Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 14 of 49 · Axial Loading

Statically Indeterminate Axial Members

Solve bars fixed between two walls and composite bars of two materials using equilibrium, compatibility and force-deformation relations, with worked numerical examples.

So far every unknown force could be found from equilibrium alone. Then you meet a bar fixed to a wall at both ends with a load in the middle. There are two unknown wall reactions but only one useful equation (ΣF = 0 along the axis). Statics cannot solve it. Such problems are statically indeterminate, and the way out is to look at the geometry of deformation.

A bar fixed between two walls with a load at B, with the equilibrium and compatibility equations and a four-step recipe
Two unknown reactions RA and RB; equilibrium gives RA + RB = P, compatibility gives the second equation.

What you will learn

  • Why some problems cannot be solved by statics alone.
  • The three-part recipe: equilibrium, compatibility, force-deformation.
  • How to solve a bar between two walls.
  • How to solve a composite bar of two materials.

Key terms

Statically indeterminate: more unknown forces than independent equilibrium equations.

Degree of indeterminacy: the number of extra unknowns.

Compatibility equation: a geometric condition on displacements, such as "the total length cannot change".

Composite bar: a bar made of two or more materials acting together.

The recipe

  1. Equilibrium. Write all the equilibrium equations you can.
  2. Compatibility. Write a condition on the deformations that the supports and connections enforce.
  3. Force-deformation. Replace each deformation using δ = N L / (A E).
  4. Solve the resulting equations together, then compute stresses and check.

You supply as many compatibility conditions as the degree of indeterminacy. A bar fixed at both ends is one degree indeterminate: one extra condition.

Example 1: a bar between two walls

A uniform bar (A = 500 mm², E = 200 GPa) is fixed to rigid walls at A and C and loaded by P = 60 kN at B, where AB = a = 300 mm and BC = b = 500 mm.

Equilibrium: RA + RB = P. (Both walls resist the load.)

Compatibility: the walls do not move, so the total length is unchanged: δ_AB + δ_BC = 0. The force in AB is a tension N_AB = RA; the force in BC is a compression N_BC = −RB.

Force-deformation: RA a / (A E) − RB b / (A E) = 0, so RA a = RB b.

Solve: substitute RA = RB b / a into RA + RB = P:

RB = P a / (a + b) = 60 × 300 / 800 = 22.5 kN, RA = P b / (a + b) = 37.5 kN.

Stresses: σ_AB = 37 500 / 500 = +75 MPa (tension) and σ_BC = −22 500 / 500 = −45 MPa (compression). Displacement of B: δ_B = RA a / (A E) = 37 500 × 300 / (500 × 200 000) = 0.1125 mm, towards C.

The shorter portion AB carries the larger share of the load because it is stiffer: indeterminate structures send force along the stiffest path. This is a deep idea. It explains why stiff members attract load, why a rigid wall draws load from a flexible one, and why a bad estimate of stiffness gives a wrong estimate of force.

Example 2: a composite bar

A short concrete column is reinforced with steel bars and carries P = 400 kN through a rigid cap, so both materials shorten equally. Steel: A_s = 1200 mm², E_s = 200 GPa. Concrete: A_c = 40 000 mm², E_c = 25 GPa.

Equilibrium: F_s + F_c = P.

Compatibility: equal strain (or equal shortening of equal lengths): F_s / (A_s E_s) = F_c / (A_c E_c).

The ratio is F_s / F_c = (A_s E_s) / (A_c E_c) = (1200 × 200 000) / (40 000 × 25 000) = 0.24.

So F_s = 400 × 0.24 / 1.24 = 77.4 kN and F_c = 322.6 kN. The stresses are σ_s = 77 420 / 1200 = 64.5 MPa and σ_c = 322 580 / 40 000 = 8.06 MPa. Steel is stressed eight times as much as the concrete (the ratio of the moduli, 200 / 25 = 8), but it carries only a fifth of the load because there is so little of it.

Python Solve the two indeterminate examples

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Slide the load along a fixed-fixed bar (interactive)

Common misconceptions

"Reactions split equally between two supports." They split in inverse proportion to the segment lengths for a uniform bar, so the closer wall takes more.

"Compatibility is a new law of physics." It is only geometry: parts that are connected must move together without gaps or overlaps.

"Indeterminate problems are rare." Most real structures are indeterminate; redundancy is a safety feature because load can find another path.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 · perfect!

  1. 1. A bar fixed at both ends and loaded axially in the middle has how many equilibrium equations (axial direction)?

    Only ΣF = 0 along the axis helps; with RA and RB both unknown the problem is indeterminate.
  2. 2. In the recipe, the compatibility equation expresses…

    It states how the deformations must fit together, such as total length unchanged.
  3. 3. For a uniform bar between walls with P at B (a = 300, b = 500 mm), what is RB?

    RB = P a / (a + b) = 60 × 300 / 800 = 22.5 kN.
  4. 4. In a composite column of steel and concrete under a rigid cap, the stiffer material…

    Equal strain with a larger E gives a larger stress, σ = E ε.
  5. 5. Doubling the area of the steel in the composite column would…

    The steel's share is A_s E_s / (A_s E_s + A_c E_c), which grows when A_s grows.

Summary

  • Indeterminate problems need equilibrium, compatibility and force-deformation relations.
  • A bar between two walls splits the load in inverse proportion to segment length; stiffer paths attract force.
  • In composites with equal strain, force shares are proportional to A E.
  • Check by verifying that the deformations fit.

Next: Thermal Stress