Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 28 of 43 ยท Risk Theory and Loss Models

Deductibles, Limits and Reinsurance

Value insurance contracts with deductibles, limits and coinsurance, compute loss elimination ratios, and compare quota share, excess of loss and stop loss reinsurance.

Few insurance contracts pay every cent of every loss. A car policy has an excess of 500; a liability policy has a limit of 1 million; a property insurer passes part of its own risk to a reinsurer. Each of these features changes what the insurer actually pays, and each changes the price. They also change behaviour: a policyholder with a deductible takes more care and does not report trivial claims.

This lesson gives you the arithmetic of these modifications. The core idea is that every modification is a function applied to the ground-up loss X, and its expected value is an integral of the survival function.

A single loss of 14,000 split between the policyholder, the insurer and a reinsurer
Who pays what: the policyholder keeps the deductible and anything above the limit, the insurer pays the middle layer and may pass part of it to a reinsurer.

What you will learn

  • Compute the expected payment per loss with a deductible, a limit and coinsurance.
  • Read a loss elimination ratio and explain why it depends on the tail.
  • Describe quota share, excess of loss and stop loss reinsurance.
  • Compare the effect of reinsurance on the insurer's retained risk.

Key terms

Ordinary deductible d: the insurer pays (X โˆ’ d)โบ, that is, the part of the loss above d.

Policy limit u: the maximum the insurer will pay.

Coinsurance ฮฑ: the insurer pays the fraction ฮฑ of the covered loss.

Loss elimination ratio (LER): the share of expected losses removed by a deductible.

Retention: the part of a loss the insurer keeps after reinsurance.

Modifying a single loss

Let X be the ground-up loss. Write X โˆง d = min(X, d) for the loss capped at d.

  • Deductible d: payment (X โˆ’ d)โบ = X โˆ’ (X โˆง d).
  • Limit on the payment L above a deductible d: payment min((X โˆ’ d)โบ, L) = (X โˆง (d + L)) โˆ’ (X โˆง d).
  • Coinsurance ฮฑ: multiply the payment by ฮฑ.

Order matters: contracts usually apply the deductible first, then the limit, then coinsurance. Expectations follow from the limited expected value E[X โˆง d] = โˆซโ‚€^d S(x) dx, where S is the survival function of X:

Text
E[(X โˆ’ d)โบ]            = E[X] โˆ’ E[X โˆง d]
E[payment with limit]  = ฮฑ ยท ( E[X โˆง (d + L)] โˆ’ E[X โˆง d] )

Exponential example

For an exponential loss with mean ฮธ = 1000, E[X โˆง d] = ฮธ (1 โˆ’ e^(โˆ’d/ฮธ)).

  • With d = 500: E[X โˆง 500] = 1000 (1 โˆ’ e^(โˆ’0.5)) โ‰ˆ 393.5, so the expected payment per loss is 1000 โˆ’ 393.5 โ‰ˆ 606.5.
  • The loss elimination ratio is 393.5 / 1000 โ‰ˆ 39.3%: the deductible removes about 39% of expected losses.

For other distributions, the limited expected value has its own formula: for the lognormal it involves the standard normal distribution function ฮฆ, and for the Pareto it is E[X โˆง d] = ฮธ/(ฮฑ โˆ’ 1) ยท [1 โˆ’ (ฮธ/(d + ฮธ))^(ฮฑ โˆ’ 1)]. Heavy tails mean fewer losses are eliminated by the same deductible because large losses dominate the mean.

Loss elimination ratio as the deductible grows for three claim size models
A deductible removes a lot of expected loss when the tail is light and much less when it is heavy.

Inflation and leverage

Suppose claim costs inflate by a factor r (say 10%, so r = 1.10). The deductible stays at d, but the loss is now rX. The insurer's expected payment becomes r ยท E[(X โˆ’ d/r)โบ], which grows by more than 10%. A deductible therefore leverages inflation, which is why contracts with deductibles need frequent repricing.

Reinsurance

An insurer can buy insurance on its own losses. Three standard treaty types:

Treaty Reinsurer pays Typical use
Quota share A fixed fraction q of every claim (and premium) Capacity and capital relief
Excess of loss (per claim) (X โˆ’ M)โบ, the part of each claim above the retention M (often with a limit) Protection against single large claims
Stop loss (S โˆ’ a)โบ, the part of the aggregate above a Protection against a bad year

Quota share reduces every risk in proportion but does not remove the shape of the distribution. Excess of loss chops the right tail of each claim. Stop loss chops the right tail of the total, so it protects directly against the bad year; it is also the most expensive per unit of protection because it covers the entire tail of S.

Try it

Python Loss elimination ratios for three claim models

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Python Which reinsurance treaty tames the bad year?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Deductible and limit explorer

Common misconceptions

"Doubling the deductible halves the insurer's cost." The expected payment falls, but by far less than half for light-tailed losses and by even less for heavy tails.

"Reinsurance always lowers the insurer's expected profit." It lowers expected profit if the reinsurer charges a loading, but it reduces variance and capital, so it can raise return on capital.

"Quota share protects against large claims." It scales everything down; a single huge claim is still large. Excess of loss is the cover aimed at individual large claims.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A loss has expected value 1000 and E[X โˆง 500] = 400. What is the expected payment per loss with a 500 deductible?

    E[(X โˆ’ d)โบ] = E[X] โˆ’ E[X โˆง d] = 1000 โˆ’ 400 = 600.
  2. 2. For the same mean and deductible, which tail gives the lowest loss elimination ratio?

    The heavier the tail, the more of the mean comes from losses far above the deductible.
  3. 3. A per-claim excess of loss treaty with retention 8,000 and a claim of 20,000: how much does the reinsurer pay?

    The reinsurer pays (X โˆ’ M)โบ = 20,000 โˆ’ 8,000 = 12,000.
  4. 4. Which treaty protects directly against a year with an unusually high total?

    Stop loss pays the part of the aggregate above the attachment point.
  5. 5. With claim inflation of 10% and a fixed deductible, the insurer's expected payment rises by

    Inflation pushes more losses above the deductible, so the payment grows faster than the losses themselves.

Summary

  • Deductibles, limits and coinsurance modify the payment; its mean follows from limited expected values E[X โˆง d].
  • The loss elimination ratio is E[X โˆง d]/E[X]; it is smaller for heavy-tailed losses.
  • Fixed deductibles leverage inflation.
  • Quota share scales risk, excess of loss trims large claims, and stop loss trims the aggregate.

Next: Risk theory and loss models: chapter review