Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 28 of 38 · Equivalence Principle and Curved Spacetime

The Equivalence Principle

Learn Einstein's equivalence principle, the elevator thought experiments, why free fall is 'weightless', and how tidal forces mark the limit of local frames.

Special relativity ignores gravity. It describes inertial frames, where free particles move in straight lines at constant speed. But gravity pulls on everything. How could you put gravity into relativity? Einstein's key insight, which he called "the happiest thought of my life", was that a person who falls freely does not feel their own weight. This simple observation leads to a new theory of gravity.

This lesson explains the equivalence principle, what it predicts, and where its limits are.

Two kinds of mass

Newton's physics uses the word "mass" in two roles:

  • Inertial mass m_i: resistance to acceleration in F = m_i a.
  • Gravitational mass m_g: the "charge" that couples to gravity in F = m_g g.

Nothing in Newtonian physics says these must be equal. For electric force, the charge q and the inertial mass are unrelated, and different objects accelerate differently. For gravity they are equal to extraordinary precision, so every object falls with the same acceleration g regardless of its mass or composition (when air resistance is negligible). Galileo is said to have tested this with falling bodies, and Newton tested it with pendulums. In 1889 and later, Loránd Eötvös used a torsion balance to confirm equality to about one part in 10⁹, and later experiments reached about 10⁻¹³. A satellite experiment named MICROSCOPE (launched 2016) tested titanium and platinum test masses falling around Earth, and it confirmed equal acceleration to about one part in 10¹⁴ or better.

Einstein took this coincidence seriously. It is not a coincidence if gravity is not a force at all.

The elevator thought experiment

Imagine a windowless elevator, and an observer inside who can do experiments. Consider four cases:

  1. At rest on Earth's surface. Dropped objects fall with acceleration g = 9.8 m/s². A scale shows the observer's weight.
  2. Far from any mass, accelerating upward with a = g. Dropped objects "fall" to the floor with acceleration g, since the floor rushes up to meet them. The scale shows the same weight.
  3. Freely falling near Earth (the cable is cut). The floor, the observer and everything else fall together. Objects float. The scale reads zero.
  4. Far from any mass, not accelerating. Objects float. The scale reads zero.

Cases 1 and 2 are indistinguishable by any local experiment. Cases 3 and 4 are also indistinguishable. This is the equivalence principle: a uniform gravitational field is locally equivalent to a uniformly accelerating frame, and a freely falling frame is locally equivalent to an inertial frame with no gravity.

Three versions

  • Weak equivalence principle (WEP). The path of a small freely falling test body depends only on its initial position and velocity, not on its mass or composition. This is the universality of free fall.
  • Einstein equivalence principle (EEP). In a freely falling local frame, the laws of all non-gravitational physics (electromagnetism, atomic physics, special relativity) take their special-relativistic form. This implies the gravitational redshift and the bending of light.
  • Strong equivalence principle (SEP). The same applies to gravitational physics itself, including the self-gravity of bodies such as planets and neutron stars.

General relativity satisfies all three.

What "local" means: tidal forces

The words "locally" and "small" matter. A real gravitational field is not uniform. Two objects falling toward Earth head toward its center, so they move slightly closer together, and the object closer to Earth is pulled harder than the one farther away. Inside a large enough falling elevator you could detect these tidal effects.

For two points separated radially by L at distance r from a mass M, the difference in gravitational acceleration is approximately

Δg ≈ 2GM L / r³

and for a separation perpendicular to the radial direction the two accelerations differ in direction, pushing the objects together with magnitude GM L / r³.

Tides are the leading evidence that gravity is curvature: a genuine gravitational field cannot be removed everywhere at once by choosing a single accelerating frame.

Python Tidal accelerations

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The Moon, though far smaller than the Sun, produces more than twice the tidal effect because tides depend on 1/r³, which strongly favors the nearer body. These are the accelerations behind ocean tides.

Predictions: light falls

Imagine a laser beam crossing a rocket cabin of width L that accelerates upward at a. The light takes time L/c to cross. During that time the cabin moves up by ½a(L/c)², so the spot hits the wall slightly below where it started. In the cabin frame, light curves downward. By the equivalence principle the same happens in a gravitational field: gravity bends light.

For an ordinary cabin the effect is tiny.

Python Light in an accelerating cabin

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input · what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

A 10 m cabin gives a displacement of order 10⁻¹⁵ m, about the size of a proton. This is why bending of light by gravity is seen only with huge masses, such as the Sun.

The "falling" cabin and the "accelerating" cabin are equivalent only for small regions of spacetime. In a large region, tides tell the difference. That is why gravity cannot be reduced to a force in flat spacetime: it must instead change the geometry of spacetime, as explained in Curved Spacetime and Geodesics.

Check your understanding

Quick check · 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 · perfect!

  1. 1. What does the weak equivalence principle state?

    The weak equivalence principle is the universality of free fall: the equality of inertial and gravitational mass.
  2. 2. An elevator in free fall near Earth (cable cut). A passenger releases a ball in mid-air. What does the passenger see?

    The ball and the elevator fall together with the same acceleration, so locally there is no gravity: the ball floats.
  3. 3. Why can't gravity always be removed by going into free fall?

    Differences in the gravitational acceleration over a finite region (tides) cannot be removed by a single accelerating frame.
  4. 4. The tidal acceleration over a radial separation L at distance r from mass M is approximately:

    Differentiating g = GM/r² with respect to r gives |dg/dr| = 2GM/r³, so Δg ≈ 2GM L/r³.

Summary

  • Inertial and gravitational mass are equal to extraordinary precision; this is the basis for the equivalence principle.
  • Locally, a uniform gravitational field is indistinguishable from an accelerating frame; a freely falling frame is locally inertial.
  • Weak, Einstein and strong versions apply to test bodies, non-gravitational physics and gravity itself.
  • Tidal forces Δg ≈ 2GM L/r³ limit how big a "local" region can be, and show that gravity is curvature.
  • The equivalence principle implies that light bends and clocks run at different rates in gravity.

Next: Gravitational Redshift and Time Dilation