Lines running away from the viewer (the edges of a floor, a table, a window frame) converge at a vanishing point on the horizon line. In the Python demo below you can build a tiled floor in perspective and move the vanishing point. Scholars still debate whether Vermeer used a camera obscura (an optical projection device) as an aid. The paintings show light effects similar to those of lenses, but there is no document that proves it, so treat it as a lively debate, not a fact.

Python Build a Dutch floor in perspective

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Landscape, seascape and still life

Jacob van Ruisdael (1628 or 1629 to 1682) painted skies that fill two thirds of the canvas, with clouds heavy over low land. For a country that fought the sea with dikes and windmills, landscape was not merely scenery: it was a record of an ordered, hard-won land. Seascapes of merchant ships and naval battles reflected the source of national wealth.

Still life became a Dutch specialty. Willem Claesz. Heda and Pieter Claesz painted breakfast tables of silver, oysters and glass that show virtuoso control of reflections. Rachel Ruysch (1664 to 1750), a celebrated flower painter in Amsterdam and The Hague, built bouquets from flowers that bloom in different seasons. No real bouquet could ever hold them together, which tells you the picture is a collage of observation and wish.

Reading a vanitas

Many still lifes carry a moral. A vanitas says: enjoy the world but remember it will pass. The symbols are a repeating vocabulary, but remember that a skull or hourglass in a picture means something quite specific, while a lemon or a fly might be just a lemon or fly. Context decides.

Vanitas symbol decoder

Spain's Velazquez: a parallel Baroque

Diego Velazquez (1599 to 1660), painter to the Spanish court in Madrid, shows that the 17th century was not a single style. His Las Meninas (1656) is a puzzle about looking: the young Infanta Margarita and her attendants fill the foreground, the painter stands at a large canvas at the left, and a mirror at the back reflects the king and queen. Who is looking at whom? Scholars still argue about where the royal couple stand and what is being painted. It is a picture about painting itself, in a courtly rather than a merchant setting.

Common misconceptions

"The Night Watch is a night scene." It was named so because its varnish darkened with age. Cleaning revealed a daytime scene. Its title was not Rembrandt's.

"Dutch painters just copied what they saw." Their pictures are carefully composed. Interiors may be rearranged, flowers combined from different seasons, and a plain scene may hold moral advice.

"Vermeer was unknown until modern times." He was respected by some collectors in his lifetime. His reputation grew strongly after the 1860s, when a French critic championed his work.

Try it

Run the perspective demo and change vp_x and vp_y. Raise the horizon line and the floor appears to be seen from higher up. Then open the vanitas decoder and imagine a table with a skull, a snuffed candle and a pocket watch: what is the message?

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Why did Dutch painters rely on private buyers instead of the Church?

    Calvinist churches did not commission altarpieces, so artists sold to merchants, guilds, magistrates and households.
  2. 2. A tronie is:

    Girl with a Pearl Earring is a tronie, a character study, not a portrait of a known person.
  3. 3. What is the main purpose of a vanitas still life?

    Vanitas pictures pair luxury goods with symbols of death and time.
  4. 4. In one-point perspective, lines that recede from the viewer meet at:

    The orthogonals converge at a single vanishing point on the horizon line.
  5. 5. Whose rediscovered monogram helped restore her reputation after being sold as another painter's work?

    Judith Leyster's monogram was found on a painting that had been attributed to Frans Hals.

Summary

  • The Dutch Republic's Calvinist church and merchant wealth moved painting from altarpieces to homes and civic buildings.
  • Painters specialized in genres and sold on an open market; the wealth behind it included colonial exploitation.
  • Hals, Rembrandt, Leyster and Vermeer show different answers to portraiture and the quiet room.
  • Perspective, light and symbolism are the best tools for reading these pictures.
  • Vanitas still lifes use a vocabulary of objects to remind viewers of mortality.

Next: Rococo and Neoclassicism