Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 33 of 38 · Black Holes, Gravitational Waves and Cosmology

Orbits in Schwarzschild Spacetime and Mercury's Precession

Compare Newtonian and relativistic orbits, use the effective potential, derive the 6πGM/(c²a(1-e²)) precession and compute Mercury's famous 43 arcseconds per century.

Newton's gravity predicts that a planet around a spherical star follows a closed ellipse that never changes. General relativity predicts that the ellipse slowly rotates: the point of closest approach (the perihelion) advances a little on every orbit. Mercury, the innermost planet, shows the largest effect in the Solar System, and it was one of the first confirmations of the theory. In this lesson you will find the equation of motion, the effective potential, the precession formula, and compute real values.

The conserved quantities

A planet is a test body following a timelike geodesic of the Schwarzschild metric. Because the metric does not depend on t or φ, two quantities are conserved along the path (per unit mass): the energy E and the angular momentum L. Restrict to the equatorial plane. Write M for the length GM/c² (half of the Schwarzschild radius, not the mass in kilograms), measure L in units of length (L = ℓ/c, where ℓ is the specific angular momentum) and use proper time τ in units of length (multiply by c). Then

(dr/dτ)² = E² - (1 - 2M/r)(1 + L²/r²)

This looks like a particle with "energy" E² moving in the effective potential

V_eff(r) = (1 - 2M/r)(1 + L²/r²) = 1 - 2M/r + L²/r² - 2ML²/r³

Compare this with Newton's effective potential for a unit mass, -M/r + L²/(2r²). The first three terms match, apart from rescaling. The last term, -2ML²/r³, is new. It is attractive and strongest at small r.

Newton's effective potential always has a repulsive "wall" from the L²/r² term, which stops any particle with L ≠ 0 from reaching the center. In GR the new r⁻³ term overpowers the wall at small radius, so even particles with large angular momentum can fall in.

Python Effective potential for several angular momenta

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

For L larger than 2√3 M the potential has a minimum (stable circular orbit) and a maximum (unstable circular orbit). As L decreases the two come together and vanish at L = 2√3 M, where they meet at r = 6M: the ISCO. Below that value there is no circular orbit at all and a particle plunges in.

The orbit equation and precession

To get the shape of the orbit, write u = 1/r and change the variable from τ to φ. The result is

d²u/dφ² + u = M/L² + 3M u²

The first two terms with the M/L² are the Newtonian orbit equation, whose solutions are ellipses u = (M/L²)(1 + e cos φ). The new term 3Mu² is small for weak gravity (3Mu²/u = 3M/r, very small for planets), and acts as a slow perturbation. Solving to first order shows that an ellipse is traced out with the angle between successive perihelia not 2π, but

Δφ = 2π + 6π GM / (c² a (1 - e²))

So the perihelion advances by

δφ = 6π GM / (c² a (1 - e²)) per orbit

where a is the semi-major axis and e the eccentricity. The effect is larger for orbits that are small (a small) and more eccentric.

Mercury and other planets

Mercury has a = 5.791 × 10¹⁰ m, e = 0.2056 and orbital period 87.97 days. Substituting gives about 0.1 arcseconds per orbit. Over a century Mercury completes about 415 orbits.

Observations showed that Mercury's orbit advances by about 5600 arcseconds per century relative to the fixed stars. Most of this comes from the precession of the coordinates themselves (≈ 5025″) and from perturbations by the other planets (≈ 532″), calculable in Newtonian physics. In 1859, Urbain Le Verrier noticed that about 43″ per century was left over. Some astronomers proposed an undiscovered planet (Vulcan). Einstein's 1915 calculation gave 43″ without any adjustable parameter and was an early success of general relativity.

Python GR perihelion advance for the planets

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The Mercury line gives the famous number. Compared with the values often quoted, you should find about 43 arcseconds per century for Mercury, 8.6 for Venus, 3.8 for the Earth and 1.35 for Mars.

Stronger gravity: binary pulsars

The formula works for any two-body system, with M replaced by the total mass. The Hulse-Taylor binary pulsar (PSR B1913+16, discovered 1974) has an orbital period of only 7.75 hours and an eccentric orbit, so its periastron advances by about 4.2 degrees per year: roughly 35,000 times faster than Mercury's advance in degrees. Such measurements were used to determine the masses of the two neutron stars, and are consistent with GR.

Why a perfect ellipse is special

In Newtonian gravity, the 1/r² force law is one of just two (with Hooke's law) for which all bounded orbits close. Any extra term, such as the r⁻³ correction in the potential, spoils this and makes the orbit precess. In the project lesson at the end of this chapter you will integrate the orbit equation numerically and measure the precession.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. In the Schwarzschild effective potential, what extra term (compared with Newton) is responsible for orbital precession?

    The -2ML²/r³ term (equivalently 3Mu² in the orbit equation) is the relativistic correction; it makes the orbit non-closed.
  2. 2. Per orbit, the perihelion advance in GR is approximately:

    δφ = 6πGM/(c² a (1 - e²)); it grows for small, eccentric orbits.
  3. 3. Roughly how large is the GR contribution to Mercury's perihelion precession?

    About 43″ per century remained unexplained by Newtonian perturbations until general relativity explained it.
  4. 4. What happens to a particle with angular momentum L smaller than 2√3 GM/c in Schwarzschild spacetime?

    Below that angular momentum the effective potential has no extremum, so no circular orbit exists and the particle plunges.

Summary

  • The geodesic equation in the equatorial plane gives (dr/dτ)² = E² - V_eff(r) with V_eff = (1 - 2M/r)(1 + L²/r²) in units where M = GM/c².
  • The extra -2ML²/r³ term means a stable circular orbit exists only for L ≥ 2√3 M, with the ISCO at r = 6M.
  • The orbit equation u'' + u = M/L² + 3Mu² yields a precession δφ = 6πGM/(c²a(1 - e²)) per orbit.
  • For Mercury this is about 43 arcseconds per century, matching the previously unexplained residual.
  • Binary pulsars show much larger effects, in agreement with the theory.

Next: Gravitational Waves