Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 10 of 45 Ā· Power Semiconductors

Chapter 2 Review: Power Semiconductors

Review chapter 2: the switching overlap picture, a recap table of diodes, MOSFETs, IGBTs, thyristors, SiC and GaN, a switching-energy demo and a ten-question quiz.

This review gathers the whole chapter into one picture and one table, then tests it. The key idea to take with you: every switch loses power in two ways. While it conducts, it wastes power through a resistance or a voltage drop. While it switches, voltage and current overlap for an instant, and the overlap becomes heat.

A turn-on waveform where voltage falls while current rises with the overlap shaded, next to a device cheat sheet
Caption: the shaded overlap between drain-source voltage and drain current is the switching loss; the formula on the picture estimates it.

Chapter in one paragraph

Diodes block in one direction, with a forward drop and, for PN types, reverse recovery. MOSFETs are fast voltage-controlled switches with a resistance RDS(on), a gate charge Qg and a body diode. IGBTs trade speed for a low on-state drop at high voltage and current. Thyristors latch and handle the highest powers at line frequency. SiC and GaN, thanks to a wide bandgap, switch faster, run hotter and lose less. A device is chosen by voltage, current and frequency.

Recap table

Device Control Typical strength Typical weakness Lesson
PN diode none high voltage, cheap reverse recovery Diodes
Schottky diode none low VF, no recovery low voltage, leakage Diodes
MOSFET gate, on and off fast, easy to drive RDS(on) at high voltage MOSFETs
IGBT gate, on and off low drop at high V and I tail current, slower IGBTs and WBG
Thyristor on only huge power, rugged cannot turn off by gate IGBTs and WBG
SiC MOSFET gate, on and off fast, hot, efficient cost, gate drive care IGBTs and WBG
GaN HEMT gate, on and off very fast, compact low gate margin, layout IGBTs and WBG

The switching-loss formula, derived simply

Consider a hard-switched transistor with an inductive load. At turn-on, the current first rises to I while the voltage across the device stays at V. Then the voltage falls to zero while the current stays at I. Each phase is a triangle of power with peak V Ɨ I and duration tri or tfv, so the energy per turn-on is about

Eon ā‰ˆ ½ Ɨ V Ɨ I Ɨ (tri + tfv)

Turn-off is similar. Multiply the energy per cycle by the switching frequency to get the average power, which gives the formula used in the picture, Psw ā‰ˆ ½ V I (tr + tf) fsw. The conclusion: halve the transition time, halve the switching loss; double the frequency, double the loss.

Try it

The simulation integrates the instantaneous power of a hard-switched turn-on, using the two-phase model above, to confirm the formula numerically. It is a model with ideal piecewise-linear edges, not a measurement of a real device.

Python Energy lost in one hard turn-on

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Ā· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding: chapter test

Quick check Ā· 9 questions

of 9 answered You scored / 9 Ā· perfect!

  1. 1. Which device is semi-controlled?

    A thyristor can be turned on by the gate but only turns off when its current falls to near zero.
  2. 2. A diode with VF = 0.8 V carries 6 A average. Approximate conduction loss?

    0.8 V Ɨ 6 A = 4.8 W.
  3. 3. Which device has no stored-charge reverse recovery?

    Schottky diodes conduct with majority carriers; SiC Schottky diodes extend this to high voltage.
  4. 4. A MOSFET has Qg = 50 nC, Vgs = 10 V and fsw = 300 kHz. Gate-drive power?

    50e-9 Ɨ 10 Ɨ 300e3 = 0.15 W.
  5. 5. Why does RDS(on) matter at the hot junction temperature?

    Silicon MOSFET resistance rises with temperature; hot values should be used for loss estimates.
  6. 6. With 300 V, 10 A and tr = tf = 25 ns at 100 kHz, what is Psw ā‰ˆ ½ V I (tr + tf) fsw?

    Psw = 0.5 Ɨ 300 V Ɨ 10 A Ɨ 50 ns Ɨ 100 kHz = 1500 Ɨ 0.005 = 7.5 W.
  7. 7. What is the tail current of an IGBT?

    Stored minority carriers decay slowly after turn-off and add switching loss.
  8. 8. Which pair describes wide-bandgap advantages?

    A wider bandgap gives a higher critical field, so thinner layers, lower capacitance and faster, more efficient switching.
  9. 9. In which application is a thyristor most appropriate?

    Thyristors excel at very high power with commutation by the mains.

Summary

  • Conduction loss: I² RDS(on) for MOSFETs, VCE Ɨ I for IGBTs, VF Ɨ I for diodes.
  • Switching loss: ½ V I (tr + tf) fsw for hard switching; gate-drive loss: Qg Vgs fsw; diode recovery: Qrr V fsw.
  • Choose devices by voltage, current and frequency, with temperature margin.
  • Wide-bandgap devices shift the loss trade-off toward high frequency and high temperature.

Next: Chapter 3 Overview: From Mains AC to DC