Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 19 of 44 ยท The First and Second Fundamental Forms

Area, Angles and the Problem of Flat Maps

Use E, F, G to compute areas and angles on surfaces, check the sphere and torus formulas, and see why no flat map of the Earth can preserve everything.

The first fundamental form does more than measure lengths. Because it tells us the squared length of every tangent vector, it also tells us the angle between any two tangent vectors (by the polarization identity for dot products) and the area of any small parallelogram. This lesson turns that observation into formulas for area and angle and uses it to understand why every flat map of the Earth lies a little.

A parallelogram on a surface with area formula, and an equirectangular map with ellipses that grow wider toward the pole
Caption: left, the area element dA. Right, on a latitude-longitude map a small circle on the globe becomes an ellipse stretched by 1/cos(latitude).

What you will learn

  • The area element dA = โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) du dv and how to integrate it
  • The angle between two curves on a surface, computed from E, F, G
  • Areas of the sphere and the torus as examples
  • What conformal and equal-area maps are, and why none is isometric

Key terms

Area element: dA = |r_u ร— r_v| du dv = โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) du dv.

Angle between curves: the angle between their tangent vectors at the intersection point.

Conformal map: one that preserves angles (but not necessarily lengths).

Equal-area map: one that preserves areas.

Tissot indicatrix: the image of a tiny circle under a map; it shows the local distortion.

Area

A small rectangle du ร— dv in the parameter plane maps to a small parallelogram on the surface, spanned by r_u du and r_v dv. Its area is |r_u du ร— r_v dv| = |r_u ร— r_v| du dv. By the Lagrange identity,

Text
|r_u ร— r_v|ยฒ = (r_u ยท r_u)(r_v ยท r_v) โˆ’ (r_u ยท r_v)ยฒ = E G โˆ’ Fยฒ

so the area element is dA = โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) du dv, and the area of a region D of the parameter domain is

Text
Area = โˆฌ over D of sqrt(E G โˆ’ Fยฒ) du dv.

Sphere. E = Rยฒ, F = 0, G = Rยฒ sinยฒu, so โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) = Rยฒ sin u and

Text
Area = โˆซโ‚€^{2ฯ€} โˆซโ‚€^ฯ€ Rยฒ sin u du dv = 4ฯ€ Rยฒ.

Torus. E = (a + b cos v)ยฒ, F = 0, G = bยฒ, so dA = b (a + b cos v) du dv, and the area is โˆซโ‚€^{2ฯ€} โˆซโ‚€^{2ฯ€} b(a + b cos v) du dv = 4ฯ€ยฒ a b. Notice that the cos v term integrates to zero over a full turn: the outer half of the torus (larger circles) exactly balances the inner half.

A graph z = f(x, y): dA = โˆš(1 + f_xยฒ + f_yยฒ) dx dy. For the paraboloid z = (xยฒ + yยฒ)/2 above the unit disc, polar coordinates make the integral easy; the answer is (2ฯ€/3)(2^(3/2) โˆ’ 1) โ‰ˆ 3.83.

Angles

Let two curves through the same point have parameter-plane directions (aโ‚, aโ‚‚) and (bโ‚, bโ‚‚); their tangent vectors on the surface are wโ‚ = r_u aโ‚ + r_v aโ‚‚ and wโ‚‚ = r_u bโ‚ + r_v bโ‚‚. Their dot product expands just like the line element:

Text
wโ‚ ยท wโ‚‚ = E aโ‚ bโ‚ + F (aโ‚ bโ‚‚ + aโ‚‚ bโ‚) + G aโ‚‚ bโ‚‚

so the angle ฮธ between them satisfies

Text
cos ฮธ = ( E aโ‚ bโ‚ + F (aโ‚ bโ‚‚ + aโ‚‚ bโ‚) + G aโ‚‚ bโ‚‚ ) / ( |wโ‚| |wโ‚‚| ),   |w|ยฒ = E aโ‚ยฒ + 2F aโ‚ aโ‚‚ + G aโ‚‚ยฒ.

A special case: the angle between the two coordinate curves, (1, 0) and (0, 1), has cos ฮธ = F / โˆš(EG). The grid lines cross at right angles exactly when F = 0.

Flat maps of a sphere

A map projection is a patch of the sphere written as a function of (x, y) on a flat sheet. Because the sphere's first form is not that of the plane, every projection distorts something:

  • Equirectangular (x = longitude, y = latitude): dsยฒ = dฯ†ยฒ + cosยฒฯ† dฮปยฒ on the sphere becomes dxยฒ + dyยฒ on the map, so east-west distances are stretched by 1/cos ฯ†. Near the poles the stretching is enormous (the ellipses in the illustration).
  • Mercator (y = ln tan(ฯ€/4 + ฯ†/2)): preserves angles (it is conformal), which is why it is useful for navigation, but areas near the poles are exaggerated by 1/cosยฒฯ†. Greenland looks as large as Africa.
  • Equal-area projections (Lambert, Gall-Peters and others): preserve area but shear shapes.

The reason is the Theorema Egregium: an isometry between the sphere and a plane would require equal Gaussian curvature, and 1/Rยฒ โ‰  0. You can have any two of "angles, areas, lengths" only in special cases, never all three.

Common misconceptions

"Angles in the (u, v) plane equal angles on the surface." Only if E = G and F = 0 (a conformal parametrization). In general you must use the first form.

"Area is just du dv." The factor โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) accounts for how much the patch stretches the grid.

"A good map projection can preserve everything." The Theorema Egregium forbids it for the sphere. Every projection is a trade-off.

Try it

First, areas computed symbolically and checked numerically for the sphere, the torus and the paraboloid cap.

Python Areas from the first fundamental form

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Next, the distortion of the equirectangular and Mercator maps. The program places small circles of angular radius 5 degrees on the globe at several latitudes, maps them with each projection, and measures how stretched they become.

Python Tissot circles on two maps

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Finally, the angle formula. The program computes the angle between two curve directions at a point on the sphere in two ways: with E, F, G only, and with 3D tangent vectors.

JS Angle between two curves on the sphere

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What is the area element of a patch?

    dA = |r_u ร— r_v| du dv, and |r_u ร— r_v|ยฒ = EG โˆ’ Fยฒ.
  2. 2. What is the area of a sphere of radius R computed from the first form?

    โˆซโˆซ Rยฒ sin u du dv = 4ฯ€Rยฒ.
  3. 3. The grid lines of a patch cross at right angles at a point exactly when...

    cos ฮธ = F/โˆš(EG) is the cosine of the angle between the coordinate curves.
  4. 4. What does a conformal map preserve?

    Conformal maps preserve angles but may change lengths and areas.
  5. 5. Why can't a flat map of the globe preserve lengths, angles and areas at once?

    By the Theorema Egregium, an isometry would need equal Gaussian curvature; the sphere's is positive, the plane's is zero.

Summary

  • dA = โˆš(EG โˆ’ Fยฒ) du dv; area is the integral of this over the parameter domain.
  • cos ฮธ = F/โˆš(EG) for the angle between coordinate curves; the general formula uses E, F, G on the direction components.
  • The sphere has area 4ฯ€Rยฒ and the torus 4ฯ€ยฒab.
  • Flat maps must distort: conformal maps keep angles, equal-area maps keep area, and none keeps lengths.

Next: The Second Fundamental Form