Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 6 of 38 ยท The Principle of Relativity

Galilean Velocity Addition Meets Light

Apply the Galilean rule u' = u โˆ’ v to a light pulse, see the contradiction with Maxwell's equations and experiments, and compare the three ways physicists could respond.

In everyday life, velocities add. Throw a ball forward at 20 m/s from a train moving at 30 m/s, and a person on the platform sees the ball move at 50 m/s. This lesson applies the same rule to light and shows it leads to a clear contradiction. Understanding the contradiction precisely is what made Einstein's solution so convincing.

The rule

Let frame S' move at velocity v relative to S. An object has velocity u in S and u' in S'. Galilean addition says

Text
u' = u โˆ’ v        (equivalently u = u' + v)

This works with trains, cars, boats, sound-in-wind (almost: air is a medium), and everything else slow. It is built into our intuition because it follows from the Galilean transformation and the assumption that time is the same in both frames.

Apply it to a light pulse

Suppose in frame S a light pulse moves in the +x direction with speed c. A spaceship (frame S') chases the pulse at speed v = 0.5c. By the Galilean rule, the pulse moves relative to the ship at

Text
u' = c โˆ’ 0.5c = 0.5c

If the ship moves at 0.9c, the pulse barely creeps ahead at 0.1c. If the ship moves at c, the pulse stands still next to the ship. If the ship moved faster than c (the rule has no limit), the light would overtake the ship backward.

An observer on the ship could in principle measure the light's speed and so find out their own velocity relative to the ether. That would violate the principle of relativity: it would let them detect uniform motion. Let's tabulate what Galilean addition predicts.

Python Galilean prediction for a light pulse

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

For a ship moving at 1.5c, the Galilean rule says the pulse moves at โˆ’0.5c, meaning backward. We now know that the correct rule never allows that. Experiments show the light is still measured at c, whatever the ship does.

What the evidence says

Several lines of evidence agree that the Galilean rule fails for light:

  1. Michelson-Morley and its descendants. Round-trip light times are the same in all directions to very high precision (see the previous chapter).
  2. Light from moving sources. In modern experiments, high-energy neutral pions travelling at very close to c decay into photons. The photons' speed was measured, and it did not include the pion's speed added on top. The result matched c to high precision. (The experiment is a test of the idea that the source's speed adds to the light's speed.)
  3. Fizeau's flowing-water experiment (1851). Light in moving water does not have the speed c/n + v that Galilean addition predicts. The measured speed is c/n + v(1 โˆ’ 1/nยฒ), with a smaller "drag" coefficient. We will show in Chapter 4 that the relativistic velocity addition formula reproduces this to first order in v.
  4. Particle accelerators. Particles pushed to 0.9999999c and beyond never exceed c, and the energy needed grows without limit. Galilean mechanics would allow arbitrary speeds.

Three ways out

Physicists in 1900 had three kinds of response:

Response Idea Problem
Stationary ether Light moves at c only in the ether frame; Galilean addition applies elsewhere Michelson-Morley found no ether wind
Emission theory Light speed is c relative to the source, so the source's speed adds Contradicted by observations of binary stars and by modern source-speed tests
Change the transformation Light has speed c in all inertial frames; the Galilean transformation must be wrong Requires giving up absolute time

The third path is Einstein's. It looks drastic, since it denies something that seemed obvious. But it makes the principle of relativity work for everything, including Maxwell's equations.

Where does the Galilean argument break?

The Galilean rule u' = u โˆ’ v depends on two assumptions:

  • Distances measured in the two frames agree (rulers do not change).
  • Time is absolute: t' = t.

If light really has the same speed c in both frames, then at least one of those assumptions must give. The speed is distance over time, and for the same pulse to have the same c in two frames that move relative to each other, the frames must disagree about distances, or times, or both. The following program shows this with a toy calculation: suppose both frames measure the pulse and find c. What would the clocks have to say?

JS If the speed is c in both frames, what must change?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The toy calculation above is not the correct relativistic answer, because in relativity lengths change too. It only shows that keeping x' = x โˆ’ vt and demanding speed c forces t' โ‰  t. The correct transformation (Chapter 4) changes both.

What comes next

The way forward is to choose the postulates and follow them with a careful mind: not to assume anything about time or length, only that all inertial observers see the same laws and the same c. Then derive the new transformation. That is the program of the next lesson, Einstein's postulates.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. According to Galilean addition, how fast does a light pulse (speed c in S) move relative to a spaceship chasing it at 0.5c?

    u' = c โˆ’ 0.5c = 0.5c. The measured value, in fact, is c.
  2. 2. Which observation contradicts the idea that a source's speed adds to the speed of the light it emits?

    Photons from very fast sources are measured at c, not c plus the source speed.
  3. 3. Which assumption of the Galilean transformation must be dropped to make c the same in all frames?

    To keep c constant in both frames, the frames must disagree about times or distances (in fact, both).
  4. 4. What does Fizeau's moving-water experiment show?

    The measured drag coefficient is 1 โˆ’ 1/nยฒ, less than the full amount, and it agrees with relativistic velocity addition.

Summary

  • Galilean addition (u' = u โˆ’ v) would make the speed of light depend on the observer, letting an observer detect absolute motion.
  • Experiments, from Michelson-Morley to tests with fast sources, show light speed is the same for all inertial observers.
  • Options were a stationary ether, emission theories, or a new transformation; only the last survives.
  • If c is the same in all frames, frames must disagree about times and lengths.

Next: Einstein's Two Postulates