Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 61 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Decision Making and Eligibility Criteria Questions

Solve selection and eligibility-criteria reasoning questions with a tick-off method, exception handling and a runnable rule checker built from our own examples.

Many reasoning papers and recruitment exams include a block that looks like a policy document. A list of conditions says who may be admitted, hired or awarded something, and then a series of candidates is described in a few lines. For each one you must decide: select, reject, refer the case to someone, or say that the information is not enough. These are decision-making questions, also called eligibility-criteria or selection questions.

No knowledge is tested. What is tested is discipline: reading every condition exactly as written, noticing the exceptions, and not using your own opinion about what is fair. Candidates lose marks by assuming a missing fact, by forgetting a waiver, or by applying a rule that was never stated. This lesson gives you a repeatable method, a worked policy with nine candidates, and a program that applies the same rules so you can see the logic. If you have not met the idea of valid and invalid inference, read Statements and Conclusions first.

The anatomy of a policy

Almost every set has the same four parts:

  1. Mandatory conditions: every one must hold ("must be a citizen", "at least 60% marks").
  2. Exceptions or relaxations: a condition that is waived or loosened in a stated case ("this does not apply to research students").
  3. Referral rules: cases that go to a named person or body instead of being decided ("if marks are between 55 and 59, refer to the committee").
  4. The decision options: for example "Award", "Do not award", "Refer to the committee", "Data inadequate".

Here is the policy we will use throughout. It is original and invented for practice.

A student is eligible for the Founders' Scholarship if the student:

  1. is a citizen of the country;
  2. is between 18 and 25 years of age (both inclusive) on 1 July. Research students may be up to 28.
  3. has scored at least 60% marks in the last examination. If the marks are 55% or more but below 60%, the case is referred to the scholarship committee (all other conditions must be met).
  4. has an annual family income below 4 lakh. This condition is waived for students with 85% or more.

The method: a tick-off table

Do not read each candidate and then think about the whole policy. Instead, build a small table with one column for each condition and mark each cell with a symbol.

  • โœ“ the condition is satisfied (or waived by an exception);
  • โœ— the condition is clearly not satisfied;
  • ? the information needed to decide is missing;
  • R the referral band applies.

Then read the row with these priority rules:

  1. Any โœ— means "do not award", even if another cell is "?". A candidate who definitely fails one mandatory condition is out whatever the missing facts are.
  2. Otherwise, any ? means "data inadequate".
  3. Otherwise, any R means "refer".
  4. Otherwise, all โœ“ means "award".
flowchart TD
    A["Read one candidate"] --> B["Mark each condition: tick, cross, question or refer"]
    B --> C{"Any cross?"}
    C -->|Yes| D["Do not award"]
    C -->|No| E{"Any question mark?"}
    E -->|Yes| F["Data inadequate"]
    E -->|No| G{"Any refer?"}
    G -->|Yes| H["Refer to committee"]
    G -->|No| I["Award"]

The order of the checks matters: a firm failure outranks missing data.

Worked candidates

Apply the table to nine candidates. Read each fact carefully; only what is written counts.

Candidate Facts given Row Decision
Mira citizen, age 22, 72%, income 3.2 lakh โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ Award
Dev citizen, age 20, 91%, income 6 lakh โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ (income waived at 85%+) Award
Anil citizen, age 27, 68%, income 2 lakh, not a research student โœ“ โœ— โœ“ โœ“ Do not award
Sara citizen, age 19, 58%, income 3 lakh โœ“ โœ“ R โœ“ Refer
Tom not a citizen, age 21, 80%, income 1 lakh โœ— โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ Do not award
Lena citizen, age 23, 66%, income not mentioned โœ“ โœ“ โœ“ ? Data inadequate
Ravi citizen, age 27, 90%, income 9 lakh, research student โœ“ โœ“ (exception) โœ“ โœ“ (waived) Award
Priya citizen, age 30, 40%, income not mentioned, not a research student โœ“ โœ— โœ— ? Do not award
Kabir citizenship not mentioned, age 24, 50%, income 2 lakh ? โœ“ โœ— โœ“ Do not award

Look at the traps. Dev fails the income test on its face but the 85% waiver rescues him. Ravi is too old for the ordinary rule, but as a research student he is allowed up to 28, and his high marks waive the income rule. Priya has a missing income figure, but two firm failures decide her case. Kabir has a missing citizenship fact, yet 50% marks already rules him out. Tom has excellent marks, but citizenship has no exception, so the policy's silence is a "no".

Never fill a gap with a guess. "Lena's income is not mentioned" does not mean it is low or high. If no condition clearly fails, the correct answer for Lena is "data inadequate", not "award".

Frequent traps

  • Boundary words: "between 18 and 25" may or may not include the ends; look for "inclusive" or "exclusive". "Below 4 lakh" excludes exactly 4 lakh; "at least 60%" includes exactly 60.
  • "Only" and "all": "Must have all of the following" differs from "at least one of the following".
  • Dates: age "on 1 July" differs from age today.
  • Order of exceptions: a waiver removes a condition; it does not add a new one. A research student is exempt from the age limit as stated (28), not from every condition.
  • Percent versus fraction: 55 out of 100 and 33 out of 60 are different; convert before comparing.
  • Referral cases: they are decided only if every other condition is satisfied. A student in the referral band who fails another condition is simply rejected.
  • Your own sense of fairness: ignore it. The policy is the only authority.

The checker

The script below encodes the same policy as functions and prints the decision with the full tick-off row for each candidate. It treats a missing fact as unknown, which is exactly what the "?" cell does. Compare its output with the table above.

JS Scholarship rule checker

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

A boundary test finishes the job: it varies one fact at a time around the thresholds, so you can see exactly where the decision changes.

JS Where do the decisions change?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Writing your own practice sets

To train yourself, take any real rule list (a library membership policy, a gym's joining rules) and write five candidates for it: one clear pass, one clear fail, one waiver case, one missing fact, one boundary value. If you can predict the decision before running the checker above, you have the skill. Mixed sets of policy questions appear again in the full-length papers at the end of this track.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Under the scholarship policy, a citizen aged 23 with 66% marks has no income stated, and nothing else is missing. What is the decision?

    No condition clearly fails, but the income condition cannot be checked (marks are below 85%, so there is no waiver). The answer is data inadequate.
  2. 2. A citizen aged 20 has 91% marks and an annual family income of 6 lakh. What is the decision?

    Income 6 lakh would normally fail, but the exception waives the income condition for 85% or more, so every condition is satisfied.
  3. 3. A student's citizenship is not stated, but the student scored 50%. What is the decision?

    A definite failure outranks missing data. 50% is below the 55% referral band, so the student is rejected whatever the citizenship is.
  4. 4. A citizen aged 27 who is not a research student has 68% marks and income 2 lakh. What is the decision?

    The age limit is 25 for ordinary students. The extension to 28 is for research students only, so the age condition fails.
  5. 5. A citizen aged 19 with 58% marks and income 3 lakh. What is the decision?

    Marks of 55% to below 60% fall in the referral band, and all the other conditions are met, so the case goes to the committee.

Summary

  • Decision-making sets have mandatory conditions, exceptions, referral rules and a fixed list of decisions.
  • Build a tick-off row for each candidate: satisfied, failed, unknown or refer.
  • Priority: any failure means reject, then any unknown means data inadequate, then any referral means refer, otherwise select.
  • Never assume a missing fact and never apply rules the policy does not state.
  • Watch inclusive and exclusive boundaries, waivers that remove a condition, and referral cases that still need every other condition met.

Next: Venn Diagrams, where overlapping groups are drawn and counted.