Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 22 of 48 ยท Kirchhoff's Laws and Nodal Analysis

Chapter 4 Review: Kirchhoff's Laws, Nodal and Mesh Analysis

Review KCL, KVL, nodal analysis and mesh analysis with a side-by-side cheat sheet, a worked comparison of both methods and a ten-question chapter quiz.

You now own the general tools of circuit analysis. Kirchhoff's laws give the equations; nodal and mesh analysis organize them; and the power balance checks the answers. This review puts the two methods side by side, solves one circuit both ways, and tests the whole chapter.

Two cards with four numbered steps each: nodal analysis and mesh analysis.
Chapter 4 on one page: same circuit, two routes to the answer.

What you will learn

  • A side-by-side comparison of the two methods.
  • How the same circuit gives the same answer by either route.
  • How to choose the method with fewer equations.

Recap table

Nodal analysis Mesh analysis
Unknowns node voltages mesh currents
Law used KCL KVL
Matrix Gยทv = i (conductances) Rยทi = v (resistances)
Number of equations nodes โˆ’ 1 branches โˆ’ nodes + 1
Easy with current sources voltage sources
Special case supernode (floating voltage source) supermesh (shared current source)
Needs planar circuit? no yes

KCL: ฮฃ i_in = ฮฃ i_out at a node. KVL: ฮฃ v = 0 around a loop. Both hold for any lumped element.

One circuit, two methods

Take the lesson 4.5 circuit: a 12 V source and R1 = 2 kฮฉ on the left, a shared R2 = 4 kฮฉ in the middle, R3 = 2 kฮฉ and a 6 V source on the right (the 6 V source's + terminal is at the top, connected to R3).

Mesh: two equations, 6I1 โˆ’ 4I2 = 12 and โˆ’4I1 + 6I2 = โˆ’6. Result: I1 = 2.4 mA, I2 = 0.6 mA.

Nodal: only one non-reference node N (the junction of the three resistors), so one equation. KCL with all currents leaving N (units kฮฉ, mA, V):

(V_N โˆ’ 12)/2 + V_N/4 + (V_N โˆ’ 6)/2 = 0

Multiply by 4: 2V_N โˆ’ 24 + V_N + 2V_N โˆ’ 12 = 0, so 5V_N = 36 and V_N = 7.2 V. The branch currents: from the 12 V source (12 โˆ’ 7.2)/2 = 2.4 mA = I1; through R3 (7.2 โˆ’ 6)/2 = 0.6 mA = I2; through R2 7.2/4 = 1.8 mA = I1 โˆ’ I2. Same answers, half the algebra.

Before writing any equation, count: unknown nodes (nodes โˆ’ 1) versus meshes. Choose the smaller number. A few seconds of counting can save many minutes of algebra.

Common misconceptions

"The two methods give different answers if the circuit is complex." They are the same physics; any difference is an arithmetic or sign error.

"I must use the same method for the whole problem." Use whichever is easiest; you can even switch methods to check your answer.

"A negative current or voltage is an error." It simply means the real direction or polarity is opposite to your reference.

Try it

Solve the circuit both ways in code and compare. The two answers must agree to rounding.

Python Nodal and mesh agree

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Then a quick console drill on method choice: for each circuit description, which method needs fewer equations?

JS Which method is shorter?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. KCL at a node says that

    KCL is conservation of charge: current in = current out.
  2. 2. A planar circuit has 7 nodes and 10 branches. How many mesh equations?

    branches โˆ’ nodes + 1 = 10 โˆ’ 7 + 1 = 4.
  3. 3. The same circuit has 7 nodes. How many nodal equations (no voltage sources to ground)?

    nodes โˆ’ 1 = 6.
  4. 4. In mesh analysis with all mesh currents clockwise, the off-diagonal entries of the resistance matrix are

    A shared resistor sees the neighbor's current in the opposite direction, so it enters with a minus sign.
  5. 5. A voltage source connects two non-reference nodes. In nodal analysis you use

    The source current is unknown, so combine the two nodes and add the voltage constraint.
  6. 6. In the chapter's worked example the node voltage V_N is

    5V_N = 36 gives V_N = 7.2 V.
  7. 7. KVL around a loop with a 10 V source and two resistors with drops 3 V and x gives x =

    +10 โˆ’ 3 โˆ’ x = 0, so x = 7 V.
  8. 8. Which circuit most favors nodal analysis?

    Current sources inject known currents directly into the node equations.
  9. 9. A current source in a branch that belongs to one mesh only

    That mesh current is known, which removes an unknown.
  10. 10. A negative value for a computed branch current means

    Signs compare the real direction with your reference arrows.

Summary

  • KCL (charge) and KVL (energy) are the two laws behind all linear circuit analysis.
  • Nodal: unknown node voltages, KCL, Gยทv = i. Mesh: unknown loop currents, KVL, Rยทi = v.
  • Special cases: supernode (floating voltage source) and supermesh (shared current source).
  • Choose the method with fewer equations, and verify with a power balance or the other method.

Next: Chapter 5 Overview: Network Theorems