Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 5 of 38 ยท The Principle of Relativity

Galilean Relativity

See why no experiment on a smoothly moving ship can reveal its motion, how Newton's laws stay the same under the Galilean transformation, and what quantities are invariant.

Long before Einstein, Galileo wrote about a ship sailing smoothly on calm water. Below deck, you drop things, pour water, watch butterflies and fish. He argued that nothing you see would tell you whether the ship is moving or standing still. This is the principle of relativity: the laws of mechanics are the same in every inertial frame. Einstein's contribution was to extend that principle to all of physics, including light, and to follow it to its surprising conclusions. First we need to understand the Galilean version properly.

The principle

The laws of physics take the same form in all inertial frames.

Another way to say it: there is no absolute rest. If you are in an inertial frame, you cannot do any experiment inside it that tells you your velocity. You can tell your velocity relative to something else, such as the ground, but not an absolute one.

Compare with acceleration. In a car that brakes or a plane that takes off, you feel pushed. You do not feel steady motion. This difference is why the principle only applies to inertial frames.

Checking Newton's laws under the Galilean transformation

From the previous lesson, a frame S' moving at v along x is related to S by x' = x โˆ’ vt and t' = t. Take the time derivative. An object with position x(t) in S has velocity

Text
u' = dx'/dt' = dx/dt โˆ’ v = u โˆ’ v

This is the Galilean velocity addition rule: velocities in two frames differ by the constant v. Differentiate again, and since v is constant,

Text
a' = du'/dt = du/dt = a

Acceleration is the same in both frames. If forces depend only on positions and relative separations (like gravity or springs), and mass is the same in both frames, then F = ma becomes F = ma' with the same F. Newton's second law keeps its form. This is what "invariant under the Galilean transformation" means.

Let's check numerically with a simulated mass on a spring, seen from two frames.

Python Same acceleration in two frames

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The velocity changes by exactly v but the acceleration does not change at all. This is why mechanics experiments cannot reveal steady motion.

What changes and what stays the same

Quantity Galilean transformation Absolute?
Position x x' = x โˆ’ vt No
Velocity u u' = u โˆ’ v No
Acceleration a a' = a Yes
Time interval ฮ”t ฮ”t' = ฮ”t Yes
Distance between simultaneous events ฮ”x' = ฮ”x Yes
Mass unchanged Yes
Kinetic energy ยฝmu'ยฒ โ‰  ยฝmuยฒ No

Kinetic energy is frame-dependent, but energy conservation still holds in every inertial frame. A collision that conserves kinetic energy in S also conserves it in S'; the numbers differ but the law does not. The program below proves it with a one-dimensional elastic collision.

JS Elastic collision seen from two frames

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

In each frame, energy and momentum are conserved, but the actual values differ. That is the sign of a good symmetry: the laws are identical, the numbers depend on viewpoint.

Electromagnetism disagrees

Galilean relativity worked beautifully for mechanics for over two hundred years. The trouble came with Maxwell's equations in the 1860s. They contain a constant speed: the speed of waves, which works out to c, about 3 ร— 10โธ m/s. If the equations hold in one inertial frame, and the Galilean transformation is right, then in another frame the wave speed would come out as c โˆ’ v or c + v. The equations would look different in the moving frame, which would break the principle of relativity for electromagnetism.

So there were two options: either the principle of relativity fails for electromagnetism and there is one special frame (the ether frame), or the Galilean transformation is wrong. The Michelson-Morley experiment failed to find the special frame. The next lesson shows exactly where the Galilean rule goes wrong when light is involved: Galilean velocity addition meets light.

When a formula depends on the speed of light, test whether it is the same in two frames. If it is not, either the formula is wrong or the rule for transforming between frames is.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. What does the Galilean principle of relativity say?

    Mechanics experiments give the same laws in all inertial frames, so uniform motion cannot be detected by them.
  2. 2. A car moves at 20 m/s relative to the road. A runner moves at 5 m/s forward relative to the road, in the same direction. What is the runner's velocity in the car's frame (Galilean)?

    u' = u โˆ’ v = 5 โˆ’ 20 = โˆ’15 m/s. The runner falls behind the car, moving backward in the car's frame.
  3. 3. Which quantity is the same in all Galilean frames?

    Because the frame velocity v is constant, differentiating u' = u โˆ’ v gives a' = a.
  4. 4. Why did Maxwell's equations cause trouble for Galilean relativity?

    Under u' = u โˆ’ v, the speed of a light wave would change from frame to frame, so Maxwell's equations would not keep the same form.

Summary

  • The principle of relativity: the laws of physics look the same in all inertial frames, so steady motion cannot be detected from inside.
  • Under the Galilean transformation, velocities shift by v (u' = u โˆ’ v) but acceleration, time intervals and mass are unchanged.
  • Newton's laws keep their form; conserved quantities like energy and momentum are conserved in every inertial frame (with different values).
  • Maxwell's equations include a fixed wave speed c, which does not fit Galilean velocity addition. That mismatch drives the rest of this chapter.

Next: Galilean Velocity Addition Meets Light