Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 34 of 46 ยท Institutions: Family, Education, Religion

Religion and Society

How do sociologists study religion without judging beliefs? Compare Durkheim, Marx and Weber, learn church-sect types and the secularization debate, with two hands-on demos.

Religion has shaped laws, calendars, families, wars, art and charity in nearly every society we know. Sociologists study it in a particular way: they do not ask whether any belief is true. They ask what religion does in society, how it is organized, and how it changes. A sociologist can study a mosque, a temple, a church or a secular movement with the same tools.

Three cards comparing Durkheim, Marx and Weber on religion.
Three classic views of religion: solidarity, comfort and control, and ideas that shape action.

What you will learn

  • Explain Durkheim's, Marx's and Weber's classic arguments about religion.
  • Distinguish church, denomination, sect and new religious movement.
  • Summarize the secularization debate and its main rival ideas.
  • Practice measuring and plotting a relationship with a simple model.

Key terms

Sacred and profane: things set apart and treated with reverence versus ordinary things (Durkheim). Collective effervescence: the shared emotional energy of gatherings and rituals (Durkheim). Secularization: the decline of the social influence of religion. Church-sect typology: a classification of religious groups by their relation to the surrounding society.

Durkheim: religion as the worship of society

In The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (1912), ร‰mile Durkheim studied totemism among Aboriginal Australian clans, using the best accounts available to him, which later anthropologists have criticized. He argued that all religions divide the world into the sacred and the profane and that sacred objects stand for the group itself. When people gather for ritual and feel carried along by the crowd, they experience collective effervescence, which renews their sense of belonging and shared values. Seen this way, a religion's most important effect is solidarity: it binds people, gives shared symbols and marks the moral boundaries of the community.

Durkheim's idea explains why national flags, anthems and civic ceremonies can work like religion. Robert Bellah (1967) called this civil religion.

Marx: religion, comfort and control

Karl Marx wrote in 1843-44 that religion is "the opium of the people." The phrase is often misread as a simple insult. In context he also calls religion "the sigh of the oppressed creature" and "the heart of a heartless world," acknowledging real comfort. His criticism was that religion can ease suffering while leaving the conditions that cause it untouched, and can make unjust arrangements seem natural or divinely ordained. Later scholars also noted the opposite: religion has often fueled protest, from abolitionist churches to liberation theology and the US civil rights movement. Both effects can occur.

Weber: ideas that shape action

In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1905), Max Weber asked why modern rational capitalism first flourished in parts of northwestern Europe. He pointed to certain Protestant, especially Calvinist, ideas: the belief in predestination (that God has already chosen who is saved), together with the idea of a worldly calling (Beruf), pushed believers to work hard, save and reinvest as signs of grace without spending for luxury. Over time, Weber suggested, the religious motive faded and the habits remained. He did not argue that religion alone caused capitalism, and he wrote comparative studies of religion in China, India and ancient Judaism. Historians still debate the thesis and its evidence.

Weber also described disenchantment: a modern world in which calculation and bureaucracy replace magic and mystery as ways of seeing things.

Types of religious organization

Sociologists (starting with Weber and Ernst Troeltsch, and extended by H. Richard Niebuhr) classify religious groups by how they relate to the society around them.

Type Relation to society Typical features
Church Low tension; closely tied to society Membership often by birth; broad; formal clergy
Denomination Low tension; one of several accepted groups Joined by family tradition or choice; tolerant
Sect High tension; protests the mainstream Often splits from another group; strict standards; voluntary
New religious movement (cult) High tension; novel to the society New beliefs or practices; often charismatic leader

The terms are technical. "Cult" in everyday speech is often an insult, so many scholars prefer "new religious movement." A group can move along the scale over time: many sects calm down and become denominations as they grow.

JS Classify a group by its features (a teaching rule set)

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Secularization: has religion declined?

The secularization thesis, rooted in Comte, Weber and Durkheim, says that modernization (science, education, cities, bureaucracy) reduces the social influence of religion. Evidence in its favor includes falling church attendance and rising numbers of people with no religious affiliation in much of Western Europe and increasingly elsewhere, such as Canada, Australia and the United States.

But the picture is mixed:

  • Global religion remains strong. Many countries in Africa, Asia and the Americas show high religious participation, and global projections by demographers suggest the religious population will remain large, partly because of differences in birth rates.
  • Peter Berger, a leading secularization theorist, argued by the late 1990s that the world is "as furiously religious as it ever was," except in parts of Europe and among some intellectual elites.
  • Rational choice theorists such as Rodney Stark and Roger Finke argue that competition between religious groups raises participation, so diversity can boost religion rather than reduce it.
  • Existential security. Pippa Norris and Ronald Inglehart (2004) argued that religion declines where people feel economically and physically secure, and persists where life remains risky. Cross-national data fit this pattern in many cases, but critics point to exceptions.
  • Believing without belonging. Grace Davie coined the phrase for people who hold beliefs but do not attend, and others note the opposite, belonging without believing.

The debate shows how a single claim, "modern societies become less religious," needs careful definitions: belief, practice, public influence and personal importance can each move differently.

Python A scatter-plot practice: ritual participation and belonging (invented data)

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The data above are made up to practice drawing and describing a relationship. Real studies must also ask which way the effect runs (does ritual create belonging, or do people who feel they belong attend more?) and what else might explain both.

Common misconceptions

"Sociologists of religion try to prove religion false (or true)." They study its social causes and effects without ruling on beliefs.

"Marx only said religion is a drug." He also described it as comfort for the suffering, and religion has been a force for protest as well as for order.

"Secularization means religion disappears." Evidence shows decline in some places and growth or persistence in others.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 6 questions

of 6 answered You scored / 6 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. In Durkheim's view, religion's main social function is

    Sacred things represent the group, and ritual renews its bonds.
  2. 2. Which concept names the emotional energy of group ritual?

    Durkheim used it for the shared excitement of gatherings.
  3. 3. Weber's Protestant ethic thesis links Calvinist beliefs with

    He argued that ideas of calling and predestination fostered habits that suited capitalism.
  4. 4. A religious group in high tension with society that split from a larger group is typically a

    Sects are high-tension and often break away from a parent group.
  5. 5. Norris and Inglehart's 'existential security' idea predicts that religion

    They argued that insecurity sustains religiosity.
  6. 6. Which statement about secularization is best supported?

    The picture is mixed, which is why the debate continues.

Summary

  • Sociologists study what religion does and how it is organized, without judging beliefs.
  • Durkheim: solidarity and the sacred; Marx: comfort and control (and sometimes protest); Weber: ideas shaping action.
  • Church, denomination, sect and new religious movement differ by tension with society and origins.
  • The secularization thesis is contested; global patterns are mixed.

Next: Chapter 7 review