Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 41 of 46 Β· Religion, Society and Ethics

Religion, Society and Ethics: Chapter Review

Review religion in society: classic theories, secularization, church-state models, ethics and the science-religion models, with a table, flashcards and a ten-question quiz.

This chapter shifted from individual traditions to the questions that run across all of them: why religion exists and how it changes, how states handle religious diversity, how traditions reason about right and wrong and how religion relates to science. Each question has several good answers, and the skill you have practiced is describing those answers fairly and attributing them to the people who hold them.

A summary table of the chapter: theories, secularization, law and state, ethics, science and religion
Caption: Five parts of the chapter and the key idea to remember for each.

The chapter in a table

Topic Key facts Where to look again
Classic theories Durkheim (1912), Weber (1904 to 1905), Marx (1843) Religion and society
Secularization Decline in some regions, growth in others; revisions by Davie, Norris and Inglehart, Stark Religion and society
Law and the state Article 18 (1948); established church, separation, laΓ―citΓ©, cooperation, principled distance Religion and society
Conflict and peace Religion is one marker among ethnicity, history and politics Religion and society
Ethics Revelation and law; natural law; virtue; compassion; the Golden Rule in many forms Ethics and science
Science Conflict thesis (Draper, White) is too simple; Barbour's four models Ethics and science

Putting it together

A strong study of any religious topic uses several of these lenses at once. Suppose you want to understand a dispute about religious dress in a public school. The sociological lens asks what the clothing means to the community and what the school symbolizes. The legal lens asks what a particular country's constitution and international law say about free exercise and neutrality. The ethical lens asks how the tradition itself reasons about modesty and obligation, and who within the tradition holds which view. The historical lens asks how the issue arose. And the comparative lens asks whether other countries handle it differently. No single lens is enough, and each one protects you from the blind spots of the others.

The same approach works for questions about science and ethics. If a news story claims that "science has disproved religion," ask which religion and which claim, whether the claim is empirical, and which of Barbour's models the speaker assumes. If a debate about a moral issue is framed as "religion versus secular society," ask which traditions and which members are involved, because religious voices usually appear on several sides.

Notice also the importance of language. Words such as "secular," "fundamentalist," "radical" and "cult" carry judgments, and scholars try to use them with care. When in doubt, describe what people do and say, and quote their own terms where you can.

Questions to think about

  • Which classical theory best explains the role of festivals in a community, and what might it miss?
  • Why do scholars now speak of several processes of secularization rather than one?
  • Which church-state model is most familiar to you, and what are its strengths and challenges?
  • Pick a topic from the applied debates, such as the environment, and describe two positions within one tradition.
  • Which of Barbour's models best fits the views of people you know, and why?

Common misconceptions

"Social theories of religion prove religion is merely social." Theories explain functions and effects; they do not by themselves settle questions about truth, which are outside the scope of sociology.

"Each religion speaks with a single voice on ethics." Every tradition contains debate and diversity.

Try it

Chapter 8 flashcards
Which theorist?

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 9 questions

of 9 answered You scored / 9 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. Who wrote The Elementary Forms of Religious Life?

    Durkheim published it in 1912, based on studies of clan ceremonies.
  2. 2. Which pair describes the 'conflict thesis' authors?

    Draper (1874) and White (1896) popularized it.
  3. 3. Which church-state model does France's 1905 law represent?

    The law separated churches and state.
  4. 4. Which is NOT one of Glock and Stark's dimensions?

    The five are belief, practice, experience, knowledge and consequences.
  5. 5. The best summary of the secularization debate is:

    Evidence varies by region, and scholars distinguish several processes.
  6. 6. What is Barbour's 'independence' model?

    Independence holds that they have separate domains and methods.
  7. 7. Which text is associated with Catholic social teaching beginning in 1891?

    Pope Leo XIII's Rerum Novarum (1891) addressed workers' rights and the common good.
  8. 8. What did Weber call authority based on exceptional personal qualities?

    Charismatic authority, as in a prophet, is later routinized in institutions.
  9. 9. Which is a fair statement about religion and conflict?

    Scholars generally find multiple causes.

Summary

  • Durkheim, Weber and Marx give complementary accounts of religion; secularization is real in some places and absent in others.
  • States relate to religion in different ways, and freedom of religion or belief is protected in international law.
  • Religious ethics draws on revelation, reason, virtue and compassion, and traditions debate hard questions.
  • The science-religion relationship is better described by models than by a single story of warfare.

Next: Projects and practice: a comparative study