Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 12 of 46 · Lattice Vibrations and Phonons

The monatomic chain and its dispersion

Derive the dispersion of a one-dimensional chain of identical atoms, find the Brillouin zone, sound speed and group velocity, and count the N modes of the chain.

Take N identical atoms of mass m on a line, equally spaced by a, connected to their nearest neighbors by springs of stiffness K. This is the simplest model of a crystal that still shows the real physics of lattice vibrations. Despite its simplicity, it explains why sound travels at constant speed in long waves, why there is a maximum vibration frequency, and why the wave vector can be restricted to a finite range called the first Brillouin zone.

The derivation takes four lines. We will do it carefully, then run it numerically as a check.

A graph of frequency against wave number for a monatomic chain: a sine-shaped curve from zero that flattens at the zone edge, with the slope at the origin marked as the speed of sound.
Linear at long wavelength (sound), flat at the zone edge where the group velocity vanishes.

What you will learn

  • How to write and solve the equations of motion for the chain.
  • What the dispersion relation ω(k) = 2√(K/m)|sin(ka/2)| says physically.
  • Why k can be restricted to the first Brillouin zone and why there are exactly N modes.
  • How the group velocity and the speed of sound emerge.

Key terms

Nearest-neighbor spring constant K: force per unit stretch between adjacent atoms (N/m).

First Brillouin zone: the range −π/a < k ≤ π/a that contains every distinct wave.

Phase velocity: v_p = ω/k, the speed at which a crest moves.

Group velocity: v_g = dω/dk, the speed at which energy and wave packets travel.

Born-von Karman boundary conditions: periodic boundary conditions, u_{n+N} = u_n.

Equation of motion

Let u_n be the displacement of atom n from its equilibrium position x_n = n a. The spring to the right is stretched by u_{n+1} − u_n and pulls atom n with force K(u_{n+1} − u_n). The spring on the left is stretched by u_n − u_{n−1} and pulls back with K(u_n − u_{n−1}). Newton's second law gives

m d²u_n/dt² = K (u_{n+1} + u_{n−1} − 2 u_n).

This is a set of N coupled equations. Try a traveling wave solution

u_n = A exp[ i (k n a − ω t) ].

Substituting, the factors e^{±ika} appear from u_{n±1}, and the A and the time dependence cancel:

−m ω² = K ( e^{ika} + e^{−ika} − 2 ) = 2K (cos ka − 1) = −4K sin²(ka/2).

Therefore

ω(k) = 2 √(K/m) |sin(ka/2)|

This single expression is the dispersion relation. A wave of any k propagates without changing shape only if ω is proportional to k; here it is not, so waves of different wavelength travel at different speeds (that is what dispersion means).

Reading the dispersion curve

Long wavelengths (k → 0). sin(ka/2) ≈ ka/2, so ω ≈ a √(K/m) k = v k, with v = a √(K/m). This is a sound wave. The speed v does not depend on k, and for atoms 0.25 nm apart with a typical bond stiffness it comes out near 4 km/s, the observed speed of sound in metals. Real crystals have v = √(modulus/density), and the chain model reproduces that form (K a plays the role of Young's modulus times area).

The maximum frequency. ω reaches its peak ω_max = 2√(K/m) at ka = π, where neighboring atoms move in exact opposition. Typical values are ω_max ≈ 10¹³ to 10¹⁴ rad/s, i.e., frequencies of a few terahertz. No wave of higher frequency exists in the chain: the lattice acts as a low-pass filter. The shortest wavelength is λ_min = 2a, because a pattern of atoms cannot vary on a scale shorter than two lattice spacings.

The group velocity. v_g = dω/dk = a √(K/m) cos(ka/2). It equals the sound speed at small k and falls to zero at the zone edge k = π/a. At the edge the wave is a standing wave: the energy does not move. This is the first example of a Bragg reflection of a wave by a periodic structure; the same thing will happen to electrons in Chapter 5.

The Brillouin zone

Replace k by k + 2π/a. Then e^{i(k+2π/a)na} = e^{ikna} e^{2πin} = e^{ikna}: the displacement pattern of atoms is identical. The new k describes the same physical wave because atoms exist only at the points x = n a. Hence every distinct wave can be labeled with k in an interval of length 2π/a, conventionally −π/a < k ≤ π/a. This is the first Brillouin zone, and 2π/a is the reciprocal lattice vector G of the chain (Lesson 250 generalizes this). Notice ω(k + G) = ω(k): the dispersion is periodic in k.

Counting modes

Choose periodic boundary conditions: u_{n+N} = u_n for a ring of N atoms (length L = N a). Then e^{ikNa} = 1, so k = 2π j/(N a) for integer j. Within the zone we have exactly N allowed values (j from −N/2 to N/2). So the chain with N atoms has N modes, equal to the number of degrees of freedom. In three dimensions, with N atoms in the sample, there are N allowed k values per branch, which prepares the ground for the Debye model. The spacing between neighboring allowed k values is 2π/L, extremely small for a macroscopic sample (L = 1 cm gives 6 × 10² m⁻¹ against a zone width of 10¹⁰ m⁻¹), so k can be treated as continuous.

Common misconceptions

"The wave carries atoms along." Each atom oscillates about a fixed position by a tiny amount. Only the pattern travels.

"Wavelengths shorter than 2a exist." They map onto longer waves. The zone limit is a statement about sampling, like aliasing in digital audio.

"Phase velocity equals group velocity." Only for k → 0. Near the zone edge ω/k stays positive but v_g → 0.

Try it

Python Dispersion and group velocity

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Python Check the formula numerically

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 · perfect!

  1. 1. The dispersion relation of the monatomic chain is

    Substituting a traveling wave into Newton's law gives −mω² = −4K sin²(ka/2), hence ω = 2√(K/m)|sin(ka/2)|.
  2. 2. What is the speed of sound in the long-wavelength limit?

    For small k, ω ≈ a√(K/m) k, so v = a√(K/m).
  3. 3. The group velocity at the zone edge k = π/a is

    dω/dk ∝ cos(ka/2) vanishes at ka = π; the wave is standing.
  4. 4. How many distinct normal modes does a chain of N atoms have?

    k = 2πj/(Na) takes N distinct values in the first Brillouin zone.
  5. 5. A chain has K = 20 N/m, m = 1 × 10⁻²⁵ kg and a = 0.25 nm. What is the sound speed?

    v = a√(K/m) = 2.5 × 10⁻¹⁰ × √(2 × 10²⁶) = 2.5 × 10⁻¹⁰ × 1.414 × 10¹³ ≈ 3,540 m/s.

Summary

  • The chain obeys m ü_n = K(u_{n+1} + u_{n−1} − 2u_n); a traveling wave gives ω = 2√(K/m)|sin(ka/2)|.
  • Small k: ω = vk with v = a√(K/m), the speed of sound. At the zone edge v_g = 0 and ω is maximal.
  • Wave vectors differing by 2π/a describe the same motion, so k lives in the first Brillouin zone and there are N modes.
  • Periodic boundary conditions make k discrete with spacing 2π/L, effectively a continuum for macroscopic samples.

Next: Optical and acoustic branches