Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 10 of 47 ยท Defining and Classifying Disorders

Chapter 2 Review: Defining and Classifying Disorders

Review what counts as abnormal, how DSM-5-TR and ICD-11 classify disorders, and reliability, validity and labelling, with a recap table, flashcards and a ten-question quiz.

This chapter was about boundaries: where ordinary variation ends and disorder begins, how experts agree to describe the territory, and how we test whether their maps are any good. Use this review to check that you can explain each idea in your own words before moving to the individual disorders.

Four cards for define, classify, test and question joined by a dotted arrow to useful imperfect tools that keep improving
Caption: Chapter 2 in one picture. Definitions and manuals are useful, imperfect tools that keep improving.

What you will review

  • The four definitions of abnormality and the four Ds.
  • The history and structure of the DSM and ICD.
  • Reliability, validity, kappa, comorbidity and labelling.

Recap table

Topic Key ideas Names and numbers
Defining abnormality Statistical infrequency, social norms, failure to function, ideal mental health; the four Ds Rosenhan and Seligman (1989), Jahoda (1958), Wakefield
Culture Norms and expression vary; severe conditions occur everywhere; WEIRD samples Henrich et al. (2010), Cultural Formulation Interview
Classification DSM (APA) and ICD (WHO); explicit criteria; polythetic rules; specifiers DSM-III 1980, DSM-5 2013, DSM-5-TR 2022, ICD-11 2022
Alternatives Dimensional models HiTOP, RDoC
Quality of diagnosis Reliability, validity, kappa, comorbidity, heterogeneity Rosenhan 1973, Spitzer 1975, Cahalan 2019, Robins and Guze 1970
Labels Benefits and stigma; person-first language Goffman (1963)

Try it

Use the flashcards: say the answer aloud, then reveal it.

Chapter 2 flashcards

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A person is extremely talented and statistically rare, but happy and functioning well. Which conclusion is best?

    Rarity is not harm.
  2. 2. Which pair shows the definition problems of social norms?

    These are historical examples where norms were used to pathologize.
  3. 3. Wakefield's harmful dysfunction requires

    It mixes a factual and a value component.
  4. 4. Which edition introduced explicit criteria?

    DSM-III (1980) did, to improve reliability.
  5. 5. ICD-11 came into effect in

    It was approved in 2019 and took effect from 1 January 2022.
  6. 6. What problem does Cohen's kappa solve?

    Kappa subtracts chance agreement.
  7. 7. A diagnosis is reliable but not valid. What does that mean?

    Consistency does not guarantee meaning.
  8. 8. Which critique of Rosenhan (1973) is accurate?

    Critics include Spitzer (1975) and Cahalan (2019).
  9. 9. Why does comorbidity encourage dimensional models such as HiTOP?

    Overlap suggests broader spectra.
  10. 10. Which is the best use of a diagnostic label?

    Labels help but never replace understanding the individual.

Summary

  • Abnormality is defined by combining criteria and context, not by one rule.
  • The DSM and ICD organize symptoms into categories; critics ask for more dimensions.
  • Reliability and validity are separate; kappa corrects for chance.
  • Labels help and harm; use them thoughtfully.
  • Chapter 3 begins the tour of the disorders with anxiety, trauma and stress.

Next: Chapter 3 Overview: Anxiety and Stress Disorders