Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 46 of 49 ยท Projects and Practice

Practice set: ten mixed problems

Ten mixed strength of materials problems on bending, shear, eccentric loads, Mohr's circle, von Mises, deflection, buckling and fatigue, with answers and a checker.

Reading about a method is not the same as being able to use it. This lesson gives you ten problems that mix the chapters of the second half of the course, plus a small answer checker. Try each problem with pencil and paper first, then compare. Use N, mm and MPa throughout, and take E = 200 GPa for steel unless the problem says otherwise.

A six-step problem-solving checklist and a card with typical material values for sanity checks.
The same habits solve every problem: sketch, find forces, compute stress, choose the criterion, convert units, sanity-check.

What you will learn

  • How to recognize which chapter's method a mixed problem needs.
  • How to check a result against a sensible size.
  • How to avoid the common slips: units, sign, wrong axis, wrong formula.

How to use this set

  • Draw a sketch and a free-body diagram for every problem, even when it seems unnecessary.
  • Write the formula first, then the numbers with units, then the answer.
  • Round only at the end. Answers are given to three significant figures.

The problems

  1. Beam bending. A simply supported beam of span 4 m carries a uniform load of 15 kN/m. Its section is a rectangle 80 mm wide and 160 mm deep. Find the maximum bending stress.
  2. Cantilever. A cantilever 1.2 m long carries a 3 kN load at its free end. The section is a solid round bar of diameter 60 mm. Find the maximum bending stress at the wall.
  3. Shear in a rectangle. A rectangular beam 60 mm ร— 120 mm carries a shear force of 18 kN. Find the maximum shear stress.
  4. Shear in a T-section. The T-section of Chapter 5 (flange 120 ร— 20 mm, web 20 ร— 100 mm, I = 5.674 ร— 10โถ mmโด, centroid 82.7 mm above the bottom) carries V = 12 kN. Find the shear stress at the neutral axis, where the web width is 20 mm.
  5. Eccentric load. A square column 120 mm ร— 120 mm carries a compressive load of 60 kN acting 15 mm from the centroid, along one axis. Find the stress on the two faces (negative for compression).
  6. Principal stresses. A plane stress state has ฯƒx = 60, ฯƒy = โˆ’20, ฯ„xy = 40 MPa. Find ฯƒ1, ฯƒ2, the maximum in-plane shear stress and the principal angle ฮธp.
  7. Von Mises. For the stress state of problem 6 and a steel with ฯƒy = 250 MPa, find the von Mises equivalent stress and the factor of safety against yielding.
  8. Deflection. An aluminum cantilever (E = 70 GPa) of length 1.5 m with I = 8 ร— 10โถ mmโด carries a 2 kN load at its tip. Find the tip deflection.
  9. Buckling. A solid round steel column of diameter 30 mm and length 1 m is pinned at both ends. Find the Euler critical load. What is it if both ends are fixed?
  10. Fatigue. A steel part has ฯƒu = 600 MPa and a working endurance limit Se = 200 MPa. In service it sees a stress amplitude ฯƒa = 90 MPa on top of a mean stress ฯƒm = 80 MPa. Find the factor of safety with the modified Goodman line.

Answers and key steps

Try to solve them yourself before reading on.

  1. Mmax = wLยฒ/8 = 15 ร— 16/8 = 30 kNยทm; S = bhยฒ/6 = 80 ร— 160ยฒ/6 = 341.3 ร— 10ยณ mmยณ; ฯƒ = 30 ร— 10โถ/341.3 ร— 10ยณ = 87.9 MPa.
  2. M = PยทL = 3000 ร— 1200 = 3.6 ร— 10โถ Nยทmm; ฯƒ = 32M/(ฯ€dยณ) = 32 ร— 3.6 ร— 10โถ/(ฯ€ ร— 216 000) = 170 MPa.
  3. ฯ„max = 1.5ยทV/A = 1.5 ร— 18 000/7200 = 3.75 MPa.
  4. Q = 20 ร— 82.7ยฒ/2 = 68.4 ร— 10ยณ mmยณ (the web below the neutral axis); ฯ„ = VQ/(Ib) = 12 000 ร— 68.4 ร— 10ยณ/(5.674 ร— 10โถ ร— 20) = 7.24 MPa.
  5. A = 14 400 mmยฒ, so P/A = 4.17 MPa; M = 60 000 ร— 15 = 0.9 ร— 10โถ Nยทmm; S = 120ยณ/6 = 288 ร— 10ยณ mmยณ gives M/S = 3.13 MPa. Near face โˆ’7.29 MPa, far face โˆ’1.04 MPa. Both are compressive because e = 15 mm is less than h/6 = 20 mm.
  6. C = 20 MPa, R = โˆš(40ยฒ + 40ยฒ) = 56.6 MPa: ฯƒ1 = 76.6 MPa, ฯƒ2 = โˆ’36.6 MPa, ฯ„max = 56.6 MPa, tan 2ฮธp = 2 ร— 40/80 = 1, so ฮธp = 22.5ยฐ.
  7. ฯƒe = โˆš(ฯƒxยฒ โˆ’ ฯƒxฯƒy + ฯƒyยฒ + 3ฯ„xyยฒ) = โˆš(3600 + 1200 + 400 + 4800) = โˆš10 000 = 100 MPa; n = 250/100 = 2.5.
  8. ฮด = PLยณ/(3EI) = 2000 ร— 1500ยณ/(3 ร— 70 000 ร— 8 ร— 10โถ) = 4.02 mm.
  9. I = ฯ€ ร— 30โด/64 = 39.76 ร— 10ยณ mmโด; Pcr = ฯ€ยฒEI/Lยฒ = 9.87 ร— 200 000 ร— 39 760/1000ยฒ = 78.5 kN; with fixed ends (K = 0.5) it is four times larger, 314 kN.
  10. ฯƒa/Se + ฯƒm/ฯƒu = 90/200 + 80/600 = 0.45 + 0.133 = 0.583, so n = 1/0.583 = 1.71.

Common mistakes to look for in your own work

  • Units. Mixing kNยทm with mmโด (problems 1, 2, 5) gives answers wrong by a factor of 1000.
  • Wrong axis. In problem 9 a round section has the same I about every axis, but a rectangle does not: use the smaller one.
  • Missing ฯƒ3 = 0. In Tresca checks of plane stress, always include the zero stress in the third direction.
  • Using the full width in ฯ„ = VQ/(Ib). Use the width where you evaluate the stress (problem 4).
  • Forgetting that shear is shared in double shear. Each plane carries half the force.

Try it

The answer checker below has ten input boxes. Type your answers (in the units shown) and press Check. A result within 2% counts as correct.

Answer checker

The second TryIt solves all ten problems with code, so you can see where each number comes from and rerun them with your own data.

Python All ten solutions in code

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. In problem 5, why are both faces in compression?

    The bending stress (3.13 MPa) is smaller than the axial stress (4.17 MPa), so no tension appears.
  2. 2. Problem 8 uses aluminum. If steel (E = 200 GPa) were used instead, the tip deflection would be...

    Deflection scales with 1/E: 4.02 ร— 70/200 = 1.41 mm.
  3. 3. Which problem number needs the radius of the section only through I = ฯ€dโด/64 and the formula Pcr = ฯ€ยฒEI/Lยฒ?

    Problem 9, Euler buckling of a round column.
  4. 4. A student gets 87 900 MPa in problem 1. What is the most likely mistake?

    A factor of 1000 almost always means a unit slip.

Summary

  • Mixed problems test whether you can choose the right method: bending, shear, combined loads, Mohr's circle, a failure criterion, deflection, buckling or fatigue.
  • Work in N, mm, MPa; draw a sketch; write the formula before the numbers.
  • Check each answer for size and sign: if it is off by exactly 1000, suspect a unit slip.
  • Keep a list of your own mistakes. They repeat.

Next: Glossary