Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 19 of 49 ยท Drag and Performance

The drag polar and maximum L/D

Learn the parabolic drag polar, what CD0 and K mean, how to find the best lift-to-drag ratio and the speed to fly for it, with worked examples and live plots.

Every aircraft has a relationship between the drag it produces and the lift it makes. Plot lift coefficient against drag coefficient and you get a curve called the drag polar. It is the most useful single picture of an aircraft's aerodynamic performance. From it you can read the best lift-to-drag ratio, the speed for the longest glide, and the drag at any condition.

What you will learn

  • The parabolic polar CD = CD0 + K CLยฒ and its two parts.
  • How the induced-drag factor K relates to span and efficiency.
  • How to find the maximum L/D and the lift coefficient at which it occurs.
  • How to compute the speed for best glide.

Key terms

Drag polar: the curve (or equation) giving CD as a function of CL for a given aircraft.

CD0: zero-lift drag coefficient, the parasite drag.

K: the lift-induced drag factor, K = 1 / (ฯ€ e AR).

Aspect ratio (AR): wingspan squared divided by wing area, AR = bยฒ / S.

Oswald efficiency factor (e): a number near 0.7 to 0.9 that says how close the wing is to ideal elliptical loading.

A parabola of CL against CD with a dashed tangent line from the origin touching at the best lift-to-drag point, and cards giving the polar equation.
Draw the tangent to the polar from the origin: its slope CL/CD is L/D, and the steepest tangent touches at the best L/D.

The parabolic polar

Experiments and theory agree on a simple model over the useful range of lift coefficients:

Text
CD = CD0 + K CLยฒ
  • CD0 is what remains when lift is zero: the parasite drag of the previous lesson.
  • K CLยฒ is the lift-induced drag coefficient CDi. A wing that produces lift has to bend the air downward, and the tilt of the lift vector relative to the flight path creates a drag component. On a finite wing it is CDi = CLยฒ / (ฯ€ e AR), so
Text
K = 1 / (ฯ€ e AR)

A long, slender wing (large aspect ratio) has small K and low induced drag, which is why gliders and long-range airliners have long wings. Chapter 5 derives this. For now, take K as given. Typical values: light aircraft AR โ‰ˆ 7 to 8 and e โ‰ˆ 0.75, giving K โ‰ˆ 0.055; an airliner AR โ‰ˆ 9 and e โ‰ˆ 0.8 gives K โ‰ˆ 0.044; a high-performance glider AR โ‰ˆ 25 gives K โ‰ˆ 0.017.

Reading L/D from the polar

The lift-to-drag ratio at any point is

Text
L/D = CL / CD = CL / (CD0 + K CLยฒ)

On the polar, CL/CD is the slope of the line from the origin to the point. The steepest such line is the tangent from the origin. To find the optimum, differentiate L/D with respect to CL and set the result to zero. This gives

Text
CL* = โˆš(CD0 / K)         CD* = 2 CD0         (L/D)max = 1 / (2 โˆš(CD0 K))

Note the beautiful result CD* = 2 CD0: at the best L/D, the induced drag equals the parasite drag (each is CD0).

Worked example. CD0 = 0.025 and K = 0.05. Then CL* = โˆš(0.025/0.05) = 0.707, CD* = 0.050, and (L/D)max = 0.707/0.050 = 14.1. Check with the formula: 1/(2โˆš(0.025 ร— 0.05)) = 1/(2 ร— 0.0354) = 14.1. โœ“

The speed for best L/D

In level flight L = W, so V = โˆš(2W / (ฯ S CL)). At best L/D:

Text
V(L/D)max = โˆš( 2 W / (ฯ S CL*) )

For W = 10,791 N, S = 16.2 mยฒ, ฯ = 1.225 kg/mยณ and CL* = 0.707: V = โˆš(2 ร— 10,791 / (1.225 ร— 16.2 ร— 0.707)) = โˆš1,538 = 39.2 m/s. That is the speed at which this aircraft glides farthest in still air, and minimum thrust is needed in level flight: Dmin = W / (L/D)max = 10,791 / 14.1 = 763 N. Heavier aircraft must fly faster to be at CL*, since V โˆ โˆšW; but the best L/D itself does not depend on weight.

Limits of the parabolic polar

  • At high CL near stall the real polar steepens because of separation.
  • At high Mach numbers, wave drag adds a term to CD0 (Chapter 6).
  • Cambered wings have their minimum drag at a positive CL, so a more general polar is CD = CD0 + K (CL โˆ’ CLmd)ยฒ.
  • Flaps and landing gear change CD0 and e; every configuration has its own polar.

Common misconceptions

"Best L/D means minimum drag coefficient." Minimum CD occurs near CL = 0. Best L/D occurs at a higher CL where the ratio CL/CD peaks.

"A heavier aircraft has a worse glide ratio." The maximum L/D does not depend on weight. A heavier aircraft glides at the same angle, but at a higher speed, and so it descends faster.

"Induced drag is a defect of poor wings." Even a perfect wing has induced drag. A perfect (elliptical) wing has e = 1; real wings are slightly worse.

Try it

Python Draw a drag polar and find the best L/D

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Polar explorer: aspect ratio and cleanliness

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. At the speed for maximum L/D (parabolic polar), induced drag is:

    CL* = sqrt(CD0/K) gives K CLยฒ = CD0, so CDi = CD0 and CD = 2 CD0.
  2. 2. With CD0 = 0.02 and K = 0.05, what is (L/D)max?

    1 / (2 โˆš(0.02 ร— 0.05)) = 1 / (2 ร— 0.0316) = 15.8.
  3. 3. Increasing aspect ratio at constant e does what to K?

    K = 1/(ฯ€ e AR), so a larger AR gives a smaller K and less induced drag.
  4. 4. Which aircraft has the largest maximum L/D?

    Long, slender wings and a very clean surface give gliders L/D values of 40 or more.
  5. 5. Does the maximum L/D of an aircraft depend on its weight?

    (L/D)max = 1/(2โˆš(CD0 K)) depends only on the polar; the speed for it scales with โˆšW.

Summary

  • The parabolic polar is CD = CD0 + K CLยฒ with K = 1/(ฯ€ e AR).
  • (L/D)max = 1/(2โˆš(CD0 K)) at CL* = โˆš(CD0/K), where induced and parasite drag are equal.
  • Best-glide speed is โˆš(2W/(ฯ S CL*)); it rises with โˆšW.
  • Long, clean wings give high L/D.

Next: Glide, range and endurance