Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 59 of 86 ยท Deductive and Analytical Reasoning

Logical Deduction and Deductive Reasoning

Learn deductive reasoning for aptitude tests: how premises lead to certain conclusions, chains of if-then rules, elimination, and common traps, with worked questions.

Deductive reasoning is the kind of thinking where the answer is forced. If the premises are true, the conclusion cannot be false. A detective who says "the thief used the back door, only the cook has a key to it, so the cook is the thief" is deducing, as long as the first two facts are true.

Aptitude tests love this style because there is exactly one defensible answer and you can find it with a method rather than a hunch. In this lesson you will learn what makes a deduction valid, how to chain rules together, how to use elimination, and which traps catch most candidates. You already know the formal tools in Syllogisms and Logical Connectives and Truth Statements; here we apply them to everyday-sounding passages.

Deduction versus induction

  • Deduction moves from general rules to a certain conclusion: "All metals expand when heated. Copper is a metal. So copper expands when heated."
  • Induction moves from examples to a likely rule: "Every swan I have seen is white, so swans are probably white." The conclusion is only probable.

In a deduction question you must treat the premises as true, even if they sound odd. "All birds can swim. A sparrow is a bird. So a sparrow can swim" is a valid deduction, because the conclusion follows from the premises. It is not sound, because the first premise is false in the real world. Reasoning tests almost always ask about validity: does the conclusion follow?

The three-step routine

  1. List the premises in short form. Replace sentences with letters or arrows.
  2. Combine them by chaining, by contrapositive or by elimination (see below).
  3. Test each option against only what you derived. If an option needs an extra fact, it does not follow.

Chaining rules

If A leads to B and B leads to C, then A leads to C. Write rules as arrows and follow them.

Example 1. Premises: Every student who finishes the lab report may borrow a laptop (R โ†’ L). Everyone who may borrow a laptop must sign the register (L โ†’ S). Priya finished the lab report. What follows?

R โ†’ L โ†’ S, so Priya may borrow a laptop and must sign the register.

The reverse is not allowed. "Neha signed the register" does not tell you she finished the report: signing is only the end of the chain, and other routes may lead to it.

Using the contrapositive

Every rule A โ†’ B has an equivalent form: not B โ†’ not A. If a premise says "whoever is on the team passed the fitness test" and Arjun did not pass, he is not on the team. Use the contrapositive whenever a question gives you a negative fact.

Elimination

Many deduction questions give a closed set of possibilities and several clues that remove options.

Example 2. Three friends, Anil, Bela and Chitra, each own one pet: a dog, a cat or a parrot. Anil is allergic to fur. Bela's pet is not the cat. Who owns what?

Anil's allergy rules out dog and cat, so Anil owns the parrot. Bela is not the cat owner and the parrot is taken, so Bela owns the dog. Chitra owns the cat.

The technique is always the same: cross out what is impossible and see what is forced.

A rule chaser you can run

The first script below stores a list of rules and a list of known facts, then keeps applying the rules until nothing new appears. It is the machine version of what you do on paper.

JS Chain the rules

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Deduction with numbers

Deductions often hide arithmetic. Keep the same discipline: use only what you are told.

Example 3. A library has 120 books. Every book is either fiction or non-fiction. Fiction books are exactly 3 times as many as non-fiction. How many are fiction?

Let non-fiction = x. Then fiction = 3x and 3x + x = 120, so x = 30 and fiction = 90.

Example 4. Every member of a club plays chess or cricket (or both). 18 play chess, 14 play cricket, and 6 play both. How many members are there? Count each group once: 18 + 14 โˆ’ 6 = 26. A claim such as "at least 12 members play only cricket" can be checked too: only cricket = 14 โˆ’ 6 = 8, so the claim is false.

JS Check a deduction with a case search

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

Traps to avoid

  • Reversing an if-then. "All A are B" does not mean "all B are A."
  • Using outside knowledge. If the passage says a lion is a herbivore, accept it for the question.
  • Hidden extra premises. An option that is plausible is not an option that follows.
  • Overreading "some." "Some doctors are teachers" says nothing about doctors who are not teachers.
  • Confusing "only" with "all". "Only members may enter" means entry โ†’ member, not member โ†’ entry.

When two options both look possible, ask which one needs an extra assumption. The option that needs none is the deduction.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 5 questions

of 5 answered You scored / 5 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. Premises: All tutors are graduates. Some graduates are musicians. Which conclusion must be true?

    The musicians who are graduates might not be tutors, so 'some tutors are musicians' is only possible. None of the first three is forced.
  2. 2. Rule: If the alarm rings, the guard checks the door. The guard did not check the door. What follows?

    The contrapositive of 'alarm rings then guard checks' is 'guard does not check then alarm did not ring'.
  3. 3. A deduction is called valid when:

    Validity is about the link between premises and conclusion, not about whether the premises are really true.
  4. 4. A bag holds 60 coins, all either gold or silver. There are twice as many silver as gold coins. How many gold coins are there?

    Gold = x, silver = 2x, so 3x = 60 and x = 20.
  5. 5. Which statement is the contrapositive of 'Every winner got a medal'?

    From 'winner โ†’ medal' the equivalent form is 'no medal โ†’ not a winner'. The first option is the converse, which is not equivalent.

Summary

  • Deduction gives certain conclusions; induction gives probable ones.
  • Judge validity from the premises alone, even if they seem false in real life.
  • Chain rules (A โ†’ B โ†’ C) forwards only; use the contrapositive for negative facts.
  • Use elimination for closed sets: cross out the impossible and see what is forced.
  • A conclusion that needs an extra assumption does not follow.

Next: Statements: Conclusions, Assumptions and Arguments.