Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 27 of 44 Β· Physics and Chemistry Transformed

Atoms and the Periodic Table: Dalton to Mendeleev

How Dalton's atoms, the weights debate and Mendeleev's gaps and predictions built the periodic table, and how Moseley later put it on solid ground.

Anyone who has seen a periodic table knows its tidy rows and columns. Few people notice the history inside it: a century of arguments about what atoms are, a conference that settled how to weigh them, and a Russian professor who dared to leave blank squares and predict what would fill them. This lesson follows the road from Dalton's atoms to Mendeleev's table and then to the number that really organizes it.

Four steps from Dalton's atoms to Moseley's atomic number
The table grew from relative atomic weights to a pattern with predictions, and finally to atomic number.

What you will learn

  • What Dalton's atomic theory claimed and which chemical laws it explained.
  • Why the right atomic weights took until 1860 to agree on.
  • How Mendeleev used gaps and corrections to make predictions.
  • Why atomic number replaced atomic weight as the ordering principle.

Key terms

Atomic weight: the relative mass of an element's atoms (today called relative atomic mass).

Law of definite proportions: a compound always contains the same elements in the same mass ratios (Proust, 1799).

Law of multiple proportions: when two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in small whole-number ratios (Dalton).

Periodic law: properties of elements repeat when they are arranged by increasing atomic number.

Dalton's atoms

John Dalton, a Quaker schoolteacher in Manchester, studied gases and weather. In his New System of Chemical Philosophy (1808) he proposed that every element consists of tiny indivisible atoms, all alike for one element and different from other elements. Compounds form when atoms of different elements join in simple numbers. This explained the law of definite proportions, and it predicted a new law: for example, carbon forms two oxides, in which the oxygen combining with a fixed mass of carbon is in a 2-to-1 ratio. That is exactly what measurements showed.

Dalton lacked a way to find how many atoms were in a compound. He assumed that the simplest combination was one atom of each, so he took water to be HO. Because of this his atomic weights were often wrong. Still, the idea of relative weights gave chemists a program: measure them carefully.

The weights tangle

Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac found in 1808 that gases react in simple volume ratios, such as two volumes of hydrogen to one of oxygen. Amedeo Avogadro suggested in 1811 that equal volumes of gases at the same temperature and pressure contain equal numbers of molecules, and that gas elements like hydrogen exist as two-atom molecules. That resolved the puzzles, but Dalton and others rejected the idea, and for about fifty years chemists used incompatible weights and formulas; one organic chemist could write acetic acid with different formulas than another.

In September 1860 Friedrich August KekulΓ© organized the first international chemistry congress at Karlsruhe. Stanislao Cannizzaro argued there that Avogadro's idea, applied consistently, gave a coherent set of weights. A young Lothar Meyer and others later said reading Cannizzaro's pamphlet was like scales falling from their eyes. Reliable weights then opened the way to patterns.

Mendeleev's table

Several chemists, including John Newlands (the "law of octaves", 1865) and Lothar Meyer, noticed patterns. Dmitri Mendeleev, a professor in St Petersburg writing a textbook, wrote the elements on cards and arranged them by atomic weight. In 1869 he published a table in which similar elements fall in the same column. His brilliance lay in three bold decisions:

  1. Leave gaps. Where no known element fit, he predicted a new one.
  2. Correct weights. If an element's weight put it in the wrong column, he proposed the weight was mistaken (sometimes he was right, sometimes not).
  3. Break the order for chemistry. He placed tellurium before iodine, though its weight is slightly higher, because iodine behaves like chlorine and bromine.

He predicted "eka-aluminium" (as the element below aluminium), "eka-silicon" and "eka-boron". Paul-Γ‰mile Lecoq de Boisbaudran found gallium in 1875, Lars Nilson found scandium in 1879, and Clemens Winkler found germanium in 1886. The match between Mendeleev's predictions and the new elements' properties persuaded many chemists that the periodic law was real. The noble gases, discovered by William Ramsay and Lord Rayleigh in the 1890s, were not predicted but fitted as a new column.

Atomic number

The tellurium-iodine reversal hinted that weight was not the true order. In 1913 Henry Moseley, working in Rutherford's lab in Manchester, measured X-ray frequencies from many elements and found that the square root of the frequency grows linearly with a whole number: the atomic number Z, the number of protons in the nucleus. Arranging by Z removed every anomaly and showed exactly where gaps remained (for example elements 43, 61, 72, 75). Moseley was killed at Gallipoli in 1915, aged 27, which is often cited as a reason for protecting young scientists in wartime.

Common misconceptions

"Mendeleev invented the periodic table alone." Others had seen parts of the pattern. His credit rests on a full table, gaps and testable predictions.

"Every prediction was correct." Several of his predicted elements never existed, such as the "coronium" he proposed. The successful ones are remembered.

"Atoms are indivisible, as Dalton said." Electrons (Thomson, 1897) and the nucleus (Rutherford, 1911) showed that atoms have parts.

Try it

First, compare Mendeleev's predictions with modern values. The predicted numbers for eka-aluminium (gallium) and eka-silicon (germanium) are those usually reported in histories; modern values are rounded.

Python Predictions versus reality

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input Β· what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Second, an interactive atomic-weight calculator. Choose a formula and see how the relative mass is built from weights, the kind of arithmetic Dalton's successors did by hand.

Formula mass calculator

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. What did Dalton's atomic theory explain in addition to definite proportions?

    If atoms combine in whole numbers, different compounds of the same elements show small whole-number mass ratios.
  2. 2. Why was the Karlsruhe Congress of 1860 important?

    Consistent weights made it possible to see patterns, as Mendeleev and Meyer did.
  3. 3. Which is a bold step that made Mendeleev's table scientifically powerful?

    Predictions for eka-aluminium, eka-silicon and eka-boron were later matched by gallium, germanium and scandium.
  4. 4. What did Moseley find in 1913?

    The square root of X-ray frequency rises linearly with atomic number Z.
  5. 5. Why did Mendeleev place tellurium before iodine despite its higher atomic weight?

    Chemical behavior mattered more to him than strict weight order; atomic number later confirmed the choice.

Summary

  • Dalton gave chemistry atoms with characteristic weights and explained multiple proportions.
  • Atomic weights were tangled until Cannizzaro's argument at Karlsruhe in 1860.
  • Mendeleev's table of 1869 made predictions that were confirmed by gallium, scandium and germanium.
  • Moseley showed in 1913 that atomic number is the true ordering principle.
  • Atoms later turned out to have parts, which is the subject of the quantum chapters.

Next: Energy and thermodynamics