Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 64 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Assertion and Reason Questions

Learn how assertion and reason questions work: the standard answer options, a two-step method to judge truth and explanation, worked examples and common traps.

An assertion and reason question gives you two statements. The first, the Assertion (A), makes a claim. The second, the Reason (R), is offered as the explanation for it. You are not asked whether you like the claim. You are asked two separate things: is each statement true, and does R actually explain A?

The format is common in science and reasoning papers because it tests two skills at once: knowing a fact and understanding why it holds. This lesson teaches the usual answer options, a two-step method that avoids the classic mistakes, and a script that turns your judgments into the right option.

The standard options

Papers word them slightly differently, but the structure is almost always this:

Option Meaning
a Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
b Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
c A is true, but R is false
d A is false, but R is true

Some papers add a fifth option, "both A and R are false". Always read the exact wording in your paper; the method does not change.

The two-step method

Step 1: judge each statement on its own. Cover R and decide whether A is true. Then cover A and decide whether R is true. Do this separately, so a plausible-sounding pairing does not influence you.

Step 2: only if both are true, test the explanation. Put the word because between them: "A, because R." Does it read as a real cause or reason, or does it feel like two unrelated facts? If R is the cause, choose (a). If not, choose (b).

flowchart TD
    S["Read A and R"] --> A{"Is A true?"}
    A -->|"Yes"| R1{"Is R true?"}
    A -->|"No"| R2{"Is R true?"}
    R1 -->|"No"| C["Option c"]
    R1 -->|"Yes"| E{"Does R explain A?"}
    E -->|"Yes"| OA["Option a"]
    E -->|"No"| OB["Option b"]
    R2 -->|"Yes"| OD["Option d"]
    R2 -->|"No"| OE["Both false"]

Two truth checks first, then the explanation check.

Worked examples

Example 1. A: Ice floats on water. R: Ice is less dense than liquid water.

Both are true. Does density explain floating? Yes: an object less dense than a liquid floats in it. Answer (a).

Example 2. A: Cricket is played with a bat and a ball. R: A cricket pitch is 22 yards long.

Both are true, but the pitch length does not explain the bat and ball. Answer (b).

Example 3. A: Water boils at a lower temperature on a high mountain. R: Air pressure is higher at high altitude.

A is true. R is false: air pressure is lower at altitude, and that lower pressure is exactly why water boils at a lower temperature. Answer (c).

Example 4. A: Every even number is divisible by 4. R: Every even number is divisible by 2.

A is false (6 is even but not divisible by 4). R is true. Answer (d).

Checking a numerical pair

Example 5. A: The sum of the first 10 positive integers is 55. R: The sum of the first n positive integers is n(n + 1)/2.

For n = 10 the formula gives 10 ร— 11 / 2 = 55, so both statements are true and the formula is the reason for the sum. Answer (a).

Example 6. A: A train 150 m long passes a pole in 10 seconds, so its speed is 15 m/s. R: The distance covered in passing a pole equals the length of the train.

150 / 10 = 15 m/s, so A is true. R is true and explains why the length is the distance to use. Answer (a).

JS Option finder

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

JS Test a numerical assertion

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Common traps

  • Two true statements are not automatically linked. Test the "because" reading before choosing (a).
  • A true reason can be a different reason. "Plants are green because chlorophyll absorbs red and blue light" is fine; "because they like sunlight" is not.
  • Extreme words (always, never, all, only) often make a statement false. Look for a single counterexample.
  • R can be a true statement that is merely related. Relatedness is not explanation.
  • Do not skip to the explanation. If A is false, the question is already decided between (d) and "both false".

If you are unsure whether R is the explanation, imagine R were false. If A would then lose its support, R is probably the reason. If A would stay just as true, R is only an extra fact.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A: A magnet attracts iron nails. R: Iron is a magnetic material. Which option fits?

    Iron being magnetic is exactly why a magnet attracts iron nails.
  2. 2. A: The Sun rises in the west. R: The Earth rotates from west to east. Which option fits?

    The Sun appears to rise in the east, so A is false. Earth does rotate from west to east, so R is true.
  3. 3. A: 17 is a prime number. R: 17 has exactly two factors, 1 and 17. Which option fits?

    Having exactly two factors is the definition of a prime, so R explains A.
  4. 4. A: A square of side 6 cm has area 36 cm squared. R: A triangle has three sides. Which option fits?

    Both statements are true, but the number of sides of a triangle has nothing to do with the area of a square.
  5. 5. What is the correct order of the method?

    Judge A and R independently first. The explanation test matters only when both are true.

Summary

  • Assertion and reason questions test two things: whether each statement is true, and whether R explains A.
  • Judge A and R separately, then test "A because R" only when both are true.
  • Both true gives (a) or (b); A true and R false gives (c); A false and R true gives (d).
  • Watch for extreme words, true-but-unrelated reasons and numerical claims you can quickly verify.

Next: Matching Definitions and Making Judgments.