Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 24 of 44 ยท Mind and Reality

Chapter Review: Mind and Reality

A one-page recap of dualism, behaviorism, identity theory, functionalism and the hard problem, with a comparison table and a ten-question chapter quiz.

You have now met the main positions on the mind-body problem, and each one was a response to a flaw in an earlier view. This review puts them side by side, shows how they relate, and tests whether you can use them, not just recall them.

A hub with five spokes summarizing the chapter
The chapter in one picture: every view is an answer to the previous view's weak point.

The chapter in one grid

Two questions sort the major positions: what is the basic stuff of the world, and can science fully explain the mind?

A two by two grid sorting functionalism, explanatory-gap physicalism, idealism and dualism
Two questions, four families. Most of the real debate happens along the top row, between those who think the gap is real and those who think it will close.

Recap table

View Core claim Chief support Chief problem
Substance dualism Mind and body are different substances Descartes' doubt argument; apparent privacy of experience Interaction (Elisabeth); causal closure
Property dualism One substance, irreducibly mental properties Mary; zombies Why do those properties go with brains?
Epiphenomenalism Experience causes nothing Fits physical closure Seems to make experience pointless
Behaviorism Mind is behavior or disposition Avoids the ghost (Ryle) Super-spartans; circular definitions
Identity theory Mental types are brain types Science discovers identities Multiple realizability
Functionalism Mind is causal role Explains realizability; supports AI Chinese Room; qualia
Eliminativism Folk psychology may be replaced Compare phlogiston Seems to deny what we know best
Idealism Reality is mental Berkeley's argument about ideas Explaining the stable, shared physical world
Illusionism Phenomenal feel is a misrepresentation Dissolves the hard problem Seems to explain away the data

When you meet a new theory, fill in this table row for it: claim, support, problem. It is the fastest way to understand and compare positions.

Skills to take with you

  1. Locate the exact joint. Descartes' argument turns on Leibniz's Law; Mary's argument turns on whether knowing facts and knowing what it is like are the same thing.
  2. Distinguish conceivable from possible. The zombie argument depends on that step.
  3. Ask what the view costs. Every position here has a price. Calling a view "obvious" usually means you have not found it yet.
  4. Separate empirical from philosophical questions. Which brain regions correlate with consciousness is empirical; whether correlation could ever explain experience is philosophical.

Try it

Which position are you closest to?

Chapter quiz

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which argument relies on Leibniz's Law?

    Descartes argues that the mind has a property (being indubitable) the body lacks, so they are not identical.
  2. 2. What did Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia ask Descartes?

    Her question started the interaction problem for substance dualism.
  3. 3. Epiphenomenalism says that

    Mental events are by-products with no causal power.
  4. 4. What did Jackson's Mary argument target?

    If Mary learns something new, there are non-physical facts about experience, said the original argument.
  5. 5. Why does multiple realizability trouble identity theory?

    If pain were one human brain state, creatures with different brains could not feel pain.
  6. 6. What is functionalism's central claim?

    That is how it allows many realizations.
  7. 7. What is the point of Searle's Chinese Room?

    Searle follows rules with no grasp of meaning; he draws a conclusion about syntax and semantics.
  8. 8. Which is an 'easy problem' in Chalmers' sense?

    Easy problems concern mechanisms; the hard problem concerns why experience exists.
  9. 9. What is the explanatory gap?

    Levine's term for how a physical story seems not to entail what the experience is like.
  10. 10. Which theory says the puzzle of experience arises from the brain's self-model?

    Illusionists (Dennett, Frankish) aim to explain why we think we have inexplicable experience.

Summary

  • Each position responds to a problem in an earlier one: dualism to physicalism's silence on feeling, behaviorism to dualism's ghost, identity theory to behaviorism's gaps, functionalism to multiple realizability.
  • The hard problem is the live frontier; theories differ on whether it is real.
  • Evaluate positions by claim, support and cost.

Next: Chapter overview: Free Will and Personal Identity