Skip to content
Tutorials Center
My learning

Topics

Lesson 30 of 37 ยท Market Failure and Government

Price Controls and Taxes: Who Really Pays?

Analyze price ceilings, price floors and per-unit taxes with demand and supply: shortages, surpluses, tax incidence and deadweight loss, with runnable models.

Governments often step into markets. They cap rents, set minimum prices for farm goods, and tax cigarettes, fuel and sales. The goals can be fair or even essential, but the tools have side effects that follow directly from supply and demand. This lesson uses a single market to trace those effects.

Let the demand for a good be Qd = 100 - 2P and the supply Qs = 20 + 2P (quantities in thousands, prices in dollars). Equilibrium is where Qd = Qs: 100 - 2P = 20 + 2P, so P = 20 and Q = 60.

Price ceilings

A price ceiling is a legal maximum price. It only matters if it is below the equilibrium price. Suppose a city caps the price at $15.

  • Quantity demanded: 100 - 30 = 70.
  • Quantity supplied: 20 + 30 = 50.
  • Shortage: 70 - 50 = 20 thousand units.

Only 50 units are traded (the short side of the market sets the quantity). Side effects: queues and waiting lists, black markets with prices above the cap, lower quality (sellers cut costs), and allocation by connections instead of price. Rent control is the standard example: the capped rent helps tenants who find an apartment but can reduce the supply and quality of housing over time.

A ceiling set above the equilibrium price (say $25) does nothing.

Price floors

A price floor is a legal minimum price, binding only if above equilibrium. Suppose farmers are guaranteed at least $25.

  • Quantity supplied: 20 + 50 = 70.
  • Quantity demanded: 100 - 50 = 50.
  • Surplus: 70 - 50 = 20 thousand units.

Producers want to sell 70 but buyers want only 50. The government might buy up the surplus (costing taxpayers), or farmers get quotas, or goods are wasted. A minimum wage is a price floor in the labor market (see the labor lessons).

Python Shortages and surpluses from price controls

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Taxes and tax incidence

A tax of $8 per unit is imposed on sellers. For every price buyers pay, sellers receive $8 less, so the supply curve shifts up by 8. The new supply is Qs = 20 + 2(P - 8) = 4 + 2P.

Solve 100 - 2P = 4 + 2P: 4P = 96, P = 24, Q = 52.

  • Buyers now pay $24 (up from 20): they bear $4 of the tax.
  • Sellers receive 24 - 8 = $16 (down from 20): they bear $4.
  • Quantity falls from 60 to 52.
  • Tax revenue: 8 ร— 52 = 416.

The incidence of a tax is who bears it in reality, regardless of who is legally charged. A very important result: incidence does not depend on who writes the check. If the tax were collected from buyers, the outcome would be the same.

What matters is relative elasticity. The side of the market that is less elastic (less able to walk away) bears more of the tax. Here the demand slope and the supply slope are equal in size, so the burden splits evenly. Tobacco has inelastic demand, so smokers bear most of a cigarette tax.

Python Who bears a per-unit tax?

Press Run (or Ctrl + Enter) to see the result here.

Program input ยท what you'd type while the program runs

Type the answers before you press Run, one per line. Each time the program reads a line (with input()), it gets the next line from this box.

Deadweight loss of a tax

A tax makes some mutually beneficial trades disappear: units between 52 and 60 are worth more to buyers than they cost to produce, but are no longer traded. The lost surplus is the triangle with base 60 - 52 = 8 and height equal to the tax 8: ยฝ ร— 8 ร— 8 = 32. The loss grows with the square of the tax rate, so doubling a tax roughly quadruples the deadweight loss. This is why economists prefer broad, low-rate taxes to a few very high ones. The exception is a tax that corrects an externality: it removes a distortion instead of creating one.

Subsidies

A per-unit subsidy is a negative tax. It lowers the price buyers pay, raises the price sellers receive and increases quantity, with a cost to the budget. It helps when there is a positive externality, otherwise it can encourage overproduction.

Other effects of intervention

  • Controls often help some people (tenants with an apartment, farmers selling at the floor) while hurting others (new renters, consumers, taxpayers).
  • Efficiency is not the only goal; societies also care about fairness. Economists point out the trade-offs and, where possible, suggest alternatives, such as direct cash support instead of price caps.

Check your understanding

Quick check ยท 4 questions

of 4 answered You scored / 4 ยท perfect!

  1. 1. A price ceiling below the equilibrium price causes

    At the low price, quantity demanded is above quantity supplied.
  2. 2. A price floor above equilibrium

    Producers supply more at the high price while buyers demand less.
  3. 3. Who bears more of a per-unit tax?

    The side with fewer alternatives cannot easily walk away and ends up with the larger burden.
  4. 4. If a tax rate doubles, the deadweight loss roughly

    The loss is a triangle whose base and height both grow with the tax, so its area grows with the square.

Summary

  • A binding ceiling causes a shortage; a binding floor causes a surplus; non-binding controls do nothing.
  • A per-unit tax raises the buyer's price, lowers the seller's, and reduces quantity.
  • Incidence depends on elasticities, not on who legally pays.
  • The deadweight loss of a tax grows with the square of the rate.

Next: Asymmetric Information