Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 29 of 86 Β· Time, Speed, Distance and Work

Chain Rule and Work-Wages

Master the chain rule for men, days, hours and work, plus equivalent-worker and daily-wage problems, with a step-by-step method and a runnable solver.

Suppose 15 men dig a 30 metre trench in 12 days working 8 hours a day. How many days will 20 men need to dig a 50 metre trench if they only work 6 hours a day? Nothing here is hard, but four quantities change at once, and guessing which ones to multiply and which to divide is where marks are lost. The chain rule (also called compound proportion) is a method that removes the guessing.

The idea is simple: every quantity either rises together with the unknown (direct) or moves the opposite way (inverse). Once you have labelled each one, the answer is a single product of ratios. In this lesson you will learn the method, practice it on men-days-hours problems and food-supply problems, then extend it to workers of different efficiency and to wages. The single-job rates behind this are in Time and Work, and the idea of direct and inverse variation is in Proportion and Variation.

The method

Write the data in two rows, one for the known case and one for the new case. Then for each quantity ask: "If this quantity increases, does the unknown increase (direct) or decrease (inverse)?"

Quantity Relation to days needed
More men Fewer days (inverse)
More hours per day Fewer days (inverse)
More work (metres, items) More days (direct)
Faster workers (more efficiency) Fewer days (inverse)

For each quantity multiply the unknown by the ratio new / old if it is direct, and by old / new if it is inverse. Another way to say it: put the quantities that make the job bigger over the quantities that do the job. This equivalent form is the one most people remember:

(men₁ Γ— days₁ Γ— hours₁) / work₁ = (menβ‚‚ Γ— daysβ‚‚ Γ— hoursβ‚‚) / workβ‚‚

Here men Γ— days Γ— hours is the capacity (total man-hours), and dividing by the work gives the man-hours needed for one unit of work. That number does not change if the workers are equally skilled, so it can be equated across the two cases.

Example 1 (the trench). 15 men Γ— 12 days Γ— 8 hours = 1,440 man-hours for 30 m, which is 48 man-hours per metre. For 50 m we need 2,400 man-hours. The new crew supplies 20 men Γ— 6 hours = 120 man-hours a day, so they need 2,400 / 120 = 20 days.

flowchart TD
    A["Write the known case and the new case"] --> B["For each quantity: direct or inverse to the unknown?"]
    B --> C["Direct: multiply by new / old"]
    B --> D["Inverse: multiply by old / new"]
    C --> E["Multiply all ratios together"]
    D --> E
    E --> F["Check the answer is sensible: more help should mean less time"]

Decide direct or inverse for each quantity separately; never for the whole problem at once.

Food supply and similar "stock" problems

A fixed stock of something is used up at a rate that depends on how many people use it and how much each uses. The capacity idea is the same: people Γ— days Γ— daily ration = total stock.

Example 2. A hostel has food for 200 students for 30 days. After 10 days, 50 students leave. How long will the remaining food last the rest of the students? After 10 days the food is for 200 students for 20 more days. With 150 students, the food lasts 200 Γ— 20 / 150 = 26.67 days, which is about 26 days 16 hours.

Example 3. The same hostel doubles each student's daily ration. With the original 30-day stock for 200 students, the stock now lasts 30 / 2 = 15 days. Inverse ratios combine: if students rise by 25% (Γ—1.25) and each eats 20% more (Γ—1.2), the stock lasts 30 / (1.25 Γ— 1.2) = 20 days.

Workers of different efficiency

When workers are not equal, convert them to a common unit first.

Example 4. If 8 men do the same work as 12 women, then 1 woman = 2/3 of a man. A job takes 10 men 18 days (180 man-days). How long will 6 men and 12 women take? The 12 women equal 8 men, so the crew equals 6 + 8 = 14 men, and the time is 180 / 14 = 12 6/7 days (about 12.86).

For three types, a statement such as "2 men = 3 women = 5 boys" gives men : women : boys efficiency as 1/2 : 1/3 : 1/5, which scales to 15 : 10 : 6 (multiply by 30). Use these as unit speeds, add what is working, and divide the total work.

Work and wages

A wage is just a rate of pay per worker per day (or hour). The total cost of a job is total worker-days Γ— wage per worker-day, so wage problems are chain-rule problems with one extra quantity, the pay, which is direct to the total cost.

Example 5. A contractor pays 1,350 per day to 5 men and 6 women, and a man earns 1.5 times a woman's wage. If a woman earns w, then 5(1.5w) + 6w = 13.5w = 1,350, so a woman earns 100 and a man 150 per day. The cost of employing 8 men and 10 women for 12 days is (8 Γ— 150 + 10 Γ— 100) Γ— 12 = 2,200 Γ— 12 = 26,400.

Example 6 (different days). Two groups finish a job together but one works fewer days. If A earns 200 a day and works 9 days, and B earns 150 a day and works 12 days, they split a fixed payment in the ratio of earnings 1,800 : 1,800 = 1 : 1. Always multiply daily wage Γ— days for each person before comparing.

When a problem says the wages are "in proportion to the work done", the shares depend on work, not on time. When it gives daily wages, shares depend on wage Γ— days. Read which one applies before calculating.

A chain-rule solver

The solver below takes a list of quantities, each marked direct or inverse, and reproduces the worked examples. Add your own rows to practice.

JS Chain rule solver

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The second tool handles wages. It solves for the unknown wage, then prices several crews.

JS Wage problems

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Check your understanding

Quick check Β· 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 Β· perfect!

  1. 1. 15 men working 8 hours a day dig 30 m of trench in 12 days. How many days do 20 men working 6 hours a day need to dig 50 m?

    Man-hours per metre = 15 x 12 x 8 / 30 = 48. For 50 m: 2,400 man-hours. The new crew does 20 x 6 = 120 per day, so 2,400 / 120 = 20 days.
  2. 2. Food lasts 200 students for 20 more days. After some leave, 150 remain. For how many days does it last?

    Fewer students means more days (inverse): 20 x 200 / 150 = 26.67 days.
  3. 3. 8 men do the same work as 12 women. A job takes 10 men 18 days. How many days will 6 men and 12 women take?

    12 women = 8 men, so the crew equals 14 men. The work is 180 man-days, and 180 / 14 = 12 6/7 days.
  4. 4. In the chain rule, a quantity that makes the job take FEWER days when it increases is:

    If more of the quantity shortens the time, it is inverse to days, so the ratio is flipped to old / new.
  5. 5. A man earns 1.5 times a woman's wage, and 5 men plus 6 women cost 1,350 a day. What does a woman earn per day?

    5(1.5w) + 6w = 13.5w = 1,350, so w = 100 (and a man earns 150).

Summary

  • Label every quantity as direct or inverse to the unknown, then multiply the matching ratios.
  • Equivalent form: (men Γ— days Γ— hours) / work is the same in every case when workers are equally skilled.
  • Stock problems (food, fuel) use people Γ— days Γ— ration = stock.
  • Convert unequal workers (men, women, boys) into one unit before applying the rule.
  • Cost of a job = total worker-days Γ— wage per worker-day; shares of a fixed payment follow wage Γ— days, or work done when stated.

Next: Pipes and Cisterns, where filling and emptying rates are added and subtracted like workers.