Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 43 of 46 ยท Projects and Practice

Practice: Five Case Studies in Religious Studies

Apply what you learned to five cases: a school timetable, clashing calendars, a disputed verse, a shared sacred city and food laws, with guiding questions and model answers.

Facts matter, but the skill that a religious studies course really builds is analysis: taking a concrete situation, asking good questions and giving a balanced answer. This lesson offers five case studies. Each has a short description, a set of guiding questions and a model approach that you can compare with your own. Try each case before you open the answer.

The cases are realistic scenarios or descriptions of well-known situations. They are meant to practice reasoning, not to settle legal or political disputes, and where something is contested the model answers say so.

Five cards listing the case studies: school timetable, calendars, a disputed verse, a shared sacred city and food laws
Caption: Five cases, each using a different set of tools from the course.

What you will learn

  • How to turn a scenario into questions about practice, belief, law and community.
  • How to use the seven dimensions and the idea of attribution in a case.
  • How to give a balanced answer when a situation is contested.
  • How to check your answers against a model.

Key terms

Accommodation: adjusting a rule or schedule so that a person can follow their religious practice.

Status quo: an agreed arrangement that regulates who may do what at a shared holy place.

Interpretation: the process of deciding what a text means, using methods and traditions of reading.

Dietary law: rules about what may be eaten and how food must be prepared.

Lunar and solar calendars: calendars following the moon or the sun, or both.

The five cases

Case 1: the school timetable. A school plans exams on a Friday afternoon, a Saturday morning and the first day of a spring festival. Students include Muslims who attend Friday congregational prayer (jumu'a), Jews who observe Shabbat, and Christians and Jews who observe Easter or Passover. Guiding questions: What is the practice in each case, and how strict is the obligation? How do different movements within a tradition differ? What are the interests of the students, of the school and of the other students? What compromise might be fair?

Case 2: calendars in collision. In some years Ramadan, Passover and Easter fall in the same few weeks. Guiding questions: Why do the dates of these festivals move through the Gregorian calendar? Which of the three calendars are lunar, which lunisolar and which fixed to the sun? What practical problems might a community or workplace face?

Case 3: an "eye for an eye." A speaker claims that the Torah teaches harsh literal revenge, and that Judaism is therefore "primitive." Guiding questions: Where does the phrase occur and in what context? How did the rabbis interpret it, and what does the Talmud do with it? What is the difference between the text and its reading tradition? How might you respond in an attributed way?

Case 4: a shared sacred city. Jerusalem contains the Western Wall and the Temple Mount, which is also the Haram al-Sharif with the Dome of the Rock and al-Aqsa Mosque, and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Guiding questions: Why is the city sacred to Jews, Christians and Muslims? How is access to the sites arranged? What does the arrangement of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre among several Christian denominations illustrate? How should a writer discuss the political aspects fairly?

Case 5: what's on the plate. A catering company wants to serve a conference with Jewish, Muslim and Hindu guests. Guiding questions: What are the basic ideas of kashrut and halal? Where do they overlap and where do they differ? What other dietary traditions might apply? What is the difference between a rule observed by all members of a tradition and one that varies?

A timeline of spring 2023 when Ramadan, Passover and Western Easter all fell within a few weeks
Caption: In spring 2023 Ramadan, Passover and Easter overlapped (Ramadan dates vary by local moon sighting).

A five-step method for any case

Use the same routine each time and your answers will become faster and sharper.

  1. Describe the facts. Say what is happening, who is involved and what is known. Separate what is certain (a calendar rule) from what is disputed (a legal or political claim).
  2. Identify the tradition's own view. Use primary sources or authoritative statements, and say which movement or school you are describing. Remember that practice varies within every tradition.
  3. Apply a tool. Pick the lens that fits: the seven dimensions for a practice, a theory of society for a community question, a model such as Barbour's for a science question, or a calendar rule for a date question.
  4. Weigh the interests and values. Who is affected, and what do they stand to gain or lose? Name competing goods, such as religious freedom and equal treatment, without pretending they never conflict.
  5. Conclude with a clear, attributed claim. State what the evidence shows and what remains uncertain. Avoid phrases that smuggle in judgments.

Marking yourself

Give yourself a point for each of the following: you stated the facts correctly; you attributed beliefs; you noted variation within the tradition; you used at least one idea from the course by name; and you avoided loaded language. Four points out of five is a strong answer.

Model approaches

Open each card in the first activity below after you have written your own answer. These models show the style of reasoning, not the only valid answer.

Common misconceptions

"A balanced answer means refusing to say anything." A balanced answer makes clear claims about what traditions say, supports them with evidence and explains where disagreements lie.

"Every case has one right answer." Some cases have settled facts (calendar rules) and others involve values and law (accommodation), where reasonable people disagree.

"If I know the tradition's rule, I know what every member does." Practice varies by movement, region and individual.

Try it

Model answers
Which of Smart's dimensions?

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What does it mean to give a balanced answer?

    A balanced answer is clear and evidence-based while attributing beliefs and presenting different views.
  2. 2. Why does Ramadan move through the seasons?

    A year of twelve lunar months is about 11 days shorter than a solar year.
  3. 3. How did rabbinic tradition generally read 'an eye for an eye'?

    The Talmud discusses compensation for injury.
  4. 4. Which statement about kosher and halal is accurate?

    Both forbid pork and require prescribed slaughter; they differ on meat-dairy separation and on alcohol, for example.

Summary

  • Cases turn knowledge into analysis: identify the practice, the strictness, the movements and the interests.
  • Use dimensions, calendars, interpretation traditions and attribution as tools.
  • Contested cases need clear description of each party's view, without taking a side.

Next: Glossary