Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 19 of 48 Β· Compact Objects

White dwarfs and the Chandrasekhar limit

Learn why white dwarfs do not collapse: electron degeneracy pressure, the mass-radius relation that shrinks with mass, the Chandrasekhar limit near 1.4 solar masses and Type Ia supernovae.

Sirius, the brightest star in the night sky, has a faint companion discovered in 1862: Sirius B. It is as massive as the Sun but only as big as Earth, and its density is millions of times that of water. When astronomers first worked this out in the early 20th century, many did not believe it. The explanation needed the new quantum theory: electrons crowded together push back, however cold they are. This lesson shows how, and why that push has a maximum strength, which sets an upper mass limit for white dwarfs.

Left: a cross-section of a white dwarf with a dashed circle for Earth's size. Right: a ladder of electron energy levels filled up to the Fermi level
A white dwarf is a carbon-oxygen crystal ball about as big as Earth; electrons fill energy levels two at a time, which creates degeneracy pressure.

What you will learn

  • What a white dwarf is made of and how dense it is.
  • How electron degeneracy pressure arises from the Pauli exclusion principle.
  • Why more massive white dwarfs are smaller, and where the Chandrasekhar limit comes from.
  • How white dwarfs cool, and how accreting ones become Type Ia supernovae.

Key terms

Pauli exclusion principle: no two electrons (fermions) can occupy the same quantum state.

Degenerate gas: a gas so dense that its pressure comes from the exclusion principle, not from temperature.

Fermi energy (E_F): the energy of the highest filled level in a cold degenerate gas.

Chandrasekhar limit: the maximum mass of a white dwarf supported by electron degeneracy, about 1.4 solar masses.

Cooling age: the time since a white dwarf formed, estimated from its temperature.

What a white dwarf is

A white dwarf is the exposed core of a star that has lost its outer layers (chapter 3). Most are made of carbon and oxygen from helium burning, with a thin skin of hydrogen and helium on top. Typical white dwarfs have a mass of about 0.6 solar masses and a radius of about 8,700 km, similar to Earth. The mean density is 0.6 Γ— 1.99Γ—10³⁰ kg / (4/3 Ο€ (8.7Γ—10⁢ m)Β³) β‰ˆ 4Γ—10⁸ kg/mΒ³: a teaspoon would weigh about two tonnes on Earth. A white dwarf has no fusion. It shines only by the heat stored in its ions, which is why it fades over billions of years.

Degeneracy pressure

Electrons are fermions. The Pauli exclusion principle says at most two of them (spin up and spin down) can occupy the same energy level in a given volume. Squeeze a gas of electrons into a smaller volume and the levels spread farther apart, because each electron's wave must fit into less space. The lowest levels fill first, and the rest of the electrons must occupy higher and higher levels, even at zero temperature. Those energetic electrons exert pressure.

The energy of the highest filled level is the Fermi energy:

E_F = (Δ§Β² / 2 m_e) (3π² n_e)^(2/3)

where n_e is the electron number density. For a white dwarf with ρ = 4Γ—10⁸ kg/mΒ³ and two nucleons per electron, n_e β‰ˆ 1.3Γ—10³⁡ m⁻³, giving E_F β‰ˆ 0.09 MeV. The thermal energy k T at 10,000 K is only 0.86 eV, a hundred thousand times smaller. Temperature is irrelevant: the gas is degenerate. In the Sun's core, by contrast, E_F is below k T and the gas behaves like an ordinary ideal gas.

For non-relativistic electrons the pressure scales as P ∝ n_e^(5/3) ∝ ρ^(5/3). Balancing this against gravity gives a surprising result: R ∝ M^(βˆ’1/3). More massive white dwarfs are smaller. Add mass and the star shrinks.

The Chandrasekhar limit

If you keep adding mass, the star shrinks, the density rises, and eventually the electrons move at speeds close to c. Then the pressure grows more slowly, P ∝ ρ^(4/3), and degeneracy pressure can no longer keep up with gravity. In 1930, on a ship from India to England, 19-year-old Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar combined special relativity with the quantum theory of the electron gas and found a maximum mass:

M_Ch β‰ˆ 1.4 Mβ˜‰ (for a helium, carbon or oxygen composition with two nucleons per electron)

Above it, no stable white dwarf exists. A useful fit between mass and radius, including the relativistic cutoff, is the Nauenberg formula R β‰ˆ 0.0112 Rβ˜‰ √((M/M_Ch)^(βˆ’2/3) βˆ’ (M/M_Ch)^(2/3)): the radius reaches zero when M = M_Ch. Observed white dwarfs cluster near 0.6 solar masses and are rarely above 1.2. Chandrasekhar received the Nobel Prize in 1983. His idea was dismissed by Eddington at the time, since it implied that a star could collapse without limit.

Cooling and ageing

Without fusion, the white dwarf slowly radiates its heat. Young ones have surface temperatures over 100,000 K; old ones drop below 4,000 K after billions of years. As they cool, the carbon-oxygen ions freeze into a crystal lattice, an effect seen in Gaia data. The coolest white dwarfs in globular clusters imply cluster ages of 10 to 13 billion years, an independent check on the age of the universe.

Binaries: novae and Type Ia supernovae

A white dwarf in a close binary can pull gas from its companion. A layer of hydrogen builds up on its surface and ignites suddenly in a nova, which brightens the star for weeks but leaves it intact. If the white dwarf gains enough mass to approach M_Ch, or merges with another white dwarf, carbon ignites throughout the star and a thermonuclear explosion, a Type Ia supernova, destroys it, leaving no remnant. Because the trigger mass is close to a fixed value, the explosions have nearly the same peak luminosity, and astronomers use them as standard candles for measuring distances across the universe (chapter 2).

Common misconceptions

"A white dwarf is a star that is still burning." It has no fusion; it only cools.

"White dwarfs are hot, so degeneracy depends on temperature." The pressure comes from the exclusion principle and would exist at zero temperature.

"A more massive white dwarf is bigger." The reverse: radius shrinks as mass grows.

Try it

First, the mass-radius relation. The plot uses the Nauenberg fit; the points for Sirius B (1.0 solar mass, 0.0084 solar radii) are a check of the approximate formula.

Python The white dwarf mass-radius relation

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Second, test degeneracy: compare the Fermi energy of the electrons (or neutrons) with the thermal energy k T for different objects. A ratio far above 1 means pressure comes from the exclusion principle.

Python Is it degenerate?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. What is the main reason a white dwarf does not collapse?

    Electrons cannot all occupy the lowest levels, so a compressed electron gas pushes back even at zero temperature.
  2. 2. As you add mass to a white dwarf, its radius

    Degenerate stars follow R proportional to M^(-1/3) for low masses, and shrink toward zero at the Chandrasekhar mass.
  3. 3. The Chandrasekhar limit is about

    Above about 1.4 solar masses, relativistic electrons cannot supply enough pressure.
  4. 4. Why are Type Ia supernovae useful as standard candles?

    The trigger near the Chandrasekhar mass makes the explosions similar, so apparent brightness gives distance.
  5. 5. A white dwarf's thermal energy at 10,000 K compared with its Fermi energy is

    The Fermi energy is around 0.1 MeV; kT at 10,000 K is under 1 eV.

Summary

  • A white dwarf is an Earth-sized remnant of about 0.6 solar masses, with a density of around 10⁸–10⁹ kg/mΒ³.
  • Electron degeneracy pressure, from the Pauli exclusion principle, supports it; temperature plays almost no role.
  • More massive white dwarfs are smaller, and above the Chandrasekhar limit (about 1.4 Mβ˜‰) no white dwarf can exist.
  • White dwarfs cool for billions of years; accreting ones near the limit explode as Type Ia supernovae.

Next: Neutron stars and pulsars