Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 42 of 47 ยท Legal Reasoning and Practice

Chapter 8 review: Legal reasoning

Review cases, precedent, statutory interpretation and IRAC with a one-page picture, a recap table and a ten-question mixed quiz.

You now have the tools lawyers use: reading cases, reading statutes and structuring an answer. This review pulls them together, so that you can apply them in the projects and practice sets of the final chapter.

Three cards: cases, statutes and IRAC
Find the rule, read it carefully, apply it fairly.

What you will learn

  • A summary of the three skills
  • How they combine when you work on a problem

Recap table

Skill Key ideas
Cases Ratio decidendi binds; obiter dicta persuades; higher courts bind lower ones; follow, distinguish, overrule
Statutes Read the structure; literal, golden, mischief, purposive; aids such as Hansard; Latin canons
IRAC Issue, rule, application (both sides), conclusion with confidence

Working them together

Imagine a problem about a park rule. First, identify the issue: is a bicycle a "vehicle" under the rule? Second, find the rule: the statute's words, then any cases interpreting similar words. Third, interpret: a literal reading may catch the bicycle; a purposive reading may not. Fourth, check precedent: is there a binding case about the same word? If so, follow or distinguish it. Fifth, apply with arguments on both sides and conclude with a level of confidence. These steps repeat in every area of law.

Try it

Chapter 8 flashcards
JS Choose the approach

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which part of a judgment binds later courts?

    The ratio.
  2. 2. A High Court decision in England is:

    It binds downward only.
  3. 3. Which approach was used in Smith v Hughes (1960)?

    The court looked at the mischief of nuisance in the street.
  4. 4. The US term for following precedent is:

    To stand by decisions.
  5. 5. In IRAC, the Application step should:

    It is the reasoning step.
  6. 6. 'Ejusdem generis' helps to interpret:

    It takes meaning from the list.
  7. 7. Distinguishing a precedent means:

    The precedent remains good law.
  8. 8. Which is a feature of a strong conclusion?

    Lawyers qualify their conclusions.
  9. 9. Pepper v Hart (1993) relates to:

    Parliamentary statements as an aid in limited circumstances.
  10. 10. Which statement is true about the literal rule?

    Certainty versus purpose.

Summary

  • Reading cases means finding the ratio and knowing which courts bind.
  • Reading statutes means careful structure reading and choosing an interpretation approach.
  • IRAC organizes an answer.

Next: Chapter 9: Projects and practice, brief a case