Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 15 of 44 ยท Surfaces and Parametrizations

Regular Surfaces and Standard Examples

Define regular surfaces, test them with r_u x r_v, and work through graphs, surfaces of revolution, the helicoid, the torus and the cone, including where parametrizations fail.

Not every map r(u, v) produces a surface you can do calculus on. If it squashes the grid along some direction, the two tangent vectors collapse into one and the tangent plane vanishes. The cure is a simple condition: r_u ร— r_v โ‰  0. A surface that can be covered by patches satisfying it is called a regular surface. In this lesson you will meet the condition, apply it to a gallery of standard examples, and learn why a cone is not regular at its tip while a sphere is regular everywhere.

Four wireframes: a graph of a bump, a vase of revolution, a helicoid, and a double cone whose apex is marked as singular
Caption: graph, revolution, ruled and singular. The red dot at the cone's apex is the one point where no tangent plane exists.

What you will learn

  • The definition of a regular patch and a regular surface
  • How to test regularity using |r_u ร— r_v|
  • Formulas for graphs, surfaces of revolution, helicoids, tori and cones
  • Why we sometimes need several patches to cover one surface

Key terms

Regular patch: a smooth r(u, v) with r_u ร— r_v โ‰  0 at every point (and one-to-one onto its image).

Regular surface: a set that is covered by regular patches, with smooth overlaps.

Surface of revolution: the surface swept by rotating a plane curve about an axis.

Ruled surface: a surface made of straight lines, such as a cone or a helicoid.

Singular point: a point where no tangent plane exists, such as the tip of a cone.

The regularity test

A patch r(u, v) is regular when r_u ร— r_v โ‰  0 everywhere, equivalently when r_u and r_v are linearly independent. The length |r_u ร— r_v| is the area of the parallelogram spanned by r_u and r_v; if it is zero somewhere, the parallelogram has collapsed. (We also want r to be one-to-one, so the surface does not cross itself.) A regular surface is a set S such that every point of S lies in the image of some regular patch, with overlaps that are smooth.

There is a convenient alternative description. If F(x, y, z) is smooth and โˆ‡F โ‰  0 at every point where F = c, then the level set {F = c} is a regular surface. The sphere xยฒ + yยฒ + zยฒ = 1 and the torus (โˆš(xยฒ + yยฒ) โˆ’ a)ยฒ + zยฒ = bยฒ are examples.

Graphs

r(u, v) = (u, v, f(u, v)) always has r_u ร— r_v = (โˆ’f_u, โˆ’f_v, 1), whose third component is 1. So every graph of a smooth function is a regular surface, with a single patch. This is the simplest and most useful family.

Surfaces of revolution

Rotate a plane curve (g(v), h(v)), with g > 0, about the z-axis:

Text
r(u, v) = ( g(v) cos u,  g(v) sin u,  h(v) ),   0 โ‰ค u โ‰ค 2ฯ€

Compute r_u = (โˆ’g sin u, g cos u, 0) and r_v = (gโ€ฒ cos u, gโ€ฒ sin u, hโ€ฒ). Then

Text
r_u ร— r_v = ( g hโ€ฒ cos u,  g hโ€ฒ sin u,  โˆ’g gโ€ฒ )        |r_u ร— r_v| = g โˆš(gโ€ฒยฒ + hโ€ฒยฒ)

This is nonzero as long as g > 0 (away from the axis) and the profile curve itself is regular. The grid lines are circles (v = const, called parallels) and copies of the profile (u = const, called meridians).

  • Sphere: profile (sin v, cos v), g = sin v; then |r_u ร— r_v| = sin v, which vanishes at the poles v = 0, ฯ€. The pole is not a bad point of the sphere, only of this patch.
  • Torus: profile the circle (a + b cos v, b sin v), a > b > 0. Then |r_u ร— r_v| = b (a + b cos v) > 0 everywhere, so the torus is covered by one patch (periodic in both u and v).
  • Cylinder: profile the vertical line g = R, h = v.

The helicoid and ruled surfaces

The helicoid r(u, v) = (v cos u, v sin u, c u) is a spiral staircase: each horizontal line through the z-axis is rotated and lifted uniformly. We find r_u ร— r_v = (โˆ’c sin u, c cos u, โˆ’v) with length โˆš(cยฒ + vยฒ). For c โ‰  0 this is never zero, so the helicoid is regular, even along the axis v = 0. It is also a ruled surface (made of straight lines) and also a minimal surface, a fact you may meet later.

The cone: a singular point

The cone r(u, v) = (v cos u, v sin u, v) has r_u ร— r_v = (v cos u, v sin u, โˆ’v) with length |v|โˆš2. The parametrization is regular for v โ‰  0 (the two nappes without the apex), but at the apex v = 0 the cross product vanishes. Is the failure of the patch or of the surface? For the cone, it is the surface: no choice of parametrization can give the apex a tangent plane, because near the tip the surface is shaped like a funnel, not a plane. Remove the apex and what remains is a regular surface.

Several patches for one surface

A single patch usually cannot cover a whole closed surface. The sphere needs at least two. A convenient pair: the six hemispheres given as graphs over discs (z = ยฑโˆš(1 โˆ’ xยฒ โˆ’ yยฒ), etc.), or the two stereographic projections from the north and south poles. On the overlaps, the change of parameters must be smooth with nonzero Jacobian. This idea, a surface covered by overlapping charts, is the seed of the definition of a manifold in chapter 8.

Common misconceptions

"If the patch is singular, the surface is singular." Spherical coordinates degenerate at the poles, but the sphere has a perfectly good tangent plane there, as another patch shows.

"Smooth formulas mean a smooth surface." The cone's formulas are perfectly smooth, yet the apex is a singular point of the surface.

"A surface of revolution is regular no matter what profile." The profile must stay off the axis (g > 0) and be regular itself.

Try it

First, a symbolic check of |r_u ร— r_v| for the sphere, torus, cone and helicoid, plus the general surface of revolution formula.

Python Regularity test with sympy

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Next, build a surface of revolution from a profile curve. Change the profile g(v) and watch the shape change.

Python A vase from a profile curve

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Finally, a numerical scan for singular points: the program samples a grid and reports the smallest value of |r_u ร— r_v| and where it occurs.

JS Scan for singular points

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A patch r(u, v) is regular if...

    Regularity means the two tangent vectors are independent, i.e. their cross product never vanishes.
  2. 2. Is the graph of any smooth function z = f(x, y) a regular surface?

    r_u ร— r_v = (โˆ’f_x, โˆ’f_y, 1) is never zero.
  3. 3. For the torus with radii a > b > 0, what is |r_u x r_v|?

    From the surface of revolution formula g โˆš(gโ€ฒยฒ + hโ€ฒยฒ) with g = a + b cos v and a unit-speed circle profile of radius b.
  4. 4. Why is the apex of the cone a singular point of the surface?

    Near the apex the surface is funnel-shaped, so it cannot be approximated by a plane.
  5. 5. How many patches are needed to cover a whole sphere?

    A sphere cannot be covered by a single regular patch; two (such as stereographic charts) are enough.

Summary

  • A regular patch has r_u ร— r_v โ‰  0; a regular surface is covered by such patches.
  • Graphs are always regular; surfaces of revolution need g > 0; the torus and the helicoid are regular everywhere.
  • Singular points such as the cone's apex have no tangent plane.
  • Parametrization failures (like the poles in spherical coordinates) can often be repaired with a second patch.

Next: Chapter 3 Review