Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 10 of 47 ยท Reading Closely

Symbol, motif and theme

Learn the difference between a symbol, a motif and a theme, see how patterns build into ideas in The Great Gatsby and Macbeth, and practice writing a strong theme statement.

So far you have looked at single words, comparisons and tones. Now zoom out. Meaning in a long text rarely rests on one image. It builds as certain things return again and again, gather weight and finally point to an idea. This lesson introduces three tools for reading that accumulation: the symbol, the motif and the theme. They form a ladder: patterns of repetition grow into symbols and, together, support a theme, the central idea a work explores.

Three rising steps. Step one is motif, a repeated pattern. Step two is symbol, a concrete thing carrying extra meaning. Step three, the highest, is theme, the idea the whole work explores. A dashed arrow labelled meaning builds up joins them.
Motif, symbol and theme are three steps from a repeated detail to a central idea.

What you will learn

  • How to define symbol, motif and theme and tell them apart.
  • The difference between conventional and literary symbols.
  • How to track a motif through a text.
  • How to write a theme as a full-sentence claim, not a single word.
  • How to avoid over-reading.

Key terms

Symbol is a concrete thing (an object, person, place or action) that stands for something beyond itself.

Motif is a recurring element, image, word or situation that develops across a work.

Theme is the central idea or insight a work explores.

Subject is what a work is about in a word or two, such as "ambition" or "love."

Leitmotif is a recurring musical phrase linked to a character or idea; the term is also used for literary motifs.

Symbols

A symbol is something real and concrete that also stands for something else. A dove can stand for peace. A road can stand for a life's journey. Some symbols are conventional, meaning a culture already agrees on them: a white wedding dress, a skull for death, a rose for love. Writers use these shared meanings, or twist them.

Other symbols are literary, built by one work. They are created by repeated attention. The green light in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby (1925) is an ordinary dock light at the end of Daisy's pier. In the book's first great scene, the narrator, Nick, sees Gatsby stretch his arms toward the dark water and notices "a single green light, minute and far away, that might have been the end of a dock." By the last chapter, the light has acquired a meaning: Nick writes that Gatsby "believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year recedes before us." Now the light stands for desire, hope and the future that we reach for and never grasp. The final sentence of the novel returns to the image of reaching: "So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past."

Note that the symbol does not replace the object. The light remains a light. A good symbol works on two levels at once, the literal and the suggestive.

Symbols can also shift. In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter (1850), the red letter A that Hester Prynne must wear is first a mark of shame for adultery, but over the book its meaning changes for the townspeople and for Hester. A symbol is not a fixed code, and following its changes is often the key to the story.

Motifs

A motif is a pattern: something that recurs. It could be an image (water), a word (the repeated "it was" of a famous opening), a situation (characters waiting), a sound or a color. A single appearance is just a detail. Three or more appearances that connect make a motif.

Shakespeare's Macbeth is full of blood. After the murder of King Duncan, Macbeth looks at his hands and asks, "Will all great Neptune's ocean wash this blood / Clean from my hand?" He answers that his hand will rather turn the "multitudinous seas" red. Later Lady Macbeth sleepwalks, rubbing her hands and crying "Out, damned spot!" The motif of blood and hands returns across the play. It tracks guilt, which cannot be washed away, and it joins ideas of violence, kingship and conscience.

A motif is a thread that lets you see an idea develop. To track one:

  1. Notice a repeated element.
  2. List each appearance with its context.
  3. Look for change. Does it grow stronger, reverse or disappear?
  4. Ask what the pattern adds to the work's meaning.

Theme

A theme is the central idea a work explores about people or life. It is not the same as the subject. "Ambition" is a subject. A theme says something about it: "Unchecked ambition destroys the person who pursues it." Notice the difference: a theme is a claim, expressed as a full sentence.

Some useful rules:

  • State a theme as a sentence with a verb, not as a single word. "Love" is not a theme; "love can both heal and trap people" is.
  • Do not confuse theme with moral. A moral is a lesson to follow ("don't be greedy"). A theme can be an observation or a question, and works can complicate or resist a simple moral.
  • Most works have several themes. Macbeth explores ambition, guilt, fate and the corruption of power.
  • A theme should be supported by the text. If you cannot point to symbols, motifs, character choices or the ending that back it up, it is a guess.

A handy formula: subject + what the work says about it. Subject: "memory." Theme: "Memory reshapes the past to protect the present."

From motif to symbol to theme

Here is how the ladder works in practice. Suppose a story keeps mentioning clocks.

  • Motif. Clocks appear in a shop, in a character's thoughts and in her sleep.
  • Symbol. One special clock, which her father winds every day, starts to stand for duty.
  • Theme. The story seems to say that duty to family can trap a person in time, and that freedom may begin when the ticking stops.

You can build such a chain for any work you read. The key is that each step arises from evidence: repeated appearances, a change in how the object is treated and a link to what the characters want or fear.

Avoiding over-reading

Not everything is a symbol. A red door may simply be a red door. Warning signs of over-reading:

  • The "symbol" appears once and is never developed.
  • You cannot connect it to the rest of the text.
  • Your interpretation could apply to any story.
  • The meaning seems to come from a list of "dream symbols" instead of from the text itself.

Use the test: does the work itself give this thing extra weight, through repetition, emphasis, placement or the characters' attention to it?

Common misconceptions

"Every object in a story is a symbol." Only those the work builds up. Many details are just details.

"A symbol has one correct meaning." Good symbols are rich and can support several readings. But those readings must still fit the text.

"A theme is one word, like 'friendship.'" That is the subject. A theme claims something about the subject.

Try it

Track a motif in a short invented story and plot where it appears, then practice writing a theme statement.

Python Tracking a motif

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

JS Is it a theme or just a subject?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What distinguishes a motif from a single detail?

    A motif is a pattern created by repetition.
  2. 2. Which is the best statement of a theme?

    A theme is a full-sentence claim about the subject, not a topic.
  3. 3. In The Great Gatsby, the green light becomes a symbol of

    Repeated attention gives the dock light the meaning of longing for an unreachable future.
  4. 4. Which is a warning sign of over-reading a symbol?

    A symbol should be built up by the work, not guessed from a single appearance.
  5. 5. How does a theme differ from a moral?

    Themes explore ideas; morals prescribe behavior.

Summary

  • A symbol is a concrete thing that carries extra meaning; literary symbols are built by the work.
  • A motif is a recurring element that develops across a text.
  • A theme is a central idea stated as a full claim about a subject.
  • Meaning builds from repeated detail to symbol to theme; evidence connects each step.
  • Avoid over-reading: require repetition, emphasis and a link to the whole.

Next: Chapter 2 review