Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 4 of 38 · Getting Started

The Michelson-Morley Puzzle

Why physicists expected an ether wind, how the 1887 Michelson-Morley interferometer was designed to find it, the arm-time calculation, and why the null result mattered.

In the 1800s, physicists had a strong reason to believe light is a wave. Waves we knew, like sound and water ripples, need a medium to travel in. So light must need a medium too. They called it the luminiferous ether: an invisible substance filling all space, at rest in some absolute frame, with light moving at speed c relative to it.

If that were true, the Earth, moving through space, would feel an "ether wind", like the wind you feel with your hand out of a moving car. Light would then travel at different speeds in different directions relative to the lab. In 1887, Albert Michelson and Edward Morley built a device to measure this difference. This lesson walks through the idea and the calculation. The result changed physics.

The ether wind prediction

Suppose the ether is at rest and the Earth moves through it at speed v. We know Earth orbits the Sun at about 29.78 km/s, so even if the Sun were at rest in the ether, the Earth would have at least that speed relative to it at some point of the year. In terms of c:

Text
β = v / c ≈ 29 780 / 299 792 458 ≈ 1.0 × 10⁻⁴

That is a tiny ratio, and β² ≈ 10⁻⁸ is even smaller. A direct measurement of one-way light speed to that precision was impossible in 1887. Michelson found a cleverer way using interference.

The interferometer

The device splits a beam of light into two beams that travel along perpendicular arms of equal length L, reflect from mirrors, and return to be recombined. Where the beams recombine, they create interference fringes: bright and dark bands. If the two beams take exactly the same time, the fringes line up. If one beam is delayed by even a fraction of a wavelength, the fringes shift.

flowchart TB
    Src["Light source"] --> BS["Beam splitter"]
    BS -- "arm 1, parallel to the wind" --> M1["Mirror 1"]
    BS -- "arm 2, perpendicular to the wind" --> M2["Mirror 2"]
    M1 --> BS
    M2 --> BS
    BS --> Det["Observer sees fringes"]

Two beams travel perpendicular paths and meet again. A time difference shifts the interference pattern.

The calculation

Assume the ether wind has speed v along arm 1.

Arm along the wind. Going out, the light moves at c − v relative to the lab (it fights the wind in this picture), and coming back at c + v. The round trip takes

Text
t₁ = L/(c − v) + L/(c + v) = 2Lc/(c² − v²) = (2L/c) / (1 − β²)

Arm across the wind. To go straight across in the lab, the light must aim a little upstream. Its speed across is √(c² − v²) both ways, so

Text
t₂ = 2L / √(c² − v²) = (2L/c) / √(1 − β²)

The difference is

Text
Δt = t₁ − t₂ = (2L/c) [1/(1 − β²) − 1/√(1 − β²)]

For small β, use 1/(1 − β²) ≈ 1 + β² and 1/√(1 − β²) ≈ 1 + β²/2. Then

Text
Δt ≈ (2L/c) × (β²/2) = (L/c) β²

As a path difference, cΔt ≈ Lβ². The trick: rotate the whole apparatus by 90°, and the arms swap roles. The path difference changes by 2Lβ². The predicted fringe shift is

Text
N = 2 L β² / λ

where λ is the wavelength of the light. Michelson and Morley used multiple reflections to make the effective arm length about 11 m, and visible light with λ around 550 nm. Let's put these numbers in Python.

Python Predicted fringe shift for an ether wind

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The predicted shift is about 0.4 of a fringe. That is easily visible, since fringe shifts of a hundredth of a fringe or so can be seen with good apparatus.

The null result

Michelson and Morley floated the apparatus on a pool of mercury so it could rotate smoothly, and watched the fringes. They found a shift much smaller than predicted, consistent with none at all. Later, more refined versions of the experiment, at different times of day and times of year and with improved precision, kept giving the same type of result: no sign of an ether wind. Modern versions with lasers and cavities have pushed the limit far below anything the ether theory could hide in.

Physicists tried to rescue the ether. One idea: the Earth drags the ether along near its surface. Others showed this conflicted with the observed aberration of starlight. Another idea, due to FitzGerald and Lorentz, was that objects moving through the ether physically contract along their direction of motion by exactly the factor needed to cancel the effect. That formula looked suspiciously like the one Einstein would later derive. The difference: Lorentz explained it as a strange force on matter, while Einstein showed that it follows from the structure of space and time itself.

You might see claims that Einstein was "responding to Michelson-Morley". The historical record is more mixed: Einstein cited the failed attempts to detect motion relative to the ether in a general way, and his 1905 paper starts from electromagnetism and the principle of relativity. The experiment is best read as one strong piece of evidence among several.

What the null result means

Three possible readings:

  1. The ether moves with the Earth (ether drag). Contradicted by other observations.
  2. Light speed depends on the source's speed (emission theories). Contradicted by astronomical observations of double stars and by later laboratory tests of light from fast-moving sources.
  3. There is no ether: the speed of light is the same in all inertial frames, and measurements of lengths and times must change to make that consistent.

Option 3 is special relativity. In the next chapter we will see why the classical rule for adding velocities cannot hold.

Our second program shows how sensitive the apparatus must be. It computes how long a "fringe" is in time and the shift for different possible wind speeds.

JS What wind speed would a given fringe shift mean?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

If the apparatus could see a shift of only 0.01 fringe, it would be sensitive to an ether wind of about 5 km/s, a small fraction of the Earth's orbital speed. A clean null result therefore ruled out the simple ether-wind picture decisively.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. What was the Michelson-Morley experiment designed to detect?

    It looked for a difference in round-trip light time along perpendicular arms, caused by an ether wind.
  2. 2. Why did the experiment rotate the apparatus?

    Rotating by 90 degrees swaps which arm is parallel to the wind, doubling the path-difference change to 2Lβ².
  3. 3. What was the result?

    No shift close to the predicted size was found. This null result undermined the stationary-ether picture.
  4. 4. Which statement is closest to the special-relativity reading of the null result?

    Special relativity drops the ether and keeps the speed of light constant for all inertial observers.

Summary

  • The ether was a proposed medium for light; Earth's motion through it should produce an "ether wind".
  • A Michelson interferometer compares round-trip times along perpendicular arms; the predicted fringe shift on rotation is N = 2Lβ²/λ, about 0.4 for the 1887 setup.
  • No shift of that size was found, and later experiments found none either.
  • The result supports the idea that light speed is the same in all inertial frames, which Einstein made a postulate.

Next: Galilean Relativity