Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 33 of 49 ยท Semantics and Pragmatics

Chapter review: Meaning

Review word relations, truth conditions, entailment, speech acts and implicature with a stair diagram, a recap table and a ten-question mixed quiz.

This chapter climbed three levels. Words have senses and relations. Sentences have truth conditions built from their parts. Speakers do things with sentences and mean more than they say. Use this page to check that the levels fit together before moving on to acquisition and change.

Three ascending steps: word meaning, sentence meaning and speaker meaning, with brackets for semantics and pragmatics
Meaning has three levels: words, sentences, and what speakers intend in context.

The chapter in one table

Level Key idea Names and terms
Word Senses connect through relations; categories have prototypes hyponymy, polysemy, Rosch, WordNet
Word and world Sense differs from reference Frege, Ogden and Richards
Sentence Meaning is truth conditions on a model Tarski, Davidson, Montague
Sentence relations Entailment is strict; presupposition survives negation Russell, Strawson
Composition The whole is built from parts and structure compositionality, idioms, scope
Quantifiers Relations between sets every, some, no, most
Speaker Saying is doing Austin, Searle
Speaker Meaning more than you say Grice, scalar implicature, relevance theory

Which level is it?

A good habit when analysing any example is to ask which level the puzzle belongs to:

  • Is a penguin a typical bird? A word-level question about prototypes.
  • Does "Tom is a cat" entail "Tom is a mammal"? A sentence-level question about truth conditions.
  • Why does "Can you pass the salt?" get the salt passed? A speaker-level question about speech acts.
  • Why does "some" suggest "not all"? Speaker-level again: a scalar implicature, which can be cancelled.

Try it

The first demo ties word relations to entailment: it answers whether X is a Y follows from X is a Z using a small hierarchy.

Python Entailment from a hierarchy

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The second demo sorts puzzles by level and by the kind of meaning involved.

JS Sort the puzzles

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 10 questions

of 10 answered You scored / 10 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Which pair of words stands in a hyponymy relation?

    A poodle is a kind of dog.
  2. 2. The morning star and the evening star have the same what?

    Both pick out Venus, but they present it in different ways, so their senses differ.
  3. 3. A sentence that is true in every model is a:

    A tautology cannot be false.
  4. 4. Which test separates a presupposition from an entailment?

    Presuppositions survive negation, questions and if clauses.
  5. 5. In the sentence Every student read a book, ambiguity arises from:

    The order of the quantifiers can be read in two ways.
  6. 6. Who proposed the cooperative principle and the four maxims?

    H. Paul Grice, in his 1975 article Logic and Conversation.
  7. 7. Which is a directive according to Searle?

    Directives try to get the hearer to act.
  8. 8. How is a conversational implicature different from an entailment?

    Some students passed, in fact all did, is not contradictory.
  9. 9. What is the main claim of prototype theory?

    Rosch found typicality effects across many categories.
  10. 10. Which belongs to pragmatics?

    Pragmatics is about how speakers' intentions and context shape the meaning conveyed.

Summary

  • Meaning has three levels: word, sentence and speaker.
  • Sense, reference, truth conditions and entailment give semantics its tools.
  • Speech acts and implicature are the core of pragmatics.
  • Asking "which level is this puzzle at?" makes most examples easier.

Next: Chapter overview: Acquisition, change and variation