Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 35 of 47 · Foundations and Soils

Footings, settlement and retaining walls

Size spread footings, check eccentricity and the kern, estimate immediate and consolidation settlement, and check retaining walls against overturning, sliding and bearing.

Bearing capacity tells you the soil will not collapse. It does not tell you how far the building will sink, or whether a wall holding back a bank will slide away. This lesson turns to the everyday work of foundation design: sizing footings so the soil pressure is acceptable, estimating settlement and checking a retaining wall for the three ways it can fail.

Soil pressure under three eccentrically loaded footings and the earth pressure on a retaining wall
Caption: Left, the soil pressure grows on one side as the load moves off-center. Right, earth pushes the wall with a triangular pressure whose resultant acts at a third of the height.

What you will learn

  • How to size a footing from a service load and an allowable pressure.
  • Eccentricity, the middle third and the pressure formula.
  • How to estimate immediate and consolidation settlement.
  • The overturning, sliding and bearing checks for a retaining wall.

Key terms

Allowable bearing pressure qall: the pressure that gives acceptable safety and settlement.

Kern (middle third): the central part of a footing within which the load resultant keeps the whole base in compression.

Consolidation: slow compression of saturated clay as pore water drains.

Rankine coefficient Ka: ratio of horizontal to vertical effective stress in the active state.

Differential settlement: unequal settlement between neighboring footings.

Sizing a spread footing

For a first size, use service (unfactored) loads and the allowable pressure:

Text
A_required = P / qall        (square footing: B = √A)

For P = 800 kN and qall = 200 kPa: A = 4 m², so B = 2.0 m. The footing's own weight and the soil above it are often included in the load or deducted from qall as a net pressure. After deciding on plan size, the thickness and reinforcement are designed as a reinforced concrete member using factored loads (the earlier chapter): it bends like a cantilever projecting from the column face, and it must resist one-way shear at d from the column and punching shear at d/2 around the column.

Eccentric loads

If a column also carries a moment M, the resultant is off-center by e = M/P. For a rectangular footing of length B in the direction of eccentricity, the soil pressure at the two edges is

Text
q = (P / A) (1 ± 6e / B)

When e ≤ B/6 the load lies in the middle third and the base is wholly in compression, shaped as a trapezoid (the left and center of the picture). At e = B/6 the pressure at one edge reaches zero. Beyond B/6 the footing would lift off, and the contact area is reduced so that the pressure triangle is 3(B/2 − e) long and its peak is 2P / (3 (B/2 − e) × width). Engineers avoid this, and resist wind and earthquake overturning with wider footings or tie beams.

Settlement

Immediate settlement

On sands and in the first moments of loading on clays, the soil compresses elastically:

Text
Si = q B (1 − ν²) Iw / Es

where q is the net pressure, B the width, ν Poisson's ratio, Es the soil modulus and Iw an influence factor depending on shape and rigidity (about 0.82 for a rigid square footing). With q = 200 kPa, B = 2 m, Es = 20 MPa, ν = 0.3: Si = 200 × 2 × 0.91 × 0.82 / 20,000 = 0.015 m = 15 mm.

Consolidation settlement

For a saturated clay layer of thickness H, the final settlement from drainage of pore water is

Text
Sc = Cc H / (1 + e0) × log10( (σ′0 + Δσ′) / σ′0 )

where Cc is the compression index from an oedometer test, e0 the initial void ratio, σ′0 the initial effective stress at mid-layer and Δσ′ the added stress from the building (spread out with depth, about the 2:1 rule). For Cc = 0.30, H = 3 m, e0 = 0.90, σ′0 = 60 kPa, Δσ′ = 40 kPa:

Text
Sc = 0.30 × 3 / 1.9 × log10(100/60) = 0.105 m ≈ 105 mm

Terzaghi's one-dimensional theory also predicts the time: it depends on the drainage path (the layer thickness squared) and on the coefficient of consolidation cv, so a thick clay layer can keep settling for years.

How much is too much?

Tolerable settlement depends on the structure. Total settlement of 25 mm is a common limit for isolated footings on sand and 50 mm for rafts. More important is the angular distortion between neighbors, the differential settlement divided by the distance: cracking in panel walls begins near 1/300, and structural damage near 1/150 (Skempton and MacDonald's observations in 1956).

Retaining walls

A retaining wall holds back soil. The soil pushes the wall with an earth pressure that grows with depth. In the active state (the wall moves slightly away from the soil) the Rankine coefficient for a level, cohesionless backfill is

Text
Ka = tan²(45° − φ/2) = (1 − sin φ)/(1 + sin φ)

For φ = 30°: Ka = 1/3. The pressure at depth z is σh = Ka γ z, a triangle, and the resultant over a height H is

Text
Pa = ½ Ka γ H²   acting at H/3 above the base

For a 4 m wall with γ = 18 kN/m³: Pa = 0.5 × (1/3) × 18 × 16 = 48 kN/m, acting 1.33 m above the base, giving an overturning moment of 64 kN·m per metre of wall.

The checks

  1. Overturning: FS = ΣM resisting / ΣM overturning ≥ 2, about the toe.
  2. Sliding: FS = μ ΣV / Pa ≥ 1.5, with μ = tan δ of the base (about tan(2φ/3) for concrete on soil).
  3. Bearing: the resultant should lie in the middle third of the base, and the toe pressure qmax = (ΣV/B)(1 + 6e/B) must not exceed qall.
  4. Drainage: water behind a wall can double the load. Provide a drain, weep holes and free-draining backfill.

Example

A gravity wall (4 m high) weighs 150 kN/m acting 1.5 m from the toe. Overturning: Mr = 150 × 1.5 = 225 kN·m against Mo = 64: FS = 3.5. Sliding with μ = tan 20° = 0.364: 0.364 × 150 / 48 = 1.14 < 1.5. The wall tips safely but slides. Remedies: a wider base with soil over the heel (adding vertical load), a shear key into the soil, or a sloping base. Adding a 60 kN/m heel soil weight at a 2.0 m arm gives ΣV = 210 kN/m, FS(sliding) = 1.59, and the resultant lies within the middle third.

Common misconceptions

"If bearing is fine, settlement is fine." A clay can have a high safety factor against failure and still settle 100 mm over ten years.

"Active pressure is the maximum possible." Active pressure is the minimum, reached after a small movement. A stiff wall that cannot move feels the at-rest pressure, K0 ≈ 1 − sin φ, which is larger.

"Water behind the wall is a detail." Poor drainage is the leading cause of retaining wall failures.

Try it

Python Retaining wall stability

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Python Settlement of a clay layer over time

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 · perfect!

  1. 1. A footing carries P = 600 kN at qall = 150 kPa. What square width is needed?

    A = 600/150 = 4 m², B = 2 m.
  2. 2. The middle third rule says the load resultant should lie within

    For e ≤ B/6 the whole base is in compression.
  3. 3. Active earth pressure for φ = 30° gives Ka of

    Ka = (1 − sin 30°)/(1 + sin 30°) = 0.5/1.5 = 1/3.
  4. 4. Where does the Rankine resultant Pa act on a wall of height H?

    The triangular pressure has its centroid at one third of the height.
  5. 5. Which settlement is slow and happens in saturated clay as water drains?

    Consolidation needs pore water to leave the clay.

Summary

  • Size footings with A = P/qall, then design the concrete for flexure, one-way shear and punching shear.
  • Keep load in the middle third; pressure is (P/A)(1 ± 6e/B).
  • Settlement has an immediate part and a consolidation part; differential settlement matters most.
  • Retaining walls: Ka, Pa = ½ Ka γ H² at H/3; check overturning (≥ 2), sliding (≥ 1.5), bearing and drainage.

Next: Chapter 7 review