Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 14 of 38 ยท Time Dilation and Length Contraction

Length Contraction Paradoxes

Work through the pole-and-barn paradox with numbers: why a contracted pole fits in the barn in one frame, not in the other, and how simultaneity resolves the apparent contradiction.

Relativity produces puzzles that look like logical contradictions. They are good teachers: each one forces you to be explicit about what "at the same time" means. The most famous is the pole-in-the-barn paradox (also told with a ladder and a garage). It is a clean test of whether you understand length contraction together with the relativity of simultaneity.

The setup

A barn has rest length L_b = 10 m, with a door at each end. A pole has rest length L_p = 10 m: exactly as long as the barn. The pole is carried at speed v = 0.866c (so ฮณ = 2) along the barn's axis, through the entrance door and toward the exit door.

Barn frame. The pole is moving, so it is contracted: L_p/ฮณ = 5 m. The barn is 10 m, so there is room to spare. For one instant, the whole pole is inside the barn. At that instant both doors can be shut: the pole is trapped inside with 5 m to spare.

Pole frame. Now the barn is moving, so it is contracted to 10/2 = 5 m. The pole is 10 m long. It cannot possibly fit in a 5 m barn. So when the doors... what happens?

The paradox: in one frame the pole fits and both doors close with the pole inside. In the other it is twice as long as the barn. Surely one frame must be wrong? No. Both are right, and the resolution is exact.

The resolution: the two door-closing events

"Both doors shut at the same time" is a statement about simultaneity, and simultaneity depends on the frame. The two door-closing events are separated by 10 m in the barn frame and are simultaneous there. In the pole's frame they are not simultaneous.

Use the Lorentz transformation (we derive it in the next chapter, and here only preview it):

Text
x' = ฮณ (x โˆ’ v t)         t' = ฮณ (t โˆ’ v x / cยฒ)

with c = 1 in "meters of light time". Place the barn from x = 0 (entrance) to x = 10 m (exit). Events in the barn frame:

  • Event A: the entrance door closes at x = 0, t = 0.
  • Event B: the exit door closes at x = 10 m, t = 0.

At t = 0 the pole (5 m long, centered in the barn) spans x = 2.5 to 7.5 m. Both doors close with the pole inside. Now transform to the pole frame.

Python The two door-closing events in both frames

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

In the pole frame the exit door closes first, at t' โ‰ˆ โˆ’17.3, and the entrance door closes later, at t' = 0. The barn is only 5 m long here and the pole is 10 m, so the whole pole is never inside with both doors closed. There is no contradiction: "both doors are closed at the same moment" is simply false in this frame.

What happens physically

Now the interesting part. In the barn frame, the pole is "trapped" inside with both doors closed. But the front of the pole hits the closed exit door, a collision. What next? The front end stops, but the back end does not know yet, since information travels at most at c through the pole (in real materials, much slower: the speed of sound in the pole).

Because the rod cannot be perfectly rigid, the back end keeps moving into the barn until the "stop" signal arrives. Relativity forbids perfectly rigid bodies: a push at one end cannot instantly move the other. What the pole does afterwards depends on its material, and no analysis from the two frames gives a contradiction, because they predict the same sequence of events, only described with different coordinates.

You can verify that the collision happens in both frames at the same event: the front end meets the closed exit door. Barn frame: front end at x = 7.5 at t = 0, moving at ฮฒ, reaches x = 10 after t = 2.5/ฮฒ โ‰ˆ 2.887. Pole frame: transform the event (t, x) = (2.887, 10).

JS The collision is one event seen in two frames

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The collision event has pole-frame position x' = 15 m, exactly where the front end of the pole sits (it is at rest at x' = 15 m in its own frame), as it must be. In both frames the collision happens after the exit door closes, because the door closing can influence the collision: the two events are time-like separated, so every frame agrees on their order.

The ladder and garage

The same puzzle appears with a ladder and a garage. The structure is identical: a ladder longer than the garage at rest can fit in the garage when it moves fast enough, if "fit" means "both ends inside at the same instant in the garage frame". The ladder's own frame sees the garage even shorter. The answer to "does the ladder fit?" is: it depends on the frame, because "at the same instant" depends on the frame. No frame-independent fact is violated.

Other classic puzzles

  • The twin paradox involves time dilation and acceleration; see the last lesson of this slice.
  • Bell's spaceship paradox: two rockets connected by a thread, both accelerating identically from rest in the lab frame. The distance between them stays the same in the lab frame, but the thread's proper length must increase, so it snaps. This is a famous demonstration that contraction applies to physical objects and not to coordinate distances.
  • The train-and-tunnel: same structure as pole-and-barn.

To solve any "paradox": (1) pick one frame, (2) list the events with coordinates in that frame, (3) transform the events to the other frame, (4) compare the events, not the descriptions. Contradictions disappear when you check the events themselves.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. In the barn frame, why can both doors be closed with the pole inside?

    At ฮณ = 2 the pole is contracted to 5 m in the barn frame, so it fits with room to spare.
  2. 2. In the pole frame, what happens to the doors?

    Simultaneous events in the barn frame, separated along the motion, are not simultaneous in the pole frame; the exit closes earlier.
  3. 3. What is the resolution of the pole-in-the-barn paradox?

    'Fits' needs the two ends to be inside at the same time, and that depends on the frame.
  4. 4. What is the first step in analyzing a relativistic paradox?

    Events are frame-independent facts; compare events, then you can transform coordinates between frames.

Summary

  • Length contraction plus relativity of simultaneity resolves the pole-in-the-barn paradox: a 10 m pole can fit inside a 10 m barn in the barn frame, but not in the pole frame.
  • The two door-closing events are simultaneous in the barn frame, with the exit door closing first in the pole frame.
  • Rigid bodies cannot exist in relativity; effects of the collision spread at finite speed.
  • To resolve any paradox, list events in one frame, transform them, and compare events rather than descriptions.

Next: The Lorentz Transformations