Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 19 of 38 ยท Lorentz Transformations and Spacetime

The Twin Paradox

Resolve the twin paradox step by step: compute both twins' ages for a trip at 0.8c, see why acceleration breaks the symmetry, and follow the simultaneity jump at turnaround.

One twin stays on Earth. The other flies to a distant star and back at high speed. When they meet again, who is younger? Time dilation says each twin sees the other's clock run slow, so the situation looks symmetric. Yet the travelling twin is the younger one. This is the twin paradox, and it is resolved without any new physics: the situation is not symmetric, and spacetime geometry shows exactly why.

The scenario

Earth and a star are at rest relative to each other, D = 4 light-years apart (measured in the Earth frame). The traveler leaves Earth, flies to the star at speed v = 0.8c, turns around instantly, and returns at the same speed. Here ฮฒ = 0.8 and ฮณ = 5/3.

Earth twin's calculation. The outbound trip takes D/v = 4/0.8 = 5 years, the return the same, so the round trip takes 10 years of Earth time. The traveler's clock runs slow by ฮณ, so it records

Text
ฮ”ฯ„ = 10 / ฮณ = 10 ร— 3/5 = 6 years

The Earth twin is 10 years older, the traveler 6 years older.

Python Both twins' ages

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The paradox

Now look from the traveler's point of view. During the outbound leg the Earth recedes at 0.8c, so the traveler sees Earth's clocks running slow. During the return leg the Earth approaches at 0.8c, and again Earth's clocks run slow. So the traveler concludes that the Earth twin should age less. Contradiction: each twin predicts that the other is younger.

The resolution: the situations are not symmetric

The two twins are not equivalent. The Earth twin stays in one inertial frame the whole time. The traveler changes frames: at the turnaround they switch from an outbound inertial frame to an inbound one. This requires acceleration, which both twins can feel and measure (the traveler is pushed against the seat; the Earth twin feels nothing). The traveler's analysis using a single frame is invalid. A correct analysis for the traveler must handle the frame change, and when it does, it agrees with Earth's.

In the spacetime picture: there are two worldlines between the same two events (departure and reunion). The Earth twin's is a straight line; the traveler's is bent. From the interval lesson: a straight (inertial) path between two time-like separated events has the largest proper time. The bent path has less. No paradox, only geometry.

Python Spacetime diagram of the twin journey

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

What the traveler sees at the turnaround

The key is the traveler's definition of "now" on Earth. In the outbound frame, the events simultaneous with the turnaround are on the line of slope ฮฒ through it (the green dotted line). It meets the Earth's worldline at

Text
t_Earth = T/2 โˆ’ ฮฒ D = 5 โˆ’ 0.8 ร— 4 = 1.8 years

In the inbound frame, "now" at the turnaround is the purple line with the opposite slope, meeting Earth at

Text
t_Earth = T/2 + ฮฒ D = 5 + 3.2 = 8.2 years

At the moment of turnaround, the traveler's idea of "what time it is on Earth" jumps from 1.8 to 8.2 years: a jump of 2ฮฒD = 6.4 years. During each leg, the traveler computes that Earth's clock advances more slowly: over the outbound leg, the traveler's clock reads 3 years (D/ฮณ/ฮฒ = 2.4/0.8), during which Earth's clock advances 3/ฮณ = 1.8 years. The same on the return: another 1.8 years. Add the jump and we get the full account:

Text
1.8 (outbound) + 6.4 (jump at turnaround) + 1.8 (inbound) = 10 years

The Earth twin's aging is entirely accounted for, and the traveler's calculation agrees. The asymmetry is in the jump.

JS Traveler's accounting of Earth's clock

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Is it just the acceleration?

A common misconception is that acceleration "causes" the age difference. It does not directly: you can make the acceleration phases arbitrarily brief compared with the coasting phases, and the age difference stays 4 years. What matters is the geometry of the worldline: the traveler's path has two inertial legs in different frames, and the difference in proper time follows from the interval calculation. Acceleration is needed only because it is the physical way to change frames.

A variant avoids acceleration altogether: three observers. Observer A passes Earth at 0.8c heading to the star. At the star, observer A passes by observer B, heading the other way at 0.8c, and B sets her clock to A's reading. B passes Earth. B's clock total (A's leg + B's leg) is 6 years, the Earth clock reads 10 years. No one accelerated; the comparison is between one inertial observer (Earth) and two (A then B), and the clock transfer takes place at a single event.

Real experiments

Atomic clocks flown on aircraft (Hafele and Keating, 1971, with the gravitational effect included) and clocks on satellites, as well as unstable particles in storage rings, confirm that a clock that follows a different path accumulates a different proper time. The muon experiment of the last chapter is a twin paradox in miniature: the muons that travel in circles age less than the muons at rest in the lab.

The asymmetric experience of the twins is physical and measurable. The traveler feels the acceleration at turnaround, so cannot claim to be at rest in an inertial frame the whole time. Special relativity has no paradox here; the "paradox" is only the mistake of treating the two as equivalent.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A traveler flies to a star 4 ly away (Earth frame) and back at 0.8c. How much does the Earth twin age?

    Each leg takes 4/0.8 = 5 years in the Earth frame, so 10 years round trip.
  2. 2. How much does the traveler age on the same trip?

    ฮ”ฯ„ = 10/ฮณ = 10 ร— 0.6 = 6 years.
  3. 3. Why is the situation not symmetric?

    The traveler's worldline has a bend, so no single inertial frame describes the whole trip.
  4. 4. Which worldline between two time-like separated events has the greatest proper time?

    Straight inertial worldlines maximize proper time; any bend reduces it.

Summary

  • A traveler going at 0.8c to a star 4 ly away and back ages 6 years while the Earth twin ages 10.
  • The symmetric argument fails because the traveler changes inertial frames at turnaround; the Earth twin does not.
  • In spacetime the traveler's worldline is bent, and straight worldlines have maximal proper time.
  • In the traveler's accounting, Earth's clock advances 1.8 years on each leg, with a 6.4-year jump in "Earth now" at the turnaround.
  • The age difference does not depend on how brief the acceleration is, only on the geometry of the paths.

Next: back to the Special and General Relativity track page