Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 8 of 38 ยท The Principle of Relativity

Synchronizing Clocks and Measuring Events

Learn how a frame's clocks are synchronized with light signals, the difference between when an event happens and when you see it, and how to correct for light delay.

Before relativity can say that two observers disagree about time, we must be careful about what "time of an event" means. This lesson builds a precise procedure for assigning times with a lattice of clocks, and separates two things that are easy to confuse: the time an event happens in a frame, and the time you see it.

What you see is not what happens

Light takes time to travel. When you look at the Sun, you see it as it was about 8 minutes and 20 seconds ago. When you watch a distant lightning flash, you see it before you hear the thunder, because light is much faster than sound. A friend 3 light-seconds away who waves at you at noon will appear to wave at 12:00:03.

This delay is not relativity. It is plain geometry plus finite light speed, and Newton would have agreed. In the earlier lessons, "the time of an event in a frame" meant the reading of the clock at the event's location in that frame's lattice. An observer who learns about the event by light must subtract the light travel time.

Text
time of the event = time of reception โˆ’ (distance to the event) / c

This formula is for an observer at rest in the frame, who knows the distance to the event in that frame.

Python Correct for light travel time

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Flashes A and B arrive a full second apart (11 s and 12 s), but once the light delay is removed they happened almost together, both at about 10 s. Run the program to see which one happened first: it is B, even though A was received first. Received order and happening order can differ. This matters for the next lesson, where we argue about the order of events.

A lattice of synchronized clocks

To define time in a frame, imagine identical clocks at rest at every grid point. They must all show the same time. How can we set a clock at a distant place? Not by carrying one clock there, since moving a clock may change its rate (as we'll see). We use light.

Einstein synchronization. Put clock A at one place and clock B at another, both at rest in the frame, a distance d apart.

  1. At time t_A1 on clock A, send a flash toward B.
  2. When the flash reaches B, clock B reads t_B. A mirror reflects it back.
  3. The flash returns to A at time t_A2 on clock A.

We say B is synchronized with A if the outbound trip takes the same time as the return trip:

Text
t_B = (t_A1 + t_A2) / 2

This definition assumes that light takes the same time in both directions. For a frame in vacuum, and given postulate 2, that is the natural convention: the speed of light is c both ways.

Alternatively, A sends a flash at t_A1 = 0 and sets B to read d/c when the flash arrives. Both methods agree.

JS Einstein synchronization of two clocks

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Frame-based times

With a synchronized lattice, a frame assigns to every event a time: the reading of the clock at that event's place. If a flash goes off at the grid point (x, y, z) while the clock there reads t, the event is (t, x, y, z). An observer sitting anywhere does not need to see the event: bookkeeping gives its time.

Two events are simultaneous in the frame if the local clocks at their places read the same time. This is the definition that the next lesson challenges: a moving frame builds its own lattice with its own synchronization, and the two lattices disagree about which spatially separated events are simultaneous.

Synchronization is carried out within one frame. The convention that the one-way speed of light is c is part of the definition and is consistent with all experiments. What cannot depend on convention is any measurable disagreement between observers, which relativity derives from the postulates.

What is measured versus what is seen

Here is a summary that will save confusion later:

Defined by Includes light delay?
Time of an event in a frame Reading of the local clock in that frame's synchronized lattice No: delay is already corrected
What an observer sees Light arriving at the observer's eye Yes
Doppler-shifted observed rate Combination of time dilation and light delay Yes

When you read "moving clocks run slow" in this course, we mean the lattice-based time: the rate comparison made with local clocks, not by eye. When we want what a camera would record, we say so.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A flash happens 6 ร— 10โธ m away and you see it at 12.0 s. About when did it happen (c โ‰ˆ 3 ร— 10โธ m/s)?

    Light delay is 6e8 / 3e8 = 2 s, so the flash happened at 12 โˆ’ 2 = 10 s.
  2. 2. In Einstein synchronization, A sends a flash at t = 0 and receives the reflection at t = 8 s. What should B read when the flash arrives?

    The outbound and return trips take equal time, so B should read the midpoint, (0 + 8)/2 = 4 s.
  3. 3. Why not synchronize distant clocks by carrying one clock there?

    As we will see, moving clocks run slow, so a transported clock is not guaranteed to agree with the lattice.
  4. 4. What does the time of an event in a frame mean?

    A frame assigns times from its synchronized clocks at each place, which does not depend on when light reaches any particular viewer.

Summary

  • What you see is delayed by distance / c; the time of an event in a frame is the reading of the local synchronized clock.
  • Einstein synchronization sets clock B to the midpoint of the send and return times of a light flash from A.
  • A frame is a lattice of synchronized clocks and rulers, at rest in that frame.
  • Two spatially separated events are simultaneous in a frame if local clocks read the same time when they happen.
  • Different frames have different lattices, which is the source of the relativity of simultaneity.

Next: The Relativity of Simultaneity