Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 28 of 44 ยท Viscous Flow in Pipes

Turbulent flow and the friction factor

Find the Darcy friction factor for turbulent pipe flow with roughness, the Colebrook and Haaland equations and the Moody chart, with a worked head-loss example.

Almost every real pipe carries turbulent flow, and there is no exact solution. The velocity jumps around, eddies mix fluid from the center to the wall, and friction is several times larger than a laminar flow would give.

Engineers rely on experiments. Johann Nikuradse measured friction in pipes lined with sand grains in the 1930s, and Cyril Colebrook and Lewis Moody turned the data for commercial pipes into the formulas and chart still used today.

A Moody-style chart of friction factor versus Reynolds number with a laminar line and four roughness curves.
The friction factor falls with Reynolds number, then flattens at a value set by roughness alone.

What you will learn

  • What relative roughness ฮต/D is and where to find ฮต.
  • How to read the Moody chart, including the smooth and fully rough limits.
  • How to compute f with the Colebrook and Haaland equations.
  • How to solve the three standard pipe problems.

Key terms

Absolute roughness (ฮต): the typical height of bumps on the pipe wall, in meters or millimeters.

Relative roughness (ฮต/D): roughness divided by diameter. Roughness matters less in a wide pipe.

Hydraulically smooth: a turbulent flow whose viscous sublayer is thick enough to cover the roughness, so f depends only on Re.

Fully rough: a high-Re flow where f depends only on ฮต/D.

Why roughness matters only in turbulence

Right next to the wall there is a thin viscous sublayer where flow is laminar. At low Re the sublayer is thicker than the bumps, so the pipe behaves as if it were smooth. At high Re the sublayer shrinks, the bumps poke through, and each one sheds small wakes. Friction then depends on ฮต/D and no longer on Re.

Typical roughness values:

Pipe material ฮต (mm)
Drawn tubing, glass, plastic (PVC) 0.0015
Commercial steel, wrought iron 0.045
Galvanized iron 0.15
Cast iron 0.26
Concrete 0.3 to 3

These are typical for new pipe. Old pipes corrode and scale, and their ฮต can be several times larger.

The Moody chart

The chart in the picture plots f against Re on logarithmic axes:

  • For Re < 2,300 the straight laminar line f = 64/Re.
  • A shaded transition band between 2,300 and 4,000 where the value is uncertain.
  • For Re > 4,000 a family of curves, one for each ฮต/D. The lowest curve is the smooth-pipe limit. The curves become horizontal at high Re: the fully rough regime.

You enter with Re and ฮต/D, read off f, then use Darcy-Weisbach.

The Colebrook and Haaland equations

Reading a chart by eye is imprecise and cannot be used in code. The Colebrook equation (1939) describes the curves exactly:

1 / โˆšf = โˆ’2 logโ‚โ‚€( (ฮต/D) / 3.7 + 2.51 / (Re โˆšf) )

It is implicit: f appears on both sides, so you solve by iteration. Start with f = 0.02, evaluate the right side to get a new f, and repeat. It converges in a few steps.

Haaland's explicit approximation (1983) is accurate to within about 2 percent for turbulent flow:

1 / โˆšf = โˆ’1.8 logโ‚โ‚€( ((ฮต/D)/3.7)^1.11 + 6.9/Re )

It is perfect for a first estimate or a spreadsheet.

A worked example

Water at 20 ยฐC (ฯ = 998 kg/mยณ, ฮผ = 1.002 ร— 10โปยณ Paยทs) flows at V = 2 m/s in a commercial steel pipe, D = 100 mm, L = 100 m.

  1. Reynolds number: Re = 998 ร— 2 ร— 0.1 / 1.002 ร— 10โปยณ โ‰ˆ 199,000. Turbulent.
  2. Relative roughness: ฮต/D = 0.045 / 100 = 0.00045.
  3. Colebrook gives f โ‰ˆ 0.0186. Haaland gives 0.0184.
  4. Head loss: h_f = f (L/D) Vยฒ/(2g) = 0.0186 ร— 1,000 ร— 4 / 19.62 โ‰ˆ 3.8 m.
  5. Pressure drop: ฮ”p = ฯ g h_f โ‰ˆ 998 ร— 9.81 ร— 3.79 โ‰ˆ 37 kPa.

So moving this water 100 m costs roughly 3.8 meters of head, about 0.37 bar.

The three standard problems

Pipe flow problems come in three flavors, and the difficulty differs:

  1. Find the head loss given Q (or V), D, L, ฮต. Easy: compute Re, f, then h_f.
  2. Find the flow rate given h_f, D, L, ฮต. V is unknown, so Re and f are unknown. Iterate: guess f, compute V, update Re and f, repeat.
  3. Find the diameter given Q, h_f, L, ฮต. D appears in Re, ฮต/D and the loss formula. Iterate on D, or use a solver.

Computers make types 2 and 3 as easy as type 1.

Common misconceptions

"Rougher pipe means more loss at any speed." At low Reynolds numbers roughness hides in the viscous sublayer and has little effect. It matters most at high Re.

"The friction factor is a constant of the pipe." It changes with Re until the fully rough limit is reached. Reusing f from another flow rate is a common error.

"Fanning and Darcy friction factors are the same." They differ by a factor of 4 (f_Darcy = 4 f_Fanning). This course always uses Darcy.

Try it

First, solve Colebrook by iteration, compare it with Haaland, and compute the worked-example head loss.

Python Colebrook and Haaland solver

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Second, rebuild the Moody chart yourself. Change the list of roughness values to see how the family of curves moves.

Python Draw your own Moody chart

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What is the relative roughness of a 50 mm commercial steel pipe (eps = 0.045 mm)?

    eps/D = 0.045 mm / 50 mm = 0.0009.
  2. 2. In the fully rough regime the friction factor depends on:

    At very high Re the curves go flat, so f is set by the relative roughness alone.
  3. 3. Why is the Colebrook equation solved by iteration?

    The unknown f is inside a logarithm on the right-hand side, so it is implicit and needs repeated substitution.
  4. 4. Which problem needs iteration even with a computer-free Moody chart?

    When V is unknown, Re and therefore f are unknown, so you guess and refine.
  5. 5. A Fanning friction factor is 0.005. What is the Darcy factor?

    f_Darcy = 4 f_Fanning = 0.02.

Summary

  • Turbulent pipe friction depends on Re and ฮต/D; roughness matters only when the viscous sublayer is thin.
  • Use the Moody chart, the implicit Colebrook equation or the explicit Haaland approximation.
  • The standard workflow: Re, ฮต/D, f, h_f = f (L/D) Vยฒ/2g.
  • Flow-rate and diameter problems need iteration.
  • This course uses the Darcy friction factor.

Next: Minor losses and pipe systems