Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 58 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Syllogisms

Solve syllogism questions with the Venn diagram method: all, some and no statements, possibility cases, either-or conclusions and a live checker.

A syllogism gives you two or three short statements about groups of things, then offers conclusions and asks which of them must follow. The statements are often silly on purpose ("All pens are books, all books are cups") so that your general knowledge cannot interfere. The only thing that matters is the logic of the sets.

This lesson teaches a method that always works: draw the statements as overlapping circles, look at what the picture forces, and distinguish what is certain from what is merely possible. You will also run a small program that checks every possible arrangement of three groups, so you can see exactly why a conclusion follows or fails.

The four statement forms

Every syllogism statement is one of four forms. Learn the picture that goes with each.

Form Example Picture
All A are B All cats are animals A circle fully inside B
Some A are B Some animals are cats A and B overlap
No A is B No cat is a dog Two separate circles
Some A are not B Some animals are not cats Part of A lies outside B

Look at them in a live drawing. Each small diagram is built with the same colors you will use on paper: A in blue, B in orange, and the area the statement guarantees is not empty marked with a dot.

The four statement forms as Venn diagrams

Two reading rules follow from the pictures. First, "some" means at least one, not "a few" and not "most". Second, "some A are B" and "some B are A" say the same thing, and so do "no A is B" and "no B is A". But "all A are B" does not say "all B are A": the circle A may be smaller than B.

Reading a statement the way an exam does

Syllogisms use a convention you should adopt for every question: the groups named in the statements are assumed to have at least one member. Under this convention "All A are B" also tells you that some A are B (A has members, and they are all inside B), and so also "Some B are A". It is not the same as the stricter logic of philosophers, who would say an empty group makes "All A are B" true without any A existing. The exam convention matches how almost every answer key is written. The checker below has a switch for it so you can see the difference.

The Venn method

  1. Draw one circle per term (A, B, C), placing them according to the first statement.
  2. Add the second statement without breaking the first.
  3. Where a statement leaves several possible pictures, draw every one that fits.
  4. A conclusion follows only if it is true in every picture. If it is true in some pictures and false in others, it does not follow.
flowchart TD
    S["Read the statements"] --> D["Draw every picture that fits"]
    D --> Q["Test the conclusion in each picture"]
    Q --> A{"True in all pictures?"}
    A -->|"Yes"| F["Follows"]
    A -->|"Only in some"| P["Does not follow<br/>but is possible"]
    A -->|"In none"| N["Cannot be true"]

The test for a conclusion: certain, possible, or impossible, judged across all the pictures.

Example 1. Statements: All A are B. All B are C. Does "All A are C" follow?

Draw A inside B and B inside C. A is inside C, so yes, all A are C. By the exam convention, some A are C and some C are A follow too. But "All C are A" does not follow: C can be larger than A.

Example 2. Statements: Some A are B. All B are C. Whatever picture you draw, the overlap of A and B lies inside C, so some A are C follows, and so does "Some C are A". "All A are C" does not follow because A may extend outside B and C.

Example 3. Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. Draw A inside B. The C circle overlaps B, but it may overlap the A part, or the rest of B, or both. So nothing definite follows about A and C. "Some A are C" is possible, but not forced.

Quick rules for two statements

You can solve most questions by pattern. The table gives the definite conclusions between the two outer terms A and C when the middle term is B (A-B in the first statement, B-C in the second). These are the results of drawing every picture under the exam convention.

First statement Second statement Certain conclusion
All A are B All B are C All A are C
All A are B No B is C No A is C (and Some A are not C)
Some A are B All B are C Some A are C
Some A are B No B is C Some A are not C
No A is B All B are C Some C are not A
No A is B Some B are C Some C are not A

Anything else, such as "some, some" or "all, some" or "no, no", gives no definite conclusion between A and C.

Check them by brute force

The following page tests any pair of premises against every possible way of filling the three-circle Venn diagram (each of the eight regions is either empty or occupied, 256 possibilities). A conclusion follows if it holds in every possibility that satisfies both premises, is possible if it holds in some, and cannot be true if it holds in none. Tick or untick the box to compare the exam convention (every group has members) with the strict reading.

Syllogism checker

The page starts on "Some A are B, All B are C", which gives Some A are C as the only certain conclusion, as in Example 2. The page also prints an either-or note about "All A are C" and "Some A are not C": that pair is complementary, so one of the two is always true, although neither is forced. Try "All A are B, Some B are C" and you will see that no row says "follows", which is Example 3. Then untick the convention box with "All A are B, All B are C" and watch "Some A are C" drop from "follows" to "possible": under the strict reading, an empty A would make that false.

Possibility cases and either-or

Two further types appear in exams.

Possibility. A conclusion such as "Some A being C is a possibility" is true whenever at least one picture allows it. In the checker, any row marked "possible" or "follows" counts as a possibility. A row marked "cannot be true" does not.

Either-or. Two conclusions form an either-or pair when they are complementary: exactly one of them is true in every picture. The classic pairs are:

  • "Some A are C" and "No A is C"
  • "All A are C" and "Some A are not C"

If neither conclusion follows on its own, but together they cover every picture, the answer is "either I or II follows". The checker prints such a note when both members of a pair are "possible". The pair must use the same two terms in the same direction; unrelated conclusions never make an either-or.

Example 4. Statements: Some tables are chairs. Some chairs are desks. I. Some tables are desks. II. No table is a desk.

Both conclusions are possible, neither is forced, and they are complementary. So either I or II follows.

Example 5. Statements: All flowers are trees. Some trees are rocks. I. Some flowers are rocks. II. All flowers are rocks.

Neither is forced, and they are not complementary (they can both be false when no flower is a rock), so neither follows.

Common mistakes

  • Reversing "all". "All A are B" does not give "All B are A".
  • Using real-world facts. If the statement says "All pens are books", accept it, however strange.
  • Missing a picture. Always ask whether there is another way to draw the second statement.
  • Mixing up "some" with "some not". "Some A are B" and "Some A are not B" can both be true at once.
  • Forgetting the complementary pair and answering "neither" when the answer is "either-or".

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Statements: All pens are books. All books are cups. Conclusions: I. All pens are cups. II. Some cups are pens. Which follows?

    Pens sit inside books, which sit inside cups, so all pens are cups. By the exam convention the pens exist, so some cups are pens too.
  2. 2. Statements: Some roads are lanes. All lanes are paths. Conclusions: I. Some roads are paths. II. All roads are paths. Which follows?

    The roads that are lanes are also paths, so some roads are paths. Roads outside the lanes may not be paths, so II does not follow.
  3. 3. Statements: No cat is a dog. Some dogs are birds. Conclusions: I. Some birds are not cats. II. No bird is a cat. Which follows?

    A bird that is a dog cannot be a cat, so some birds are not cats. Other birds may be cats, so II does not follow.
  4. 4. Statements: Some tables are chairs. Some chairs are desks. Conclusions: I. Some tables are desks. II. No table is a desk. Which is correct?

    Neither is forced, but they are complementary: in every picture exactly one is true. So either I or II follows.
  5. 5. Statements: All flowers are trees. Some trees are rocks. Conclusions: I. Some flowers are rocks. II. All flowers are rocks. Which follows?

    The rocks that are trees may lie outside the flowers, so neither conclusion is forced. They are not complementary, because both are false when no flower is a rock.

Summary

  • Syllogism statements come in four forms: all, some, no, and some-not. Each has a fixed picture.
  • A conclusion follows only if it is true in every Venn picture that fits the statements.
  • By the exam convention, named groups are assumed to have members, so "All A are B" implies "Some A are B".
  • "Some" and "no" statements are symmetric; "all" is not.
  • A conclusion marked "possible" can hold but is not forced; a possibility question accepts it.
  • Complementary conclusions (some/no, all/some-not) give an either-or answer when neither is forced.

Next: Statements: Conclusions, Assumptions and Arguments, where the same careful reading is applied to real-world statements.