Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 14 of 37 ยท Demand and Supply

Price Ceilings and Price Floors

Learn how maximum and minimum prices affect markets: binding versus non-binding controls, shortages, surpluses, deadweight loss and who gains or loses.

Sometimes a government decides that the equilibrium price is unfair or too painful for one group. Instead of waiting for the market to adjust, it sets a legal limit on the price. This lesson shows what such limits do, using only the demand and supply tools you already know.

Two kinds of price control

  • A price ceiling is a legal maximum price. It is meant to protect buyers. Rent control and caps on the price of some medicines are examples.
  • A price floor is a legal minimum price. It is meant to protect sellers. A minimum wage is a floor on the price of labor, and some countries support farm prices with floors.

Whether a control matters depends on where it is set compared with the equilibrium price.

Price ceilings

We use the demand and supply from the previous lessons: Qd = 1400 - 100P, Qs = -200 + 100P, with the equilibrium at P = 8 and Q = 600. Treat the market as monthly rented rooms in a town (units are invented).

A ceiling above equilibrium (say at 10) has no effect. The price can reach 8 and still be legal. This is a non-binding ceiling.

A ceiling below equilibrium (say at 6) is binding. At P = 6:

  • Quantity demanded: 1400 - 600 = 800.
  • Quantity supplied: -200 + 600 = 400.
  • There is a shortage of 400 rooms.

Since sellers will only provide 400, only 400 rooms are traded. In a free market the shortage would raise the price, but the law forbids that.

Consequences of a binding ceiling

  • Shortages. More people want to rent than there are rooms.
  • Non-price rationing. Without a price to ration goods, other methods appear: queues, waiting lists, connections or favoritism.
  • Lower quality. Owners may spend less on maintenance because they can always rent the room.
  • Black markets. Illegal side payments may push the real price above the legal maximum.
  • Who gains? Lucky tenants who find a room pay less. Who loses? People who cannot find a room, and owners.

Price floors

A floor below equilibrium (say at 6) is non-binding. The market price 8 is already higher.

A floor above equilibrium (say at 10) is binding. At P = 10:

  • Quantity demanded: 1400 - 1000 = 400.
  • Quantity supplied: -200 + 1000 = 800.
  • There is a surplus of 400.

Only 400 units are actually sold, because buyers will not buy more. Sellers want to sell 800.

Consequences of a binding floor

  • Surpluses. Unsold goods or, in the labor market, unemployment. The government may buy the surplus, which costs taxpayers money.
  • Lost sales for some sellers. Those who sell get a higher price; others sell nothing.
  • Waste. Resources are drawn to producing goods nobody wants at that price.
Python Test a price control

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Deadweight loss

When a control stops trades that would have benefited both sides, society loses. The lost gains are called deadweight loss. On the demand and supply graph it is a triangle.

For a binding ceiling at 6 the traded quantity is 400 instead of 600. At Q = 400, buyers would be willing to pay as much as 10 (from the demand curve) but sellers would be content with 6 (from the supply curve). That 4-dollar gap is the gain from trade that does not happen. The triangle has height 4 and base 600 - 400 = 200, so its area is 0.5 ร— 200 ร— 4 = 400 dollars per month. The same arithmetic gives 400 for the floor at 10, since traded quantity falls from 600 to 400 again.

JS Deadweight loss

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the console output here.

No output.

The numbers come from our invented curves, but the method works with any straight-line curves.

flowchart TD
  A["Price control"] --> B{"Binding?"}
  B -->|"No"| C["No effect on market"]
  B -->|"Ceiling below equilibrium"| D["Shortage and rationing"]
  B -->|"Floor above equilibrium"| E["Surplus and waste"]

A control matters only if it lies on the wrong side of equilibrium.

Real-world discussion

Economists often point to the shortage and quality effects of rent controls and the unemployment effects of high price floors. Yet the real world adds complications: some controls are exempt for new housing, some labor markets have employers with power over wages, and some groups clearly gain from the control. Evidence is mixed, and whether to use controls also involves fairness, a normative issue (see positive and normative statements).

How strongly quantities react depends on how responsive buyers and sellers are to price. That responsiveness is called elasticity, the topic of the next chapter, starting with price elasticity of demand.

A control that is set at the equilibrium price or on the "right" side of it does nothing. Always compare the legal price with the market equilibrium before drawing conclusions.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A price ceiling set below the equilibrium price causes

    At the lower price quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied.
  2. 2. In our example a floor at 10 gives Qd = 400 and Qs = 800. How many units are traded?

    Trade is limited by the smaller side of the market, which is buyers at 400.
  3. 3. A price ceiling set above equilibrium is

    The market price is already below the legal maximum, so the ceiling has no effect.
  4. 4. A minimum wage set above the equilibrium wage is an example of

    Wage is the price of labor, and a minimum above equilibrium is a binding floor that may cause a surplus of labor.

Summary

  • A ceiling is a maximum price, a floor is a minimum price.
  • Only controls on the wrong side of equilibrium are binding: ceilings below it, floors above it.
  • Binding ceilings cause shortages; binding floors cause surpluses.
  • Controls reduce the quantity traded and create deadweight loss, though some people gain.

Next: Price Elasticity of Demand