Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 24 of 46 ยท Gears

Tooth forces and bending strength

Turn power into tooth force, then check a spur gear for bending with the Lewis equation and for surface fatigue with Hertz contact stress, with worked numbers.

A gear tooth is a short, stubby beam that is loaded on one flank, over and over, millions of times. Two things can go wrong. The tooth can snap at its root, where the bending stress is highest, or its surface can pit and flake, where two steel flanks press on each other with enormous local pressure. A gear designer checks both. To do so, you first have to know how big the force is and in which direction it acts.

In this lesson you will convert a motor's power into the force on a tooth, split that force into useful and wasted parts, and then use two classic stress models: the Lewis equation for bending and the Hertz equation for surface contact. The models are simplified, and real standards (ISO 6336 and AGMA 2001) add many correction factors, but they teach you which variables matter and in which direction to change them.

Two meshing gears with the tooth force split into tangential and radial parts, and a tooth drawn as a cantilever beam.
The mesh force W has a useful tangential part Wt and a radial part Wr. The Lewis model treats the tooth as a cantilever loaded at its tip.

What you will learn

  • Convert power and speed into torque, and torque into the tangential and radial tooth forces.
  • Apply the Lewis bending equation, including the form factor and velocity factor.
  • Compute Hertz contact stress between two involute flanks.
  • Explain why bending stress depends on module while contact stress depends on diameter.

Key terms

  • Tangential force Wt: the component of the tooth force perpendicular to the radius. It carries the torque.
  • Radial force Wr: the component along the radius. It does no work and pushes the gears apart.
  • Lewis form factor Y: a number that depends on the tooth count and describes how strong the tooth shape is.
  • Velocity factor Kv: increases the load to allow for impact at higher speeds.
  • Hertz stress: the contact pressure at the surface between two curved bodies pressed together.

From power to tooth force

Power is torque times angular speed, P = T ฯ‰. With power in kilowatts and speed in rpm, the torque in newton-meters is

Text
T = 9550 P / n

(the 9550 is 60 000 / 2ฯ€). The tangential force on the pitch circle follows from the torque and the pitch radius:

Text
Wt = T / (d/2) = 2 T / d        or equivalently        Wt = P / v

where P is in watts and v in m/s. Because the force acts at an angle (the pressure angle) to the tangent, there is also a radial component and the full tooth force:

Text
Wr = Wt tan ฯ†        W = Wt / cos ฯ†

For ฯ† = 20ยฐ, Wr = 0.364 Wt and W = 1.064 Wt. The radial force is the price of the involute: it does no useful work but presses on the shafts and bearings. A larger pressure angle gives a larger Wr. Gear pairs always act with equal and opposite forces. On the driven gear, Wt points in the direction of rotation; on the driver it opposes the rotation (the driver has to push against the load). You will use these forces in later chapters to find the shaft loads and bearing reactions.

Worked example: forces

A 7.5 kW motor turns a pinion of module 2.5 mm and 20 teeth at 1450 rpm. Then:

  1. Torque: T = 9550 ร— 7.5 / 1450 = 49.4 Nยทm.
  2. Pitch diameter: d = 2.5 ร— 20 = 50 mm = 0.050 m.
  3. Tangential force: Wt = 2 ร— 49.4 / 0.050 = 1976 N.
  4. Radial force: Wr = 1976 ร— tan 20ยฐ = 719 N.
  5. Total tooth force: W = 1976 / cos 20ยฐ = 2103 N.

How teeth fail

There are four common ways. Bending fatigue cracks the tooth at the root fillet, usually after a long life, and a missing tooth then wrecks the whole gearbox. Pitting is surface fatigue: tiny cracks under the surface grow and release small pits. Scoring (scuffing) is a welding and tearing of the surfaces when the lubricant film fails at high speed and load. Wear is gradual loss of material in a dirty or poorly lubricated mesh. Bending and pitting are the ones checked by calculation; scoring and wear are controlled by lubrication, finish and cleanliness.

The Lewis bending equation

In 1892 Wilfred Lewis made a simple idea: a gear tooth is a cantilever beam. Treat the tooth as a rectangle of width F (the face width) and thickness t at the root, loaded at its tip by Wt at height h. The bending stress in a beam is ฯƒ = M c / I, with M = Wt h, c = t/2 and I = F tยณ / 12, giving

Text
ฯƒ = 6 Wt h / (F tยฒ)

Multiply and divide by the module m to separate size from shape:

Text
ฯƒ = Wt / (F m Y)        where        Y = tยฒ / (6 h m)

The form factor Y depends only on the tooth shape, and for a standard tooth that depends only on the tooth count. Lewis's Y is a bit smaller for few teeth because a pinion tooth is thin at the root and long.

Teeth N 14 17 20 25 30 40 60 100
Y (20ยฐ full depth) 0.277 0.303 0.322 0.340 0.359 0.389 0.422 0.447

Since Y increases with N, the pinion of a pair has the lower Y and is the weaker tooth, even though it carries the same force.

Two adjustments make the equation more realistic. First, teeth that meet at speed hit each other. The classical Barth velocity factor for cut gears is Kv = (6.1 + v) / 6.1 with v in m/s, and it multiplies the stress. Second, the real load depends on the driver and driven machines: a smooth electric motor driving a fan is gentle, while an engine driving a rock crusher is violent. A factor Ka, the application factor, from 1.0 up to 2 or more, covers this. The design equation is

Text
ฯƒ = Ka Kv Wt / (F m Y)  โ‰ค  ฯƒ_allowable

Allowable bending stress for the tooth root depends on the steel and its heat treatment. For common through-hardened and case-hardened steels, handbook values range from roughly 150 MPa to well over 400 MPa; take the value from your standard, not from memory. A rule of thumb for the face width is about 8 to 16 times the module: too narrow a tooth is flimsy, too wide a tooth loads unevenly if the shafts bend.

Worked example: bending

Continue the example. Face width F = 25 mm, Y = 0.322 for N = 20, speed v = ฯ€ ร— 0.050 ร— 1450 / 60 = 3.80 m/s. Then Kv = (6.1 + 3.80)/6.1 = 1.62 and, with Ka = 1:

Text
ฯƒ = 1.62 ร— 1976 / (25 ร— 2.5 ร— 0.322) = 159 MPa

If the allowable stress is 200 MPa, the safety factor is 200/159 = 1.26. That is modest. In the calculator below, cutting the face width to 15 mm pushes the pinion stress to 265 MPa and the safety factor below 1, while raising the module to 3 mm lowers it to 119 MPa.

Contact stress: the Hertz model

Where two curved surfaces touch under load, the contact is not a line but a thin strip, and the pressure there is very high. Heinrich Hertz solved this for two parallel cylinders in 1881. Two involute flanks at the pitch point behave like two cylinders whose radii are the radii of curvature of the profiles, ฯ = (d sin ฯ†) / 2 for each gear. The peak pressure is

Text
ฯƒH = Zโ‚‘ ยท โˆš[ (Wt / (F cos ฯ†)) ยท (1/ฯ1 + 1/ฯ2) ]

with Zโ‚‘ = 189.8 โˆšMPa for steel on steel (it combines E = 206 GPa and ฮฝ = 0.3), when Wt is in newtons and lengths in mm.

For the example gears (ฯ1 = 50 sin 20ยฐ/2 = 8.55 mm, ฯ2 = 200 sin 20ยฐ/2 = 34.2 mm), Wt/(F cos ฯ†) = 1976 / (25 ร— 0.940) = 84.1 N/mm, and 1/ฯ1 + 1/ฯ2 = 0.1462 mmโปยน. So ฯƒH = 189.8 โˆš(84.1 ร— 0.1462) = 666 MPa. Hardened steel gears have allowable contact stresses of roughly 500 to well over 1000 MPa, so this pair passes with a margin.

Two knobs, two failure modes

The two stresses respond to different design variables, which is the main practical lesson:

  • Bending stress depends on the module m (and on Y, which depends on tooth count). A bigger tooth is stronger.
  • Contact stress depends on the pitch diameter and the face width but not on the module. To lower it, make the pinion bigger or the gear wider, or use harder steel.

So you pick the pinion diameter and the face width to satisfy contact, then pick the module and tooth count to satisfy bending.

Common misconceptions

  • "The tooth force is 2T/d in total." That is only the tangential part. The real tooth force is Wt / cos ฯ†, and the radial part loads the bearings.
  • "The gear with more teeth is the weaker one." The pinion has the smaller form factor and takes more load cycles per second, so it usually governs.
  • "Lewis gives the exact stress." It ignores stress concentration at the fillet and load sharing between pairs. It is a first estimate; use a standard for the final design.
  • "Doubling the module halves the contact stress." Contact stress does not depend on the module at all.

Try it

The first TryIt computes forces, bending and contact stress for any pair. Change the face width and the module and watch which check becomes critical.

Python Gear force and stress checker

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The second TryIt keeps the pinion's pitch diameter constant at 60 mm and changes the tooth count (and therefore the module m = 60/N) under a fixed tooth force of 2000 N. It shows that bending stress changes strongly with the module, while the Hertz stress does not move.

Python Bending and contact stress versus tooth count

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A pinion with a 100 mm pitch diameter transmits 5 kW at 1000 rpm. What is the tangential tooth force?

    T = 9550 ร— 5 / 1000 = 47.75 Nยทm, and Wt = 2T/d = 2 ร— 47.75 / 0.100 = 955 N.
  2. 2. For a 20 degree pressure angle, what is Wr in terms of Wt?

    Wr = Wt tan 20ยฐ = 0.364 Wt. The 1.064 factor belongs to the total force W = Wt / cos 20ยฐ.
  3. 3. Which variable does the Hertz contact stress NOT depend on?

    Contact stress depends on the force, the face width and the radii of curvature set by the diameters. At a given pitch diameter, changing the module does not change it.
  4. 4. Why is the pinion usually the weaker gear in bending?

    The pinion tooth is thinner at the root (smaller Y), and it also sees more load cycles. The force on both teeth is the same.
  5. 5. A designer wants to reduce the bending stress without changing the pitch diameters. What helps?

    Bending stress falls with a larger module (stronger teeth) and a wider face. A smaller module makes the teeth weaker.

Summary

  • T = 9550 P / n, Wt = 2T/d, Wr = Wt tan ฯ†, W = Wt / cos ฯ†.
  • Lewis bending: ฯƒ = Ka Kv Wt / (F m Y), with Kv = (6.1 + v)/6.1 for cut gears and Y from the tooth count.
  • Hertz contact: ฯƒH = 189.8 โˆš[(Wt/(F cos ฯ†))(1/ฯ1 + 1/ฯ2)] MPa for steel, with ฯ = d sin ฯ† / 2.
  • Choose diameter and face width to satisfy contact; choose module and tooth count to satisfy bending.
  • Standards (ISO 6336, AGMA 2001) refine these formulas with more factors; the physics is the same.

Next: Helical, bevel and worm gears