Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 33 of 37 ยท Solutions and Policy

Environmental Economics and Externalities

Learn why markets overuse the environment, how externalities, carbon taxes and cap-and-trade work, and calculate an optimal pollution tax.

Why do we pollute when pollution harms us? Economics gives part of the answer. When a factory or driver does not pay for the damage it causes, the price of its product is too low, so too much is produced. Environmental economics studies this problem and designs policies that correct it. This lesson explains externalities, the tragedy of the commons, and the two main market tools: taxes and tradable permits.

Externalities

An externality is a cost or benefit that falls on someone who did not choose to be involved in the transaction.

  • A negative externality is a cost to others, such as air pollution from a power plant or noise from a factory.
  • A positive externality is a benefit to others, such as a neighbor's well-kept garden or a vaccinated person protecting others.

Producers consider only their private cost. Society bears the social cost, which equals the private cost plus the external cost. If prices ignore the external cost, the market produces more of the harmful activity than is best for society.

Economists do not claim that the ideal level of pollution is zero. They compare the extra benefit of doing more of an activity (marginal benefit) with the extra cost to society (marginal social cost) and look for the level where they are equal.

A numerical model

Suppose the demand for a product is P = 100 โˆ’ Q (price falls as quantity rises). The private marginal cost is MPC = 20 + Q and each unit also causes damage of 20 units of money, so MSC = 40 + Q.

  • Market outcome: set demand equal to private cost: 100 โˆ’ Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 40.
  • Social optimum: set demand equal to social cost: 100 โˆ’ Q = 40 + Q, so Q = 30.

So the market overproduces by 10 units. A tax equal to the external damage per unit (here 20) makes the producer's cost match the social cost, so the market moves to Q = 30. Such a tax is called a Pigouvian tax, after the economist Arthur Pigou.

Python Optimal pollution tax

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

The tragedy of the commons

In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin described the tragedy of the commons. A shared resource that no one owns, such as a pasture, fishery or the atmosphere, tends to be overused when each user gains the full benefit of taking more while the cost is spread among all. Solutions include private ownership, government regulation, and community management with agreed rules. Elinor Ostrom showed that many local communities manage shared resources successfully with clear boundaries, rules and monitoring, work that earned her the Nobel Prize in economics in 2009.

Carbon pricing

Greenhouse gas emissions are a global externality, so many governments price carbon.

Carbon tax. The government sets a price per tonne of COโ‚‚ and the market decides how much to emit. The price is certain; the quantity is not. Revenue can be returned to households as a dividend or used to cut other taxes or fund clean energy.

Cap-and-trade (emissions trading). The government sets a cap on total emissions and issues or auctions permits that add up to the cap. Companies can buy and sell permits. Those who can cut emissions cheaply do so and sell spare permits; those who find it expensive buy them. The quantity is certain; the price varies. The European Union Emissions Trading System is the largest such scheme.

Python Cost of a carbon tax on fuel

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Valuing the environment

How much is clean air or a forest worth? Economists estimate total economic value that includes direct use (timber), indirect use (flood control, carbon storage), and non-use values (existence and bequest value). Ecosystem services are the benefits nature gives us, such as pollination, water filtration and climate regulation. Methods include market prices, avoided cost, travel cost and surveys asking people what they would pay. All of them are imperfect, and some things, such as an extinct species, are irreplaceable.

Cost-benefit analysis compares total costs and benefits of a policy, usually converted to money and discounted over time. The discount rate reduces the weight of future benefits; for long-lived problems such as climate, a high discount rate makes future damage look small, which is why the choice is debated. The social cost of carbon estimates the damage of an extra tonne of COโ‚‚, and published values vary widely depending on assumptions.

Fairness and design

Environmental taxes can fall harder on low-income households, so many designs return revenue to them. Subsidies for fossil fuels worldwide work against the goal because they lower the price of polluting energy; reforming them is a common recommendation. Policies are often combined: for example a carbon price, efficiency standards and public investment in transport.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A negative externality is

    Pollution harming neighbors who did not choose to be involved is the typical example.
  2. 2. Demand P = 100 โˆ’ Q, private cost 20 + Q, external damage 20 per unit. What is the socially best quantity?

    Set 100 โˆ’ Q = 40 + Q to get Q = 30.
  3. 3. In cap-and-trade, which quantity is fixed?

    The cap fixes the total; the permit price is set by the market.
  4. 4. The tragedy of the commons describes

    Individuals gain from using more while the costs are shared.

Summary

  • Externalities are costs or benefits that markets ignore, so prices can be wrong.
  • A Pigouvian tax equal to the external damage can restore the social optimum.
  • Common resources tend to be overused unless rules or ownership exist.
  • Carbon taxes fix the price; cap-and-trade fixes the quantity.
  • Valuing nature and choosing discount rates involve judgments about fairness and the future.

Next: The Renewable Transition and Green Policy