Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 29 of 45 ยท Metaethics

Chapter 6 review: a map of metaethics

Review chapter 6 with a two-question map of metaethical positions, a recap table of arguments and objections, and a ten-question mixed quiz.

Metaethics can feel like a jumble of -isms. The trick to keeping them straight is to ask two questions of any position: What do moral claims do? (state beliefs or express attitudes) and Is there anything that makes them true independent of minds? Nearly every view lands in a different place on that grid.

A two by two grid. Columns: moral claims state beliefs or express attitudes. Rows: moral facts independent of minds exist or not. Realism is beliefs plus facts, error theory and constructivism are beliefs without independent facts, expressivism is attitudes without facts, and attitudes with independent facts is a rarely defended empty cell.
Chapter 6 in one picture: two questions place almost every metaethical position.

What you will review

  • The grid of positions and the main argument for and against each.
  • The is-ought gap, direction of fit and the Frege-Geach problem.
  • What moral psychology and evolution do and do not show.

Key terms

Cognitivism / non-cognitivism: moral claims express beliefs / attitudes.

Realism / anti-realism: there are / are not stance-independent moral facts.

Error theory: moral claims are cognitive but all false.

Quasi-realism: expressivism that earns the language of truth.

Debunking: undermining a belief by showing its origin is unconnected to its truth.

Recap table

Position What moral claims do Are there independent facts? Key thinkers Main objection
Naturalist realism State beliefs Yes, natural Boyd, Sturgeon, Brink Open question argument
Non-naturalist realism State beliefs Yes, sui generis Moore, Parfit, Enoch Queerness; how do we know them?
Error theory State beliefs (all false) No Mackie, Joyce Seems to undermine morality or be unstable
Expressivism Express attitudes or plans No Ayer, Stevenson, Hare, Blackburn, Gibbard Frege-Geach; mistakes of morality
Constructivism State beliefs true by procedure Procedure-dependent Korsgaard, Street, Rawls Is the procedure itself moral?

Arguments to remember

  • Open question argument (Moore): for any natural definition of good, it still seems open whether it is good.
  • Queerness and relativity (Mackie): objective values would be strange, and moral variation suggests a human origin.
  • Direction of fit: beliefs fit the world, desires try to make the world fit them. Moral judgments seem to motivate.
  • Frege-Geach (1960s): attitudes cannot sit in "if" clauses; how can moral reasoning be valid?
  • Is-ought gap (Hume): an ought needs an ought-bridge.
  • Haidt and Greene: intuition and dual processes shape judgment; evidence is mixed and not normative.
  • Debunking (Street, Joyce): evolutionary origins may undermine realism, but replies say the argument over-generalizes.

Common misconceptions

"Cognitivism equals realism." Error theorists and constructivists are cognitivists without being realists.

"Expressivism is relativism." Relativism says truth varies with the code; expressivism is about what moral claims do.

"Psychology answers metaethics." It supplies evidence about how judgment works; philosophers argue over what follows.

Try it

Python Place the position on the grid

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

JS Frege-Geach: spot the pattern

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which position is cognitivist but denies that any moral claim is true?

    Error theory says moral claims aim to state facts, but none exist, so all are false.
  2. 2. The open question argument was developed by

    Moore (Principia Ethica, 1903) used it against naturalistic definitions of good.
  3. 3. Which pair of terms best fits expressivism?

    Expressivists say moral claims express attitudes, plans or norms.
  4. 4. In direction-of-fit terms, which is the odd one out?

    A shopping list has world-to-word fit; the others aim to match the world.
  5. 5. What is the Frege-Geach problem about?

    It asks how moral sentences keep meaning when embedded, for example in an if-clause.
  6. 6. Which of these is a fair summary of Mackie's argument from relativity?

    Mackie used variation in moral codes to argue that objective values are an implausible explanation.
  7. 7. Which statement is accurate?

    Constructivism has moral truth fixed by a procedure; it is cognitivist but not stance-independent realism.
  8. 8. What is an evolutionary debunking argument?

    Street and Joyce argued that if evolution shaped our moral attitudes without regard to truth, belief in moral truth lacks support.
  9. 9. The is-ought gap means that

    A bridging normative premise is required.
  10. 10. Which would be the most careful conclusion from Haidt's moral dumbfounding studies?

    The findings support a role for intuition without proving that reasoning is idle.

Summary

  • Place any metaethical view by what moral claims do and whether independent facts exist.
  • The main arguments: open question, queerness, direction of fit, Frege-Geach, is-ought and debunking.
  • Moral psychology describes how judgment works; it does not settle what we ought to do.
  • A careful student can hold a firm moral view and still be unsure about its metaethical foundation.

Next: Chapter 7 overview: ethics in practice