Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 32 of 46 ยท Social and Emotional Development

Peers, parenting and morality: friends, play, parenting styles and moral reasoning

Learn how play and friendship grow, what Baumrind's parenting styles do and do not show, and how Piaget and Kohlberg described children's moral reasoning.

A toddler plays beside another toddler, each busy with a bucket of blocks, never speaking. A few years later the same child leads a pretend restaurant with three friends, assigning roles and arguing about who gets to be the chef. By age ten she has a best friend, a clear sense of what is unfair, and strong opinions about the rules of a game. Peers, parents and moral ideas all shape this journey.

This lesson covers three connected topics: how play and friendship change, what researchers have learned about parenting styles (and the limits of that research), and how children come to think about right and wrong. Much of the research comes from North America and Europe, so you will see where culture changes the picture.

A staircase of six steps in three levels: pre-conventional reasoning (avoid punishment, get a fair deal), conventional reasoning (be seen as a good person, obey laws and duty) and post-conventional reasoning (weigh rights and contracts, follow ethical ideals).
Kohlberg's six stages in three levels. What changes is the reason given for an act, not the verdict.

What you will learn

  • Parten's stages of play and why they are better seen as types than a fixed ladder.
  • What popularity and rejection mean and how aggression takes different forms.
  • Baumrind's four parenting styles, the evidence behind them and their limits.
  • Piaget's and Kohlberg's accounts of moral reasoning, with critiques from Gilligan and others.

Key terms

  • Parallel play: playing near another child but not together.
  • Sociometric status: a child's standing among peers (popular, rejected, neglected, controversial, average).
  • Authoritative parenting: high warmth and clear expectations, with explanations and some flexibility.
  • Heteronomous morality: Piaget's early stage in which rules are seen as fixed and handed down by authority.
  • Post-conventional reasoning: judging by principles such as rights and justice, even above existing laws.

Play grows up

In the 1920s and 1930s Mildred Parten watched preschoolers and described six types of play:

Type What it looks like
Unoccupied Wandering, watching with no clear focus
Solitary Playing alone with own toys
Onlooker Watching others without joining
Parallel Playing side by side, little interaction
Associative Sharing materials, talking, but no common goal
Cooperative Working toward a shared goal with roles

Parten thought these formed a progression, but later studies found that parallel and solitary play remain common and useful even in older children. Today the types are seen as a range that children move in and out of. Play changes in content as well. Pretend play, which appears around 18 months and expands in the preschool years, lets children try roles, practice emotions and negotiate rules. In middle childhood, games with rules, sports and group projects become common.

Lev Vygotsky argued that pretend play is a kind of rehearsal for self-control: a child who pretends to be a soldier standing guard must obey the rules of the pretend role, sometimes doing more than he would do in ordinary life.

Friends and status

Friendships change from "playmates" in early childhood, to loyal, trust-based relationships in middle childhood, to deep sharing of feelings in adolescence. Children with at least one good friend usually feel less lonely and cope better with stress.

Researchers such as Coie and Dodge asked children whom they liked most and least and then described five groups:

  • Popular: liked by many, disliked by few.
  • Rejected: disliked by many. Some rejected children are aggressive, others shy and withdrawn.
  • Neglected: neither liked nor disliked much; often quiet.
  • Controversial: both strongly liked and strongly disliked.
  • Average: in between.

Aggression takes forms that change with age. Physical aggression such as hitting is common in toddlers and drops as language grows. Relational aggression, such as excluding someone or spreading rumors, appears later. Albert Bandura's Bobo doll studies (1961, 1963) showed that children who watched an adult hit an inflatable doll often imitated the hitting, which supports observational learning. Critics note that a Bobo doll is built to be hit, so the studies are limited as models of real violence, but the idea that children copy what they see has held up.

Parenting styles

In the 1960s Diana Baumrind observed preschool children and their parents and described three styles. Eleanor Maccoby and John Martin later split the third into two, giving a grid of two dimensions: warmth (responsiveness) and control (demands).

Style Warmth Control Typical approach
Authoritative High High Clear rules with reasons; listens; flexible
Authoritarian Low High "Because I said so"; strict, little discussion
Permissive High Low Loving but few limits
Neglectful (uninvolved) Low Low Little attention or guidance

In many studies of North American and European families, authoritative parenting is linked to better school performance, social skills and wellbeing. Neglectful parenting is linked to the poorest outcomes.

Be careful with this. The findings are correlations, and children shape their parents as much as the reverse: an easy child may draw out an authoritative style, a very impulsive child may draw out harsher control. Genes shared by parents and children may play a part. Culture matters too: Ruth Chao argued in 1994 that, in many Chinese families, parental strictness is tied to the idea of "training" and care and does not mean coldness, so Western labels may not fit. Finally, serious harm from physical abuse is clear, and researchers generally find that harsh physical punishment is linked to more behavior problems and not fewer.

Piaget: from rules as laws to rules as agreements

In his 1932 book The Moral Judgment of the Child, Jean Piaget watched children play marbles and told them short stories. Younger children (up to about age 7 or 8) showed heteronomous morality: rules come from authority and cannot be changed, and wrongdoing is judged by the amount of damage. A child who broke fifteen cups by accident seemed "naughtier" than one who broke one cup while stealing jam. Older children moved toward autonomous morality: rules are agreements that people can change, and intentions matter.

Kohlberg: three levels, six stages

Lawrence Kohlberg (1958 onward) presented moral dilemmas, the best known being Heinz, whose wife is dying and who considers stealing a drug he cannot afford. Kohlberg cared less about the answer ("steal" or "do not steal") and more about the reasoning:

  • Level 1, pre-conventional: Stage 1 avoids punishment; Stage 2 seeks a fair exchange ("you scratch my back").
  • Level 2, conventional: Stage 3 wants approval and being a good person; Stage 4 respects law and duty to society.
  • Level 3, post-conventional: Stage 5 weighs rights and a social contract; Stage 6 follows universal ethical principles.

Kohlberg argued that people move through the stages in order, and most children and many adults reason at the conventional level. Few reach Stage 5, and it is hard to find clear examples of Stage 6.

Critiques

  • Gilligan (1982) argued that Kohlberg's scheme favored a "justice" view and under-valued an ethic of care and relationships. Later studies found smaller gender differences than she suggested, but her point that morality involves care as well as justice remains influential.
  • Culture. Stages 5 and 6 reflect Western, individual-rights philosophies; many societies emphasize community duty or harmony.
  • Reasoning is not behavior. People who reason well do not always act well.
  • Domains. Elliot Turiel found that even young children distinguish moral rules (hurting is wrong, even if there is no rule) from conventions (wearing a uniform is only a custom).

Do babies have a moral sense?

In a well-known 2007 study, Kiley Hamlin, Karen Wynn and Paul Bloom showed infants puppet shows with a "helper" and a "hinderer", and found that many infants preferred the helper. This sparked a lively debate about early moral instincts. Some later replications found the effect and others did not, so the field regards the claim as interesting but not settled. A safe summary: young children are sensitive to harm and help early, and their sense of fairness and empathy grows through childhood with experience.

Common misconceptions

  • "Parallel play means a child is antisocial." It is a normal, often useful way to play.
  • "Authoritative parenting causes good outcomes, full stop." The evidence is correlational and cultural context matters.
  • "Kohlberg showed that men reason better about morals than women." Studies find small or no average differences in his stages.
  • "A child who steals is at Stage 1 forever." Reasoning develops, and context affects it.

Try it

First, a parenting-style grid. Click a quadrant to see how the style combines warmth and control. It is an educational summary, not a way to label real families.

Parenting styles: warmth and control

Second, a play observation tally. It counts invented observations of a preschool class and reports the share of each type of play.

JS Tally Parten's play types (invented observations)

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Third, a simulated classroom sociogram. Each child nominates classmates they like most and least; the code sorts children into Coie and Dodge's groups. The data are random, made up for practice.

Python Simulated peer status (Coie and Dodge style)

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 6 questions

of 6 answered You scored / 6 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Two toddlers play side by side with their own blocks and do not interact. Which type of play is this?

    Parallel play means playing near others without playing together.
  2. 2. Which parenting style combines high warmth with high control (clear expectations)?

    Authoritative parents are warm and responsive and also set and explain limits.
  3. 3. Why should we be careful about concluding that parenting style causes outcomes?

    Associations can reflect two-way influences and shared genes, and cultural meaning differs.
  4. 4. A child says stealing is wrong because you get punished. Which Kohlberg stage is this?

    Stage 1 reasoning is based on avoiding punishment.
  5. 5. What was Gilligan's main criticism of Kohlberg?

    Gilligan argued that morality involves care as well as justice.
  6. 6. Piaget found that younger children judge wrongdoing mainly by what?

    In heteronomous morality, bigger damage seems worse regardless of intention.

Summary

  • Play moves among solitary, parallel, associative and cooperative forms; the types are a range, not a strict ladder.
  • Peer status (popular, rejected, neglected, controversial) and different forms of aggression shape children's social lives.
  • Authoritative parenting is linked to good outcomes in many Western studies, but causation, temperament and culture complicate the picture.
  • Piaget described a shift from rules as fixed to rules as agreements; Kohlberg described six stages of moral reasoning.
  • Critics point to care ethics, culture and the gap between reasoning and behavior.

Next: Chapter review: social and emotional development