Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 44 of 50 Β· Problem Solving and Expertise

Chapter 8 Review: Problem Solving and Expertise

Review problem spaces, means-ends analysis, insight and fixation, analogy, chess expertise, deliberate practice, creativity and metacognition with a summary picture and a quiz.

Problem solving combines search, restructuring and knowledge. Experts do not so much search better as know more, organized into patterns, and creativity and good judgment can be supported by methods that work with the mind's limits. This page pulls the chapter into one picture and one table, then tests all three lessons.

Three summary cards: strategies, expertise, creativity
Chapter 8 in one picture: search, knowledge and good habits.

What you will review

  • Problem spaces, means-ends analysis and the Tower of Hanoi.
  • Insight, functional fixedness, mental set and analogy.
  • Chunking, expert-novice differences, the power law and deliberate practice.
  • Creativity, incubation, group brainstorming and metacognition.

Recap table

Topic Key findings Names
Problem space States, operators, goals; Hanoi needs 2ⁿ βˆ’ 1 moves Newell and Simon 1972
Means-ends analysis Reduce the difference; create subgoals Newell and Simon
Insight Sudden restructuring; warmth stays low until the end KΓΆhler 1925; Metcalfe and Wiebe 1987
Fixation Functional fixedness and mental set Duncker 1945; Luchins 1942
Analogy Few notice the match without a hint Gick and Holyoak 1980
Chess expertise Masters recall real positions, not random ones de Groot 1946; Chase and Simon 1973
Expert representation Experts sort by principle, novices by surface Chi, Feltovich and Glaser 1981
Practice Power law; stages; deliberate practice with limits Newell and Rosenbloom 1981; Ericsson et al. 1993; Macnamara et al. 2014
Intuition Trustworthy in regular, feedback-rich environments Kahneman and Klein 2009
Creativity Divergent thinking; incubation helps a little Guilford 1950; Sio and Ormerod 2009
Groups Production blocking cuts brainstorming output Diehl and Stroebe 1987
Metacognition Illusion of explanatory depth Rozenblit and Keil 2002

Try it

JS Retrieval practice for problem solving

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. The minimum number of moves for a 7-disk Tower of Hanoi is

    2^7 - 1 = 127.
  2. 2. Hill climbing fails in the Tower of Hanoi because

    Solving the puzzle requires temporary moves that seem unhelpful.
  3. 3. Functional fixedness is best illustrated by

    The usual function of an object blocks seeing a new use.
  4. 4. In Gick and Holyoak's work, the main reason people failed to use the fortress story was

    Hints greatly increased use of the story.
  5. 5. Masters' advantage in remembering chess positions largely disappears when the pieces are

    Random arrangements contain no familiar chunks.
  6. 6. Novices in physics tended to sort problems by

    Chi et al. (1981) found a shift to principle-based sorting with expertise.
  7. 7. The power law of practice predicts that improvement is

    Time per trial declines steeply at first.
  8. 8. Skilled intuition is most reliable when the environment is

    Kahneman and Klein (2009) set out these conditions.
  9. 9. Incubation studies suggest the largest benefit when

    Meta-analysis found larger effects with low-demand breaks after initial work.
  10. 10. A good conclusion about group brainstorming is

    This reduces production blocking while keeping the benefits of collaboration.

Summary

  • Problems are searched and restructured; fixation and surface similarity obstruct, and hints, subgoals and comparison help.
  • Expertise is organized, domain-specific knowledge built by practice, with limits and caveats.
  • Creativity benefits from knowledge, incubation after effort, and working alone first.
  • Metacognition is imperfect; testing, considering the opposite, pre-mortems and checklists improve judgment.

Next: Case Studies in Cognitive Psychology