Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 19 of 44 ยท Knowledge and Skepticism

Chapter 4 Review: Knowledge and Skepticism

Review the Gettier problem, the debate between rationalists and empiricists, Kant's synthesis and skeptical arguments with a recap table, a tool and a ten-question quiz.

You have followed philosophy's most famous question, "what can we know?", from the simple definition of knowledge as justified true belief to the stairs of doubt that lead to Descartes' cogito. This review gathers the chapter into one picture, shows where each idea lives in the lessons and then tests you. Notice how often you use chapter 3: skeptical arguments are valid-or-not arguments, and replies to them are premises you can accept or reject.

Three cards: defining knowledge, sources of knowledge and skepticism, with two points to keep in mind
Chapter 4 in one picture: what knowledge is, where it comes from, and how doubt tests it.

What you will learn

  • A recap of the chapter in one table.
  • How the three main lessons connect.
  • Where to go next in the course.

Recap table

Idea Summary Lesson
Kinds of knowing Knowing that, knowing how, acquaintance Overview
Sources Perception, reason, testimony, memory, introspection Overview
JTB Knowledge = justified true belief Justified True Belief
Gettier problem Justified true belief that is true by luck (1963) Justified True Belief
Replies to Gettier No false lemmas, causal, reliabilism, safety, virtue, knowledge-first Justified True Belief
A priori / a posteriori How a claim can be known Rationalism vs Empiricism
Analytic / synthetic What makes a claim true Rationalism vs Empiricism
Rationalism / empiricism Reason vs experience as the source Rationalism vs Empiricism
Kant's synthesis Experience gives content, the mind gives structure Rationalism vs Empiricism
Method of doubt Senses, dreams, evil demon, cogito Skepticism and Descartes
Replies to skepticism Moore, Putnam, contextualism, best explanation, denying closure Skepticism and Descartes

How the pieces fit

Start with the definition: knowledge needs truth, belief and justification, plus something that rules out luck. Then ask where justification comes from: reason, experience or both? Finally test the whole thing with the skeptic, who asks whether any of our evidence can rule out a scenario in which we are fooled. Notice the pattern: a proposal, a counterexample, a repair. That is the same cycle you practiced in chapter 1, from thought experiments to reflective equilibrium.

Try writing a three-sentence answer to "Do I know that I am awake?" that mentions one idea from each of the chapter's three lessons. If you can, you have the chapter.

Common misconceptions

"Gettier proved we know nothing." He showed that a particular definition was inadequate.

"Rationalists and empiricists disagreed about whether to use evidence." They disagreed about the sources and justification of certain kinds of knowledge.

"The cogito shows I have a body." It shows only that a thinking thing exists.

Try it

Which view said it?
JS Apply a repair to Gettier

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A Gettier case is

    Gettier cases show that justification and truth together can still leave the belief accidentally true.
  2. 2. Which condition is part of the traditional analysis of knowledge?

    The traditional analysis requires truth, belief and justification.
  3. 3. Rationalists such as Descartes and Leibniz held that

    Rationalism stresses reason and innate ideas, with mathematics as the model.
  4. 4. Hume's fork divides objects of reasoning into

    Relations of ideas are known by thought and are certain; matters of fact depend on experience.
  5. 5. Which statement is a priori?

    It is true by the meaning of its terms and needs no survey.
  6. 6. In Descartes' method of doubt, which step comes after the dream argument?

    The order is senses, dreams, evil demon, then the cogito.
  7. 7. Kant claimed that

    He argued that experience supplies content and the mind supplies concepts and forms.
  8. 8. The closure-based skeptical argument is valid. How can one resist it?

    A valid argument forces you to accept the conclusion only if you accept the premises, so replies target a premise.
  9. 9. Which philosopher argued that a brain in a vat could not meaningfully think 'I am a brain in a vat'?

    Putnam's semantic externalist reply says the words of a vat-brain would not refer to real vats.
  10. 10. Why does the Bayesian demonstration suggest the skeptic's challenge is hard to answer with evidence alone?

    When likelihoods are equal, the posterior equals the prior, so the answer depends on prior plausibility such as simplicity.

Summary

  • The traditional analysis (justified true belief) faces Gettier cases of lucky justified true belief; no repair is universally accepted.
  • Rationalists stress reason and innate ideas; empiricists stress experience; Kant combines them.
  • Descartes' doubt moves from the senses to dreams to the evil demon to the cogito.
  • Replies to skepticism include Moore's common sense, Putnam's semantic argument, contextualism and best-explanation reasoning.
  • Chapters 5 to 9 apply these tools to minds, freedom, religion, politics and your own projects.

Next: Chapter overview: Mind and Reality