Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 21 of 49 · Torsion

Indeterminate Shafts and Thin-Walled Tubes

Solve shafts fixed at both ends with compatibility of twist, then learn closed thin-walled tubes with shear flow and Bredt's formula τ = T/(2Aₘt), compared with open sections.

Two more cases complete the picture of torsion. The first repeats the logic of the axial chapter: a shaft fixed at both ends cannot be solved by statics alone, and the missing equation comes from the geometry of twist. The second is a different shape: a thin-walled tube, such as an aircraft fuselage skin or a box girder, which resists torque very differently depending on whether the section is closed or open.

A shaft fixed at both ends loaded by an intermediate torque, and a closed thin-walled tube cross-section with its mean area
Left: two unknown wall torques TA and TB. Right: a closed tube carries torque as a constant shear flow around the wall.

What you will learn

  • How to solve a shaft fixed at both ends.
  • The shear flow in a closed thin-walled tube and Bredt's formula.
  • How to find the angle of twist of a thin-walled tube.
  • Why an open thin section is far weaker in torsion than a closed one.

Key terms

Shear flow q: shear force per unit length of wall, q = τ t, constant around a closed thin-walled section in torsion.

Mean area Aₘ: the area enclosed by the centre line of the tube wall.

Closed section: a tube whose wall forms a complete loop.

Open section: a section with a slit or free edges, such as a channel or a slit tube.

Shafts fixed at both ends

A shaft fixed to walls at A and C, loaded with a torque T₀ at B. Treat it exactly like the axial bar between two walls:

  1. Equilibrium: TA + TB = T₀.
  2. Compatibility: the walls do not rotate, so the total twist from A to C is zero: φ_AB + φ_BC = 0.
  3. Torque-twist: TA a / (G J) − TB b / (G J) = 0 for a uniform shaft, giving TA a = TB b.

Solving: TA = T₀ b / (a + b) and TB = T₀ a / (a + b). The nearer wall takes more torque. For T₀ = 2 kN·m, a = 0.4 m and b = 0.6 m: TA = 2 × 0.6 / 1.0 = 1.2 kN·m and TB = 0.8 kN·m. Each segment can then be checked with τ = T R / J, and the twist of B is φ_B = TA a / (G J).

The same method handles a shaft with two different materials or diameters (use each G J) and a composite shaft where a tube is bonded over a rod: equal twist, so the torques share in proportion to G J.

Closed thin-walled tubes

For a closed section with a thin wall of thickness t, we assume the shear stress is uniform across the thickness and parallel to the wall. Equilibrium of a small slice of the wall shows that the shear flow q = τ t is constant around the loop. Taking moments of the shear flow about any point gives the torque:

T = 2 q Aₘ

where Aₘ is the area enclosed by the mid-line of the wall. Replacing q with τ t:

τ = T / (2 Aₘ t) (Bredt's formula)

The stress is largest where the wall is thinnest. The angle of twist per unit length follows from energy considerations:

φ = T L / (4 Aₘ² G) ∮ ds / t

For a circular tube of constant thickness the integral gives the circumference over t, which reduces to the familiar φ = T L / (G J) with J = 2π r³ t.

Example. A circular tube with mean radius r = 40 mm and wall thickness t = 3 mm carries T = 1.5 kN·m. Then Aₘ = π × 40² = 5027 mm² and

τ = 1.5 × 10⁶ / (2 × 5027 × 3) = 49.7 MPa.

Why closed beats open

Cut a lengthwise slit in that same tube. The section is now open, and the shear flow can no longer circulate around the loop; the wall behaves like a thin strip that is twisted. For a thin strip of length b (the developed length) and thickness t, τ ≈ 3 T / (b t²). With b = 2π × 40 = 251 mm and the same torque:

τ ≈ 3 × 1.5 × 10⁶ / (251.3 × 9) = 1990 MPa

about 40 times the stress of the closed tube, and the twist is far larger too (it scales with 1 / t³). This is a classic result and the reason a slit pipe, an I-beam or a channel twists so easily: use box or tube sections where torsion matters.

Python Fixed-fixed shaft and closed versus open tube

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Move the torque along the shaft (interactive)

Common misconceptions

"A tube and a slit tube twist the same." A slit destroys the closed loop and reduces torsional stiffness by a factor of order (t / r)², here about 1/1000 or less.

"In a thin tube the stress is highest where the wall is thick." τ = T / (2 Aₘ t) is highest at the thinnest part, because shear flow is constant and τ = q / t.

"The wall torque is shared equally in an indeterminate shaft." It is shared in inverse proportion to the segment length (for equal G J): the nearer wall carries more.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 · perfect!

  1. 1. A uniform shaft fixed at both ends has a torque T₀ at distance a from A and b from C. TA equals…

    From TA a = TB b and TA + TB = T₀, TA = T₀ b / (a + b).
  2. 2. What is constant around a closed thin-walled section in torsion?

    Equilibrium of a wall slice gives a constant shear flow q.
  3. 3. A circular tube has mean radius 40 mm, t = 3 mm and carries 1.5 kN·m. Bredt's formula gives about…

    Aₘ = π × 40² = 5027 mm², τ = 1.5 × 10⁶ / (2 × 5027 × 3) = 49.7 MPa.
  4. 4. Why is a slit tube so weak in torsion?

    Without a closed loop the wall acts like a thin strip, giving high stress and large twist.
  5. 5. In Bredt's formula, Aₘ is…

    Aₘ is the area bounded by the centre line of the wall thickness.

Summary

  • A shaft fixed at both ends needs equilibrium (TA + TB = T₀) plus compatibility (total twist zero).
  • Closed thin-walled tubes carry a constant shear flow: T = 2 q Aₘ, τ = T / (2 Aₘ t).
  • Twist of a closed tube: φ = T L / (4 Aₘ² G) ∮ ds / t.
  • Open thin sections are dramatically weaker and more flexible in torsion than closed ones.

Next: Chapter 4 Review