Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 65 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Matching Definitions and Making Judgments

Learn how to match a situation to a definition and judge whether it qualifies: split the definition into required features, check each one and avoid common traps.

In a matching-definitions question you are handed a short, formal definition of some term, for example "procrastination", "outsourcing" or "plagiarism". Beneath it are several situations. Your job is to say which situation fits the definition, or whether a particular situation counts as an example.

You do not need to know the term beforehand. In fact, prior knowledge can hurt, because the definition given may be narrower or different from everyday usage. The rule is the same as in all deductive reasoning: use the definition as written and nothing else.

Break the definition into features

A definition is a bundle of conditions. Split it into separate, checkable features.

Outsourcing is the practice of a business hiring an outside organization to perform a task that it would otherwise do itself.

Features: (1) a business is involved, (2) an outside organization does the work, (3) the task is one the business would otherwise do itself.

A situation matches only if every feature is present. If a single feature is missing, or contradicted, it does not match.

The method

  1. Underline the key words in the definition, especially only, always, intentionally, without, for the purpose of.
  2. Write the features as a short list.
  3. Take each situation and tick or cross each feature.
  4. The answer is the situation with all ticks. If you must choose the best match, choose the one with the fewest crosses, but check that no cross is on a feature that the definition marks as essential.
flowchart LR
    D["Definition"] --> F["Feature list"]
    F --> T["Tick each feature<br/>for each situation"]
    T --> M["All ticks:<br/>matches"]
    T --> N["Any cross:<br/>does not match"]

Split first, then test.

Worked examples

Example 1. Definition: Delegation is the assignment of a task or authority by a person in charge to another person, who then becomes responsible for completing it.

Features: (1) the assigner is in charge, (2) a task or authority is assigned, (3) the receiver becomes responsible.

Situations:

  • A manager asks a team member to prepare the monthly report and tells her it is now hers to finish. Matches: all three features.
  • A colleague asks a friend to cover his shift because he is unwell. Does not match: the colleague is not in charge.
  • A manager writes the report himself. Does not match: nothing is assigned.

Example 2. Definition: Procrastination is voluntarily delaying an intended task, despite knowing that the delay will make things worse.

Features: (1) the delay is voluntary, (2) the task was intended, (3) the person knows delay will make things worse.

  • A student plans to revise today, watches videos until midnight, and knows this will leave too little time. Matches.
  • A student postpones revision because a relative is in hospital. Does not match: the delay is not voluntary in the intended sense, and there is no "knowing it is worse" element.
  • A student has no plan to revise at all. Does not match: the task was never intended.

Example 3 (a close call). Definition: A subsidy is a payment by a government to a producer, which lowers the price consumers pay for a product.

  • A government pays farmers a sum per tonne of wheat, and bread prices drop: matches.
  • A government taxes farmers to fund roads: does not match; money flows the other way.
  • A charity pays farmers: does not match; the payer is not a government.

Notice that Example 3 is decided by one word each time: government and producer. This is why underlining key words pays off.

Judging validity

Some questions ask: "Does the situation fit the definition? Yes, No, or Cannot say." Use these rules:

  • Yes when every feature is clearly present.
  • No when at least one feature is clearly absent or contradicted.
  • Cannot say when nothing contradicts the definition but the situation does not give information about a required feature.

Example 4. Definition: A franchise is an arrangement in which one party pays a fee to use another party's brand and business methods. Situation: "Ravi opened a cafe under a well-known coffee brand." The fee is not mentioned, so the honest answer is cannot say, unless the question tells you to assume the usual features.

JS Feature checker

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

JS Best match by score

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Traps

  • Everyday meaning beats the definition. If the text defines "bonus" as "a payment for exceeding a target", an unconditional gift is not a bonus here.
  • Near misses. Options are often built to match two of three features. Check all of them.
  • Word magic. Words like only, entirely, without exception narrow a definition sharply.
  • Intent and knowledge. Words such as intentionally and knowing require evidence of intent in the situation, not just the outcome.
  • Do not add facts. If a situation does not state a feature, do not assume it unless the question permits it.

Ask of every situation: "Which feature is it missing?" Finding the missing piece is faster than proving a match.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Definition: 'Recycling is processing used materials so they can be made into new products.' Which situation is recycling?

    Only melting cans for new cans processes used material into a new product. Reusing a jar is not processing it into a new product.
  2. 2. Definition: 'A monopoly exists when a single seller controls the entire supply of a product.' In which case does it exist?

    Only a single seller controlling all supply fits. The other options have several sellers.
  3. 3. Definition: 'Sabotage is the deliberate damage of equipment or plans to hinder a person or organization.' Which is NOT sabotage?

    A storm is not deliberate, so it lacks the key feature.
  4. 4. A situation does not mention one feature of the definition, and nothing contradicts it. The best judgment is usually:

    Without information on a required feature you cannot confirm the match, but nothing rules it out either.

Summary

  • Split the definition into features and check every one against each situation.
  • Use the definition as written, not the everyday meaning of the word.
  • A single missing or contradicted feature means no match; unknown features mean "cannot say".
  • Key words like deliberately, only and government often decide the answer.

Next: Theme Detection and Main Idea Questions.