Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 47 ยท Faults and Protection

Symmetrical components

Learn Fortescue's method: split unbalanced three-phase voltages and currents into positive, negative and zero sequence sets, with worked examples and a live calculator.

A balanced three-phase system is easy: analyze one phase and the other two follow by a 120ยฐ shift. A fault usually destroys that balance. A single line-to-ground fault loads one phase and leaves the other two alone, so the usual one-line method no longer applies. In 1918 Charles Fortescue showed that any unbalanced set of three phasors can be written as the sum of three balanced sets, called symmetrical components. Each balanced set can then be analyzed with the single-phase tools you already have, and the answers are added back together.

This is the standard language of fault analysis and relay design. Once you see why it works, unbalanced faults become a recipe: draw three networks, connect them in the way the fault dictates, solve one loop.

Three unbalanced phasors Va, Vb, Vc equal the sum of a positive sequence set, a negative sequence set and a zero sequence set
Unbalanced phasors (left) are the sum of three balanced sets (right): positive, negative and zero sequence.

What you will learn

  • Define the operator a and write the transformation between phase and sequence quantities.
  • Describe positive, negative and zero sequence sets and what physical effect each has.
  • Decompose a given unbalanced set by hand and with code.
  • Explain why the neutral current equals 3ยทI0 and why sequence impedances differ.

Key terms

Positive sequence (1): three equal-magnitude phasors 120ยฐ apart in the normal order a, b, c.

Negative sequence (2): three equal-magnitude phasors 120ยฐ apart in the reverse order a, c, b.

Zero sequence (0): three equal phasors in phase with each other.

Operator a: the complex number 1โˆ 120ยฐ that rotates a phasor by 120ยฐ.

Sequence impedance: the impedance a piece of equipment offers to one sequence set (Z1, Z2, Z0).

The operator a and the three sets

Define a = 1โˆ 120ยฐ = โˆ’0.5 + j0.866. Multiplying a phasor by a rotates it 120ยฐ counterclockwise; aยฒ = 1โˆ 240ยฐ = 1โˆ โˆ’120ยฐ, and aยณ = 1. A very useful identity follows from adding three equally spaced unit vectors:

Text
1 + a + aยฒ = 0

Now take phase a as the reference. The three sets are:

Set Phase a Phase b Phase c Rotates as
Positive V1 aยฒยทV1 aยทV1 a, b, c (normal)
Negative V2 aยทV2 aยฒยทV2 a, c, b (reverse)
Zero V0 V0 V0 all equal

Adding the three sets gives the actual phase voltages:

Text
Va = V0 + V1 + V2
Vb = V0 + aยฒยทV1 + aยทV2
Vc = V0 + aยทV1 + aยฒยทV2

Three unknowns (V0, V1, V2) and three equations: they can be solved. Using 1 + a + aยฒ = 0 the inverse is:

Text
V0 = (Va + Vb + Vc) / 3
V1 = (Va + aยทVb + aยฒยทVc) / 3
V2 = (Va + aยฒยทVb + aยทVc) / 3

The same formulas hold for currents. The zero-sequence component is simply the average of the three phasors. For a perfectly balanced set the average is zero, so V0 = V2 = 0 and V1 = Va. The more unbalanced the set, the larger V2 and V0 become, which is why the ratio V2/V1 is used as a voltage unbalance factor.

A worked decomposition

A simple case first. A fault leaves current only in phase a: Ia = 90 A, Ib = Ic = 0. Then

Text
I0 = (90 + 0 + 0)/3 = 30 A
I1 = (90 + aยท0 + aยฒยท0)/3 = 30 A
I2 = 30 A

All three sequence currents are equal to one third of the fault current. That is the signature of a single line-to-ground fault: I0 = I1 = I2 = Ia/3. The current in the neutral or ground is In = Ia + Ib + Ic = 3ยทI0 = 90 A.

Zero-sequence current is the only component that can flow through the neutral or the earth, because it is the only one that adds up instead of cancelling. Neutral current is 3ยทI0. Wherever there is no neutral or ground path (for example a delta winding or an ungrounded wye), I0 cannot flow.

For a less obvious case, take the phasors drawn in the figure: Va = 1โˆ 0ยฐ, Vb = 0.8โˆ โˆ’110ยฐ, Vc = 0.9โˆ 125ยฐ per unit. The runnable example below gives the three components and verifies that they add back to the original set.

Why sequences behave differently

The decomposition is useful only because equipment treats each set differently, and each set sees a simple single-phase network.

  • Rotating machines. Positive-sequence currents make a field that rotates with the rotor, so the machine responds with its synchronous, transient or subtransient reactance, X1. Negative-sequence currents make a field that rotates against the rotor at twice the speed relative to it, so the machine sees a smaller, roughly constant X2 (close to the subtransient reactance X''d). Zero-sequence currents produce no net rotating field: X0 is smallest.
  • Transformers and static equipment do not care which way the phases are ordered: Z1 = Z2. For a transformer Z0 is also about the same as Z1, but only if a path for zero-sequence current exists. A grounded-wye to delta transformer lets zero-sequence current flow on the wye side and circulates it inside the delta; a delta bank on the other side stops it from going further.
  • Transmission lines. Z1 = Z2 again. Z0 is larger because the zero-sequence current returns through the earth and ground wires: for overhead lines a typical Z0 is between two and four times Z1.

The network drawn for each sequence therefore has the same structure as the positive one, with its own impedance values:

Text
Positive:  V1 = Ea โˆ’ Z1ยทI1       (the only network with a source)
Negative:  V2 =    โˆ’ Z2ยทI2
Zero:      V0 =    โˆ’ (Z0 + 3Zn)ยทI0

The generator emf Ea only appears in the positive network, because the machine only generates a balanced positive set. A neutral impedance Zn appears as 3Zn in the zero-sequence network, since 3ยทI0 flows through it.

Power in sequence components

Complex power is the same whether you work in phase or sequence quantities: S = VaยทIa* + VbยทIb* + VcยทIc* = 3(V0ยทI0* + V1ยทI1* + V2ยทI2*). The factor 3 is the price of defining components with a 1/3 average. Some books scale the transformation by 1/โˆš3 so that power is invariant without the 3.

Common misconceptions

"Sequence components are physical currents." They are a calculation device. You cannot put an ammeter on I2. Only phase currents (and 3ยทI0 in the neutral) can be measured directly, although relays compute I2 and I0 internally.

"Negative sequence means negative current." It means a set rotating in the reverse order. The magnitudes are positive numbers.

"Zero sequence is the same as DC." It is a set of three 50 or 60 Hz phasors that are equal, so it is an AC quantity.

Try it

The first example decomposes the phasors from the figure, verifies the reconstruction and checks the single-line-to-ground case. Everything is computed with complex numbers.

Python Decompose an unbalanced set

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The second example is a live calculator. Drag the magnitude and angle of phases b and c (phase a is fixed at 1โˆ 0ยฐ). The balanced setting (1โˆ โˆ’120ยฐ and 1โˆ 120ยฐ) gives zero V0 and V2.

Sequence calculator

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What is the value of 1 + a + a^2?

    The three unit phasors at 0, 120 and 240 degrees are symmetric and add to zero.
  2. 2. A set of currents is Ia = 60 A, Ib = 0, Ic = 0. What is the zero sequence current I0?

    I0 is the average of the three phase currents: (60 + 0 + 0)/3 = 20 A.
  3. 3. Which sequence set can flow in the neutral of a wye connection?

    Only zero-sequence currents add in the neutral (In = 3 I0); positive and negative sets sum to zero.
  4. 4. Which statement about sequence impedances of a static transmission line is correct?

    Static equipment does not care about phase order, so Z1 = Z2; zero-sequence current returns through earth, which raises Z0.
  5. 5. Why does the generator emf appear only in the positive sequence network?

    A synchronous generator's internal emf is balanced and in positive order; unbalance only arises from the fault or load.

Summary

  • Any unbalanced three-phase set equals a positive, a negative and a zero sequence set: Va = V0 + V1 + V2, and so on.
  • The operator a = 1โˆ 120ยฐ gives the transformation; V0 is the average and 1 + a + aยฒ = 0.
  • Neutral current equals 3ยทI0; a delta or an ungrounded wye blocks zero-sequence current.
  • Static equipment has Z1 = Z2; rotating machines have different X1, X2, X0; line Z0 is typically larger than Z1.
  • The generator source exists only in the positive network.

Next: Fault types and fault current calculation