Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 9 of 38 · The Principle of Relativity

The Relativity of Simultaneity

Use Einstein's train and lightning thought experiment to see why events simultaneous in one frame are not in another, with the formula for the time gap and a checked calculation.

This is the most important idea in the chapter: two events that happen at the same time in one inertial frame generally do not happen at the same time in another frame moving relative to the first. Once you accept this, time dilation, length contraction and the Lorentz transformation all follow. This lesson uses a classic thought experiment to prove it from the two postulates, and then derives a formula for the size of the effect.

Einstein's train

A train of rest length L moves along a straight track at speed v relative to the ground. Ground frame: S. Train frame: S'.

Place a light source at the exact middle of the train. At some moment it flashes. Light spreads out from the middle toward the front wall and the back wall.

In the train frame. The source is in the middle. Light travels at c in both directions, covering L/2 each way. It reaches the front and back walls at the same time. In S', the two arrival events are simultaneous.

In the ground frame. Light also travels at c (postulate 2). But the train is moving. While the light travels, the back wall moves toward the light, and the front wall moves away from it. So the light reaches the back wall first, and the front wall later. In S, the arrivals are not simultaneous.

Both observers are right. They just use different frames, with different synchronized lattices. Simultaneity of separated events is relative.

flowchart LR
    subgraph TF["Train frame"]
      A1["Flash at middle"] --> B1["Back wall hit"]
      A1 --> C1["Front wall hit"]
      B1 -.- C1
    end
    subgraph GF["Ground frame"]
      A2["Flash at middle"] --> B2["Back wall hit first"]
      A2 --> C2["Front wall hit later"]
    end

The same two events: simultaneous in the train frame, back wall first in the ground frame.

The size of the gap

Let the train have length L_g as measured in the ground frame (we will see in the next chapter that L_g = L/γ, but you can treat L_g as just a number for now). In the ground frame the flash starts at the middle at time 0. The light moving forward must cover half the train plus the extra distance the front wall moves away:

Text
c t_f = L_g/2 + v t_f   →   t_f = L_g / (2(c − v))

For the back wall, which moves toward the light:

Text
c t_b = L_g/2 − v t_b   →   t_b = L_g / (2(c + v))

The time difference in the ground frame:

Text
Δt = t_f − t_b = (L_g/2) [1/(c − v) − 1/(c + v)] = L_g v / (c² − v²) = γ² L_g v / c²

Substituting L_g = L/γ (to be proved later), this becomes

Text
Δt = γ L v / c²

In terms of the train-frame separation Δx' = L between the two events (which are simultaneous there, Δt' = 0), this is Δt = γ v Δx' / c². It is the first piece of the Lorentz transformation, which we will derive in Chapter 4: Δt = γ(Δt' + v Δx'/c²).

Let's check that the two expressions agree numerically.

Python Time gap between the wall hits (ground frame)

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

For a real train at 30 m/s and L = 100 m, the gap is about 3 × 10⁻¹⁴ s, far below anything measurable. At a large fraction of c, it is of the order of the light-crossing time of the train. The effect exists at all speeds, but it only grows large when v is a good fraction of c.

Simultaneity depends on position, too

The formula Δt = γ v Δx'/c² shows the structure: the time gap between events depends on Δx', the spatial separation in the other frame, not just on v. Two events at the same place (Δx' = 0) and the same time in S' are the same event, and everyone agrees. But if the events are at different places, simultaneity in one frame means a gap in the other.

This is why this effect never shows up in daily life: you would need both a huge distance between events and a huge relative speed. Multiply v/c² by Δx' of one meter at 30 m/s: 30 / (9 × 10¹⁶) ≈ 3 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.

Which event "really" came first?

For two events separated by a time-like distance (one could cause the other, because light signal could get from one to the other), all observers agree on the order. For events too far apart for light to connect them (space-like), the order can differ between frames. In the example above, the train events are separated by the train length L with no time between, so they are space-like. No signal could cross from front wall to back wall. So there is no causal contradiction. We study this in the lesson on the spacetime interval.

Run a quick tool for frame-dependent ordering. It takes two events and a frame speed and tells which event comes first in the new frame. The formula Δt' = γ(Δt − vΔx/c²) is the same one, with roles swapped, and is a preview of Chapter 4.

JS Does the order of two events depend on the frame?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

"Relativity of simultaneity" does not mean that the order of cause and effect can be reversed. Only events that no signal could connect can have their order swapped by a change of frame.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. In Einstein's train, a flash goes off in the middle of the train. For the passenger, light reaches both walls at the same time. For a ground observer, which wall is hit first?

    In the ground frame the back wall moves toward the light and the front wall moves away, so the back wall is hit first.
  2. 2. Which postulate is crucial for the argument that the ground observer sees light moving at c in both directions?

    Postulate 2 says the ground observer measures c for both light flashes, which makes the walls' motion decide who is hit first.
  3. 3. Two events happen at the same time and the same place in one frame. In another inertial frame, they are...

    A coincidence (same place and time) is an objective fact: the events are one and the same.
  4. 4. The time gap between the events in the ground frame is Δt = γ v Δx'/c². If the train-frame separation Δx' is zero, what is Δt?

    With Δx' = 0 and Δt' = 0, both events are the same event, so there is no time gap in any frame.

Summary

  • Events simultaneous in one inertial frame are generally not simultaneous in another moving relative to it.
  • Einstein's train: the flash reaches both walls together in the train frame, but the back wall first in the ground frame.
  • The ground-frame gap is Δt = γ v Δx'/c²; it vanishes if the events are at the same place.
  • Order can only be swapped for events no light signal can connect; cause and effect keep their order.
  • Relativity of simultaneity is the root of time dilation, length contraction and the Lorentz transformation.

Next: Time Dilation and the Light Clock