Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 60 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Statements: Conclusions, Assumptions and Arguments

Learn to judge inferences, conclusions, assumptions, courses of action and strong or weak arguments with clear rules, the negation test and worked examples.

Syllogisms deal with made-up groups. This lesson deals with real-sounding sentences: a short paragraph about a school, a city or a company, followed by statements you must judge. Do the data support this inference? Does this conclusion follow? Which assumption is hidden inside the argument? Is the proposed action sensible? Does this new fact make an argument stronger or weaker?

All of these question families reward the same discipline: use only what the statement says, plus ordinary common sense, and no outside facts. The skill is separating what a text claims from what you happen to believe about the world. You will meet five question types, each with a rule you can apply in a few seconds, and you will practice two of them with live exercises.

The anatomy of an argument

Most passages in this lesson are small arguments. An argument has a premise (what we are told), a conclusion (what we are asked to accept), and, hidden between them, one or more assumptions (what must be true for the premise to support the conclusion).

flowchart LR
    P["Premise<br/>(stated)"] --> H["Assumption<br/>(unstated)"]
    H --> C["Conclusion<br/>(stated)"]
    P --> C
    W["New information"] -->|"supports H"| S["Strengthens"]
    W -->|"attacks H"| K["Weakens"]

New information strengthens or weakens an argument by supporting or attacking its hidden assumption.

Keep this picture in mind. Every question type below is a question about one of these boxes.

Type 1: Inference from a passage

You are given a passage and asked to rate an inference on a five-point scale.

Rating Meaning
Definitely true The passage states it, or it follows with no room for doubt.
Probably true The passage makes it likely but not certain.
Data inadequate The passage says nothing that decides it.
Probably false The passage makes it unlikely but not impossible.
Definitely false The passage contradicts it.

The rules are simple. Do not use outside knowledge. Words like all, every, always, never, only make an inference hard to accept unless the passage uses them too, because one exception breaks them. Words like some, may, likely are easy to support. If the passage gives numbers, check whether the inference needs numbers the passage does not give.

Try the exercise below. For each inference, choose a rating, then see the expected rating and the reason.

Rate the inference

Notice the pattern in the third and fifth items. When the passage gives a direction ("rose"), its opposite is definitely false. When the passage gives a total, a claim about every member is probably false or inadequate, never safely true.

Type 2: Statement and conclusion

Here a statement is followed by two or more conclusions, and you decide which follow. The rules:

  1. A conclusion follows only if it is directly supported by the statement. Not if it is merely possible, or true in the real world.
  2. A conclusion that adds a new fact, a new cause, or a stronger word (all, always) does not follow.
  3. Two conclusions that exactly contradict each other can form an either-or pair, as in Syllogisms.

Example 1. Statement: "The new bridge has cut the travel time between the two towns from 50 minutes to 30 minutes." Conclusions: I. The bridge makes travel between the two towns quicker. II. Every vehicle now takes exactly 30 minutes.

I follows: it restates what the statement says. II adds "every" and "exactly", which the statement never claims; the 30 minutes is a typical time, not a promise for each vehicle. Only I follows.

Type 3: Statement and assumption

An assumption is something the speaker takes for granted. The test is called the negation test.

Take the assumption, state its opposite, and ask: would the speaker's statement still make sense? If it collapses, the assumption is implicit.

Example 2. Statement: "The council will fit speed cameras on the ring road, since drivers slow down when they know they are being watched."

Assumption I: Drivers who know about the cameras will tend to slow down. Negate it: drivers who know about the cameras will not slow down. The reason given collapses, so I is implicit.

Assumption II: Every driver on the ring road exceeds the limit. Negate it: not every driver exceeds the limit. The plan still makes sense, so II is not implicit.

Practice the negation test on four candidates for the same statement (the first two repeat the example). Press the button on each to see the negated sentence and the verdict.

Negation test for assumptions

Two habits help here. First, a true assumption must connect the premise to the conclusion; a fact that is merely related to the topic is not an assumption. Second, assumptions are often very general ("people will read the notice", "the rule will be enforced"), and they are rarely stated with strong words like "all" or "only".

Type 4: Statement and course of action

A statement describes a problem; courses of action are steps to deal with it. A good course of action:

  • Addresses the problem in the statement, not a different one.
  • Is practical: possible for the people concerned to do.
  • Is proportionate: it does not punish everyone for one person's error, nor ignore a serious risk.
  • Is usually constructive rather than punitive (investigate, train, inspect, review).

Example 3. Statement: "Several customers have complained that the pharmacy's online orders arrive with the wrong labels." Courses of action: I. The pharmacy should review its labeling process. II. The pharmacy should close its online store permanently.

I follows: it addresses the cause. II is extreme and out of proportion. Only I follows.

flowchart TD
    A["Course of action"] --> B{"Does it address<br/>the stated problem?"}
    B -->|"No"| X["Does not follow"]
    B -->|"Yes"| C{"Practical and<br/>proportionate?"}
    C -->|"No"| X
    C -->|"Yes"| Y["Follows"]

Two questions decide a course of action: does it fit the problem, and is it sensible in size?

Course of action in depth

In the exam, a statement is followed by two or three numbered courses of action, and you choose which follow. Sort every course into one of these groups before deciding.

Kind of course Usually follows? Why
Investigates or reviews the cause Yes Addresses the problem without assuming blame
Fixes the stated fault directly (repair, train, inspect) Yes Practical and proportionate
Informs or warns the people affected Yes, if the problem is a risk Reduces harm quickly
Punishes everyone for one person's mistake No Disproportionate
Shuts down or abandons the whole activity No Extreme, unless the statement describes a grave and ongoing danger
Solves a different problem than the one stated No Not connected
Says "do nothing" or "wait" Rarely Only when the statement says the problem will fix itself

Two more rules help with close calls.

  • Match the verb to the facts. If the statement says "reports suggest" a fault, a course of action that says "arrest the manager" jumps ahead of the facts, while "inquire into the reports" fits.
  • Some courses are mutually exclusive. If I says "increase the fee" and II says "lower the fee", at most one can follow; the exam may then ask for "either I or II".

Example 3b. Statement: "Several villages along the river were flooded after the embankment gave way, though engineers had warned it was weak." I. The authorities should repair the embankment immediately. II. The authorities should relocate all river-side villages permanently within a week. III. An inquiry should find out why the warning was not acted on.

I addresses the cause and is practical. III is constructive. II is extreme and impractical in a week. Only I and III follow.

Example 3c. Statement: "Many commuters say the 8 a.m. train is overcrowded." I. The railway should add coaches to that train. II. Commuters should be fined for traveling at 8 a.m. Only I follows: II blames the victims and punishes a harmless behavior.

Type 5: Strengthening and weakening arguments

Here you are given an argument and a new fact. Does the fact make the conclusion more likely (strengthen), less likely (weaken), or leave it unchanged? The method follows directly from the diagram earlier: find the assumption, then see whether the new fact supports or attacks it.

Example 4. Argument: "Since the bakery began playing slow music, its customers have stayed longer and spent more. So slow music causes customers to spend more."

The hidden assumption is that the music, and not something else, caused the change.

  • Strengthens: "Customers also stayed longer in a second bakery when it began playing slow music."
  • Weakens: "At the same time the first bakery started serving coffee at its tables."
  • Neutral: "The bakery opens at 7 a.m."

The common weakening patterns are: another cause exists, the sample is small or unrepresentative, the comparison is unfair, or the assumed link is missing. The common strengthening patterns are the mirror images: other causes are ruled out, the sample is large and typical, a similar case shows the same effect.

Example 5. Argument: "A survey of 20 members of a gym found that 18 prefer morning classes, so most people in the city prefer morning classes."

The weakness is the sample. Information that the 20 people were all early-shift workers weakens the conclusion; information that a random survey of 2,000 residents gave the same result strengthens it.

Strong and weak arguments

A related format asks whether an argument offered for or against a proposal is strong or weak. A strong argument is important, directly related to the proposal, and based on facts. A weak argument is vague, based on opinion or example, or about something else. "Should students use maps on phones? Yes, because maps are colorful" is weak: color is not a relevant reason. "Yes, because phone maps update routes in real time" is strong.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Passage: 'A town replaced its streetlights with LED lamps and its electricity bill for lighting fell by 40 percent.' Inference: 'The town spent less on lighting electricity after the change.' This inference is:

    The passage states directly that the electricity bill for lighting fell, so the inference is definitely true.
  2. 2. Statement: 'The company will give all drivers a refresher course, since many recent accidents happened because drivers ignored speed limits.' Which is an implicit assumption?

    Negate B: a course cannot improve attention to limits. Then giving the course makes no sense, so B is implicit. The others use all, never or add cost, which the statement does not rely on.
  3. 3. Statement: 'Pupils in a school keep forgetting to hand in homework on time.' Course of action I: 'The school should introduce a homework planner.' II: 'The school should stop setting homework.' Which follows?

    A planner addresses the problem in a practical, proportionate way. Stopping homework removes the task rather than solving the forgetting, and is out of proportion.
  4. 4. Argument: 'Shops that put flowers at their entrance get more customers, so a shop should put flowers at its entrance to get more customers.' Which new fact weakens it most?

    If the flower shops were all on the busiest street, the customers may have come because of the location, not the flowers. That attacks the assumption that flowers are the cause.
  5. 5. In the negation test for an assumption, you should:

    If the statement collapses when the assumption is negated, the assumption is implicit. The test does not depend on real-life truth or on the wording appearing in the passage.

Summary

  • Judge only from the passage plus ordinary common sense, never from outside facts.
  • For inference questions, strong words (all, every, only) are hard to support; an inference that reverses a stated direction is definitely false.
  • A conclusion follows only when the statement directly supports it.
  • Use the negation test for assumptions: if the opposite makes the statement collapse, the assumption is implicit.
  • A good course of action fits the problem and is practical and proportionate.
  • New information strengthens or weakens an argument by supporting or attacking its hidden assumption.

Next: Venn Diagrams and Set Problems, where circles move from logic to counting.