Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 34 of 44 ยท Religion and Meaning

Chapter Review: Religion and Meaning

A recap of the arguments about God, the problem of evil and theories of meaning, with a comparison table and a nine-question chapter quiz.

This chapter covered some of the oldest arguments in philosophy. Here is the whole picture in one place, followed by a quiz that mixes the three lessons.

Four cards summarizing arguments about God, evil, meaning and doubt
Chapter 7 at a glance: four ideas to remember.

Recap table

Argument or view Core idea Classic reply
Ontological (Anselm) God's concept implies God's existence Gaunilo's island; Kant: existence is not a predicate
Cosmological (Aquinas, Leibniz, kalam) The universe needs a cause or explanation Why not a brute fact? Why call the cause God?
Design (Paley, fine-tuning) Order points to a designer Hume, Darwin, anthropic selection, multiverse
Pascal's wager Belief has the best expected payoff Many gods; belief is not a choice
Logical problem of evil (Mackie) God, goodness and evil are inconsistent Plantinga's free will defense
Evidential problem (Rowe) Pointless evil makes God unlikely Skeptical theism; theodicies
Subjectivism Meaning is what you care about The grass-counter objection
Hybrid (Wolf) Fitting fulfillment Who decides what is worthwhile?
Absurdism (Camus) Revolt against a silent universe Is happiness in revolt enough?

How to use these arguments

  1. Write each argument as numbered premises and a conclusion. If you cannot, you do not yet understand it.
  2. Test validity first, then each premise. The kalam argument is valid, and the debate is about soundness.
  3. Name the cost. Skeptical theism undermines moral knowledge; soul-making struggles with animal pain; subjectivism counts obsessions as meaningful.
  4. Hold views with reasons, and know the best objection to your own. That is the mark of a mature stance, whatever the conclusion.

Try writing a two-sentence summary of each lesson: one sentence for the argument, one for its strongest reply. If you can do that without notes, you are ready for the next chapter.

Try it

JS Match the argument to its reply

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Chapter quiz

Quick check ยท 9 questions

of 9 answered You scored / 9 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Anselm defined God as

    This definition is the starting point of the ontological argument.
  2. 2. Which reply used a perfect island as a parody?

    Gaunilo argued the same form of reasoning would prove an absurd conclusion.
  3. 3. What is Paley's design argument based on?

    A watch implies a watchmaker; living things imply a designer.
  4. 4. What makes an argument sound?

    Validity concerns form; soundness adds true premises.
  5. 5. Which premise in Mackie's argument do theists usually deny?

    The bridge premise is the natural target.
  6. 6. What did Rowe's fawn example illustrate?

    He used it to argue that some evil seems gratuitous.
  7. 7. Which theory of meaning requires both being engaged and the object being worthwhile?

    Fitting fulfillment needs subjective attraction meeting objective attractiveness.
  8. 8. In Camus's view, how should we respond to the absurd?

    He rejects both escape and the leap.
  9. 9. What does 'steel-manning' help you do?

    It is a habit of fair and useful argument.

Summary

  • Arguments about God come in four families, each with classic replies; evaluate validity then soundness.
  • The logical problem of evil is widely thought answered by the free will defense; the evidential problem remains debated.
  • Theories of meaning vary on how much depends on you; Wolf's hybrid and Camus's revolt are two influential views.
  • Mature thinking means knowing the best objection to your own view.

Next: Chapter overview: Political and Social Philosophy